Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Post-Covid may pit individualism against nationalism, person against company

Individualism and nationalism can coexist In fact, they depend on each other

This might sound strange at first, but it’s an undeniable fact.

An individual who is strong enough doesn’t need the state, but an individual is weaker than a group in almost every case. Push individualism far enough and it splits the masses into a small number of gorillas who can easily fight alone as individuals and a majority of sheep who cannot fight alone. Only the state can support a large number of sheep lined up together. Everyone senses this, so they lean toward nationalism.

For those who want a more detailed explanation, see this.

https://www.clazytech.com/2020/10/369/

The fragmentation caused by COVID is expected to considerably weaken the power of employment to form groups. No — it has already begun.

Since I was young, I strongly believed “it would be great if lifetime employment just disappeared.” That belief itself hasn’t changed even now, but with age it has softened into “it’s just that I personally don’t need it.” Put simply, I’ve come to accept that there are business forms that require lifetime employment, and scenes where lifetime employment should exist. In other words, there are “weak individuals” within economic activity. (To everyone who put up with my prickly younger self — thank you for bearing with me. Look how fine an adult I’ve turned into! Ha.)

From a career perspective, a clear and easy example of a weak individual is someone who, intentionally or not, has been “put in long-term charge of running a siloed department that is itself siloed.” Such a person carries extremely high risk. For instance, if some change occurs in the business environment (a change of management, a drastic deterioration in profits, an acquisition, etc.) and the company decides to break up that silo, that person becomes useless in any other department. As long as the silo exists, their position is actually secure — but there’s no telling when that silo might collapse. In this case, if lifetime employment properly exercises its intended function, the logic runs:

But suppose, hypothetically, that individualism is strongly emphasized here instead. Then the logic becomes:

Individuals bear the responsibility of building their own careers, and a company so lacking in understanding that it needlessly restricts an individual’s career advancement is unacceptable. Everyone should just leave such a company. The company itself deserves to eventually be weeded out by the churn of this fluid society.

So how persuasive is this line of reasoning?

In my twenties, it was fully persuasive to me. In fact, by setting my own turning points at my own pace, I took losses, got burned, stumbled through trial and error, and carved out my own career — and I have almost no memory of relying on a company from a career standpoint (my apologies to everyone involved for this attitude). “Never let someone else hold the power of life and death over you.” I wanted overseas experience, and when it seemed the company wasn’t going to send me, I quit and moved to America on my own. During a period when I wasn’t in a department that did real product planning, I drew up product plans on my own private time and pushed them up the chain myself (apologies again to everyone involved). Even now I’m essentially independent, so whether my career withers or flourishes is entirely my own responsibility. As it should be.

This is a fairly unusual stance (my apologies again, to various people, for various things).

There are tens of millions of people in Japan who are employed in some form. How many of them would agree with the position above?

Thinking about it soberly, I suspect most people’s reaction would be something like, “I understand what you’re saying, but emotionally, it feels hard.”

But if an “after COVID” era arrives smoothly, there’s a very high chance that everyone will be forced to agree with the above regardless.

As remote work becomes the norm, companies lose (or are relieved of) several of the general obligations they have toward employees. For instance, having an office may no longer be a given. The level of benefits aimed at promoting employees’ health is also likely to decline. Companies will likely stop functioning well as places for socializing and expanding one’s network. Even where companies are expected to function as sites of employee education, the effectiveness of that is likely to become limited. In other words, employees will likely be told it’s simply normal to secure their own workspace, manage their own health, build their own networks on personal time, and plan and design their own skill development on personal time as well.

Long live individualism.

So once individualism has strengthened this way, what kind of social movements will emerge?

Will a vibrant society arrive in which individuals stand on their own and freely build their careers? Will individuals become better able to contribute to the economy by flexibly using their personal time to build networks and develop skills untethered to any company?

No — I think individuals will instead start saying to companies, “Take better care of us.”

Why? Because this is an already-proven template playing out between the state and the individual. When individuals are prioritized, the group weakens, and the group loses its motivation to contribute to individuals. The group then stops functioning as a foundation that supports the individual. In the end, the only group left that can be trusted is the state. It’s a logic that’s reached almost by process of elimination.

A company functions as a combination of multiple groups — project teams, divisions, business units, and so on. What does it mean for these to weaken? For example, when I joined my company fresh out of graduate school, frankly, I didn’t even know how to use a soldering iron properly. I was a useless know-it-all with nothing but theory. I was overwhelmingly short on practical knowledge of components, and I had no idea how to handle conversations with outside vendors. But during that period, senior colleagues close to my age, mentors, and veteran old hands taught me all sorts of things. That is the strength of a group. Shift the view to individual life, and this is the beautiful, tenement-style supportive world in which relatives and neighbors all pitch in to look after a toddling baby. Unfortunately, that kind of world is already lost. As a result, raising children has gotten harder. And to compensate, people now call for solutions at the national and municipal level — child allowances, city-run daycare, free after-hours childcare at kindergartens, and so on. In truth, much smaller groups should have been able to solve this. It’s proof that groups have weakened.

It’s strikingly the same. The same thing happens.

As individualism strengthens, companies start demanding strong results from individuals. They come to value outcomes over process (since process can no longer be monitored anyway, outcomes are all that’s left to look at). Individuals start demanding compensation from the company commensurate with results. The company responds by raising the workload. Individuals’ personal time shrinks. There’s no time left for skill development or networking. Individuals start demanding some kind of guarantee from the company. Since the company has less inclination to hold onto employees, about all it can offer is some temporary financial benefit. It demands results commensurate with pay. The workload rises. Time runs out. The employee demands some response from the company. The company says, sure, we can do that, but we’ll cut your pay accordingly, won’t we? The employee grits their teeth and endures the load. In the end there’s still no time. They consider quitting. Their skills haven’t grown, so changing jobs is hard. They’re stuck choosing between continuing to endure the load or switching jobs at a pay cut.

This is the vicious cycle.

Of course, some people will say this negative spiral has nothing to do with them. Indeed, I may be one of them. We’re the kind of high-intensity people who, from the start, have only ever conceived of carving out our own careers ourselves. Job changes, restructuring, company bankruptcy — none of it matters; we’re tough gorillas who believe that as long as we ourselves are solid, there’s always a way forward.

An experience from my time in America comes to mind. I was once called into a meeting framed as, “We’ve decided to bring in an HR service, so let’s hear an explanation from that company.” The “HR service” in question was essentially a benefits package. Going in, I thought, half-heartedly, “Sure, I remember getting a similar briefing about resort facilities and discount tickets when I joined some other company (not interested).” But I quickly noticed everyone else’s enthusiasm was unusually high. (Even T, a guy who almost never showed his face at the office, was there!) Why was that? The reason is medical costs. Medical costs in America are high, and there’s no universal national health insurance system equivalent to Japan’s. So the role of covering that gap falls to the company. More precisely, it’s an insurance system the company enrolls in by leveraging group benefits. During my five years in America, there was a period when, administratively, I was unemployed (to be clear, I wasn’t there illegally). The high cost of medical care truly made my eyes pop. At least a quarter of one’s salary, sometimes nearly a third, gets taken. Take another third for taxes, and only a third is left. On top of that, rent is also high. That leaves nothing. There’s no choice but to eat into savings. I was only in that situation for a very short period, so I could endure it, but it made clear that living as a fully independent freelancer in America on a sustained basis takes real resolve. Incidentally, if you can belong to a large company, insurance premiums come to less than a tenth of what they are when unemployed. At that point, it actually feels cheaper than the burden of Japan’s social insurance premiums. This, too, depends on the company’s size and benefits policy. In this way, America is already full of people whose lives cannot function unless they demand a great deal from their company. Except for a wealthy few, this applies to most people. In fact, I suspect many Americans consider this normal. At the same time, once you realize how much weight rests on which company you belong to and that company’s policies, you also start to see a situation where your own survival can end up hostage to something as large-scale as corporate policy (something an individual has no control over, especially at a big company). It’s not hard to imagine that in America, everyone sits in their office chair perpetually half out of their seat, ready to leave their job at any moment.

Does the rise of individualism actually make people happy? Thinking about that question doesn’t really accomplish much. There’s almost no escaping a society in which individualism is on the rise.

So there are just two simple options.

Either live tenaciously within a society where individualism is on the rise, or else build an entirely separate small-scale society.

Global capitalism never misses a chance to advance rationality and gains. Individual happiness is secondary. It’s the logic of “if you don’t like it, there are plenty of replacements” — in a sense, the finished form of utilitarianism.

If you dislike that, the only option is to say NO to the overall increase in utility. Forming a small group and fighting together should let you put up a far better fight than fighting alone as an individual. Whether that takes the form of a village, a town, or even a corporate organizational structure — the innovation cultivated in that space strikes me as the area most needed going forward.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/04/401/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.