Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

We Raise Four Children Without Ever Putting Them to Sleep

We have four children, and we don’t put any of them to sleep ourselves. Our eldest son is 8, our eldest daughter is 5, our second son is 3, and our second daughter is 0. To repeat: we do not put any of them to sleep at all.

Not putting kids to sleep — especially not lying down with them — comes with huge benefits. For example:

After 9pm is adult time

All the kids are in bed between 8:30 and 9pm without fail, so after that we can just watch TV in the living room, read a book, eat special sweets that feel wasted on kids. We spend time together as a couple.

No need to be nervous about laying the child down in bed

There’s a common saying that “kids have a switch on their back.” You know the one — you rock a child to sleep and the moment you lay them in bed, they bolt awake screaming. But if you don’t put them to sleep in the first place, you’re laying a child who’s still awake into bed anyway, so there’s no need to be careful at all. You just plop them down, pull up the blanket, say “okay, goodnight,” wave, and leave the room. And this isn’t about an 8-year-old. This starts from when they’re 0.

No accidentally falling asleep yourself

Actually, with our first child, we started out lying down with him to get him to sleep. That meant we had to write off the hours from around 8:30pm to past 10pm as unusable — a situation a lot of parents will recognize. If you fall asleep during that stretch, you end up pushing your real bedtime later and later, which is rough on your health. If you never lie down with them in the first place, none of that happens.

They put themselves back to sleep even after crying at night

Kids cry at night. Our 3-year-old has mostly stopped by now, but our 0-year-old obviously still needs night feedings, and up through age 1 or 2 some amount of night crying is normal. Sometimes something is actually wrong (a bloody nose, say), so if there’s a commotion we do go check on the room. But once we confirm there’s no real problem, we say “goodnight” (and pull the blanket back up if needed) and leave. The child then goes back to sleep on their own.

They sleep deeply

Our kids don’t wake up easily once we go into their room after they’re asleep. We can re-cover them with the blanket, pull things out of the dresser. Turning on the light would probably wake them, but short of that, they’re pretty solid sleepers — even the 0-year-old. This makes daily life enormously easier.

Kids learn to fall asleep even when they’re wound up and excited

If something fun happened during the day, or they went somewhere exciting, kids can get wound up and have trouble falling asleep — but once they’ve built the habit of falling asleep on their own, you don’t need to worry about that. Once we put them in bed, they might not fall asleep immediately, but each of them has their own way of getting there — tangling themselves up in the blanket, sticking a pillow under their legs, pulling their favorite stuffed animal close — and they fall asleep in their own style. Meanwhile, the parents get to deal with the day’s leftover chores.

I’ve just dashed off whatever came to mind, but there are surely plenty more benefits beyond these.

You may have heard from a friend or acquaintance, “oh, we don’t put our kids to sleep either.” But honestly, I think most people find it pretty hard to actually pull off.

So from here, I want to share the specific method for establishing “NO bedtime assistance.”

Don’t put them to sleep from the day they’re born

In the newborn period, most people have a bassinet next to the parents’ (or mom’s) bed. That part doesn’t change. But you don’t put the baby to sleep yourself. This part isn’t actually that hard once you try it. A newborn baby will usually just fall asleep on its own once you feed it milk and lay it down. The key is to keep this going, adapting the form as the child grows.

Split the rooms early

The next hurdle is how to handle night crying or the baby happening to wake up at night. Around 3 to 4 months, babies start to roll over. At that point, they might suddenly notice at night that you’re asleep in the next bed. That can set off a “(Dad!)” “(Mom!)” excitement spiral that triggers crying or fussing. If they’ve only just started rolling over, you can handle it with something like a cushion (bumper) attached to the side of the crib. But once they’re at the crawling or pulling-up-to-stand stage, you can suddenly find yourself making eye contact with the baby in the middle of the night. Once that happens, it’s game over, so you should split the rooms early. In our experience, night feedings drop off considerably around 6 to 8 months (down to once, or at most three times), so we split rooms once a child reaches that age. If you don’t have enough rooms, even just putting up a partition helps.

The 15 brutal minutes

So if you just plop the kid in bed, do they really just fall asleep like that? No. They cry. You wonder what on earth to do. You grit your teeth and hold firm. It helps to have a rough target. How long you can hold out probably depends on the person (and the house), but for us it’s about 15 minutes. For 15 minutes, we wait no matter how much crying or screaming happens. If they’re still crying past 15 minutes, we go into the room and pick them up. Once they stop crying, we put them back in bed and leave the room again. They cry again. We wait another 15 minutes. How far do you take this? In practice, after doing this 2 to 3 rounds, in the early days we’d sometimes give up, give them milk, and let them fall asleep that way. The trick is not to push too hard. If you push too hard, neither the baby nor the parents can keep it up. If listening to a crying child is too hard for you, even 5 or 10 minutes is fine. I’d recommend 10 to 15 minutes if you can manage it. Do this for a few days, and naturally they start falling asleep on their own. With our second child it took a bit of a struggle, if I remember right, but with our third and fourth, it only took a handful of tries — fewer than you have fingers on one hand — before they were smoothly falling asleep by themselves.

Tips for handling the crying

As noted above, we only stay with them until the crying stops — never longer. We never pat their back after laying them in bed, and we never rock them to sleep in our arms before laying them down. Ideally, you catch the moment right as the full-on wailing turns into hiccup-y sobbing, and lay them straight into bed. You might picture the child looking up at you with eyes that say “(wait, that’s it, you’re done?!)” but that’s surprisingly not what happens. It’s actually the parent’s own feelings — “I want to hold them,” “I want to soothe them” — that are more reluctant to let go; once the child calms down a bit, they’d honestly rather just get to sleep. Lay them down, give their head a good stroke, say goodnight, and leave the room.

Don’t make “milk = sleep.” Make it about the clock

We try hard not to build the habit of “drink milk, then fall asleep.” The reason is that eventually they stop drinking milk. For our kids, pretty much all of them weaned somewhere between just after age 1 and about 1 year 3 months. In fact, that age range is exactly when “NO bedtime assistance” gets harder. If you’ve let them internalize “drink milk and fall asleep” as a habit by that point, you end up in a tug-of-war between wanting to wean them and wanting them to fall asleep on their own, and it gets rough. So before that happens, we’re careful not to build a “milk = sleep” cycle in the first place. The method is simple:

If they resist being put down, stop immediately and play for a while

Sometimes a child resists the moment you pick them up to carry them to bed, or starts fussing the moment you lay them down. In those cases, we stop for a while and play with them until they’re in a good mood again. It takes a bit of effort to make the bed a place the child finds calming, a place they like.

Ignore them if they’re awake in the middle of the night

Kids sometimes wake up in the night and roll around in bed, or even play. Right now our second daughter is 7 months old, and she’s started babbling a little, so sometimes we hear “daa” or “appaa” from the next room. We ignore it, naturally. Leave her be and she’ll fall asleep eventually. Sometimes she’s up for about an hour, but that’s fine too. We just think of it as part of the process of her learning to wake up on her own and fall back asleep on her own, and that’s good enough.

Sometimes there’s poop, but even that you just let be

In our house, even if our second daughter is crying a fair amount, we’re just watching TV in the living room as usual. After a while it goes quiet, and we think “(finally asleep, maybe)” and peek into the room — and occasionally there’s a strange smell and, sure enough, there’s poop in the diaper. When that happens, we apologize, wake her up, change the diaper, and slather her bottom with plenty of petroleum jelly. Then we plop her right back in bed, and more often than not she falls asleep smiling.

Nothing written here is conceptually complicated — if anything, it’s all extremely simple. What it comes down to is just doing it. I wrote this post with new parents in mind, but really, all it takes is the resolve and courage to try it once. Including some rough guidelines, here’s a summary of this “NO bedtime assistance” scheme:

**- Don’t put them to sleep in your arms, don’t pat their back

By the way, I was told this approach is pretty common in America. I clearly remember a conversation I had once while wandering the coffee aisle at a Cost Plus World Market in Redwood City, when an elderly woman struck up a conversation with me.

The grandmother: “Excuse me, could you read this for me — the expiration date here on this coffee bag? The print’s too small, I can’t make it out.” Me: “Of course, no problem.” The grandmother: “Could you look along this shelf, from here to here, and tell me which one has the longest shelf life?” Me: “Ahh — of course, sure thing.” (I spend a moment reading out the expiration dates from one end of the shelf to the other) Me: “So, this one here lasts the longest. Just the one, is that fine?” The grandmother: “Yes, one is plenty. Thank you.” (looking at what I was holding) “Oh, you’re buying Ground coffee? You really should go with Whole Bean instead. Better flavor, better aroma, and it keeps much longer too. If you don’t have a grinder, you should buy one.” Me: “No, I do have one. But, you see, we have small children, and if I use it while they’re asleep — well, it wakes them up. So I basically never use the grinder anymore.” The grandmother: “That won’t do. You ought to enjoy your life properly.” Me: “Huh?” The grandmother: “Which do you prefer, Ground or Whole Bean?” Me: “Well, Whole Bean, obviously.” The grandmother: “Then drink that.” (She takes the bag I was holding, puts it back on the shelf, and presses the bag she’d just picked out for me into my hands instead) The grandmother: “I had three children, and I never worried about any of that. Raise them that way, and that’s how they turn out. My kids never woke up even when I used the grinder — honestly, they didn’t even wake up when I ran the vacuum.”

The specific methods behind “NO bedtime assistance” came together afterward, after local friends and more experienced moms taught us things and we worked out our own arrangement through trial and error — but there’s no question that it was that grandmother’s words that first pushed me to actually try it.

Make sure you properly enjoy your life. Even after 9pm.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/10/391/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.