Adult Work Is Preparing the Exit
My first half-year as a part-time university lecturer has just come to an end.
It wasn’t the kind of class people typically imagine, with a thick textbook lectured from and students copying notes off a blackboard, so I was able to approach it with a fair amount of ease. My thanks go to the staff who ran around handling preparation and support.
Direct contact with young people brought, unsurprisingly, a great deal of stimulation and discovery. Let me list a few lightly:
- I realized I understand nothing at all about students (though I’d imagined as much)
- Even at a university full of serious-minded students, plenty of them have wild, unconventional ideas
- Students mostly don’t understand what it means to let something “ferment”
- Young people dislike interference from old men (don’t let it get you down—you were the same way yourself)
Those are the kinds of things I found myself thinking.
Let me organize this a bit. The course ultimately had students plan a product or service and build a prototype. All kinds of ideas emerged from the students’ free thinking and unique perspectives. My role was to comment on them, offer advice, and feed in systematic knowledge where needed: sometimes technical methods of implementation, sometimes guidance on how to generate ideas in the first place, sometimes the basics of how to build a business plan.
And sure enough, some students say things that most adults would simply laugh off (or meet with a wry smile). But those are exactly the opinions I find myself tuning into most closely.
Conversely, I once told one team, bluntly, about their “well-crafted proposal”: “Well, you’d find that written up if you just read Nikkei Business or Toyo Keizai.” (Sorry about that.)
A unique point of view, and the ignorance to push a wild idea into action without fear, are extremely precious things. I don’t want to say something as trite as “you lose that as you age,” but it needs to be stated plainly: too much accumulated experience brings its own harm.
History is full of cases where young people, outsiders, or people who’ve strayed from the established path have shocked a stagnant market and opened the way to a new era.
Wow, this is something, I thought—and at the same time, I noticed an overwhelming flaw the students carried. Very often, they simply don’t know “what comes after this.”
That’s not some grand claim about predicting the future. It’s simply that they don’t know the template. They’ve built a prototype—it works, it looks cool, I want this… and then? They’ve made an app—it’s fun, they put real care into it… and then?
To be clear, these are extremely capable students with sharp minds (I can vouch for that as an alumnus myself, ha). Naturally they don’t just read the textbook—they dig through reference literature on their own, search online, gather information accurately. They “know” things.
But as a matter of felt experience, they know nothing.
Someone like me, steeped in challenge and failure, faces students like this and the things I want to say come pouring out endlessly: you should do it this way, try this next, you should take on this challenge, here’s what you tell investors about the long term, in the short term you can’t move forward until you’ve knocked this down, and on and on.
But interference from an old man is, unfortunately, something young people rarely welcome.
And that’s fine. Because I was the same way myself.
What matters for them is standing on their own two feet, running on their own two feet, and then tripping on their own two feet, throwing their whole body forward, and falling flat. That’s how they become strong and resilient, and eventually they’ll surpass us, the previous generation, with room to spare. That’s what I’d like to expect.
Ah, how powerless adults are.
That’s not what I’m going to say. Adults have important work to do.
That work is what the title calls “preparing the exit.”
Young people typically can see only one step ahead, two at most. And very often even that expectation turns out wrong. In some cases they haven’t thought about the next step at all.
Adults, meanwhile, have a habit of daydreaming about, and trying every day to build, not just two steps ahead but a continuity that lasts a hundred years. (If anything, that’s the mark of being an old man.)
So should we run alongside them as accompany runners? In a certain sense, I don’t think so.
Careful hand-holding robs them of countless small opportunities to scrape their knees. It robs them of the chance to agonize until their eyelids twitch from stress. It robs them of the chance to lie in bed at night, suddenly realize they’ve made a terrible mistake, jump up, and pull an all-nighter fixing it.
I have four children, and I find myself thinking along similar lines when dealing with them. I imagine many parents of young children feel the same way.
Protecting a child is a parent’s job, but if a parent gives the child everything, the child stays a nestling forever gaping its beak open in the nest. The parent bird sets an appropriate hurdle at an appropriate time, and the chick clears it, or struggles without clearing it, or gives up and falls short, or gets back up and tries again. Through repeating this, the child eventually learns to set its own goals and hurdles and tackle them of its own will. (That’s what I hope, anyway.)
In business, development, and entrepreneurship, the crucial hurdle to set is the “exit.” This doesn’t only mean an “exit” in the corporate sense. It also encompasses, as a matter of meaning, goals or milestones across various phases: “putting out” a product or service, or “stepping out” into some competition.
Suppose, for example, that a particular business plan proposal is one that’s difficult to turn into a business right now—it would need a few more years of research. The basic theory is established, but proof or data is lacking, and rather than rushing forward now, adding one, two, or maybe three years of research results would create far more value. Say the people behind it are currently graduate students.
In a situation like that, what options are available?
- Keep steadily continuing the research in the lab as is
That’s probably the option that comes to mind first. The supervising professor would likely approve, and it seems like it would go well. But to some people, this might look like “giving up.” It’s not about how others see it—it’s about how the proposer themselves feels. On the surface, at least, nothing changes from the present, and if the story is “step on the accelerator again in a few years,” when exactly is that moment? Will that moment really come?
They have an idea. They’re convinced it will work. If so, shouldn’t the time to act be now? Shouldn’t the time to take the challenge be now?
It’s only natural to think so.
That’s when it becomes an adult’s job to show them various other exits. Even if the research continues, when you think about rights like patents, it might be better to think now about ways to separate it from the university and take action. And even if the research entity stays at the university, it might be worth arranging a contract in advance for jointly funding an outside company to which the research results would be transferred. Funding, too, doesn’t have to rely solely on the traditional Grants-in-Aid for Scientific Research. Depending on the subject, various grant programs exist from the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry or the Ministry of the Environment. Landing something with AMED or NEDO, for instance, can bring funding an order of magnitude larger than a typical grant. In some cases, it might be worth challenging deep-pocketed overseas institutions that fund research, such as DARPA. (In fact, Schaft, the University of Tokyo’s first startup, later acquired by Google for a time, obtained funding through a DARPA program.)
All that’s needed is to set an appropriate exit according to each person’s goals, motivations, and passions. I doubt many students could rattle off the above fluently (how many lifetimes have they lived?), but adults who can say the same things as me are probably everywhere, in droves.
And if the idea is one where you might think, “just turn this into a product right away,” the situation becomes even harder for students. Suddenly challenging the battlefield called “the market,” full of seasoned creatures skilled at releasing products and services, demands far more knowledge and experience than they have.
In supporting and guiding students like that, the presence of advisors such as angel investors and mentors matters a great deal within a startup ecosystem. But students “don’t know that,” and “aren’t connected to the right people in the first place.”
This isn’t true of every adult, but in many cases, adults know how to connect people one or two hops away. In business, it’s said that references matter. In more colloquial terms, it’s about connections—you might put it this way: “who introduced you carries more credibility than your Facebook profile.”
Something like, “Well, I don’t know if he’ll take the meeting, but why not ask this person?”—that level of introduction is probably about right. (After all, excessive interference from an old man is unwelcome, ha.)
What you’re doing is quietly placing down the first exit of the first stage of the long journey, within the small labyrinth they’re caught in.
That modest contribution is, perhaps, a fittingly modest return for the modest stimulation and energy they’ve given me. (Because the old man himself gets stimulation and energy out of it too! Ha.)
What kind of contribution can be made at a university, what can be handed to young people, what are the limits of what I myself can do: I hope this challenge, a mix of excitement and exhausting effort, continues on for a while yet.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2021/02/394/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.