Climate Change May Not Be the Main Driver of Wildfires

I couldn’t give my son (8) a clear explanation the other day, so I looked into it and wrote it up.
Here’s how the conversation went, by the way.
Daughter (5): “A fire ant!” Son (8): “Ah, that’s not a fire ant. That’s a red ant. Fire ants are an extinct species, you know.” Me: “Not extinct — eradicated.” Son (8): “Oh, right. Because they… hurt people… so people are trying to wipe them out! (smug face)” Me: “Yes, that’s right.” Son (8): “Speaking of which, koalas apparently became an endangered species recently.” Me: “Oh, that’s right. There’s a proposal being made about that right now. Do you know why?” Son (8): “Because there was a big wildfire in Australia (smug face)” Me: “That’s right.” Son (8): “Wildfires happened in America too, didn’t they? Why do they happen?” Me: “Hmm, in Japan I hear it’s often from campfires or carelessly discarded cigarettes, but I wonder how it is in Australia or California.” Son (8): “Does global warming have anything to do with it?” Me: “Hmm, I wonder. To begin with, what’s the spark that starts a wildfire, and is that connected to warming…”
I wasn’t sure, so I hesitated, then decided to look into it properly.
My wife, by the way, closed out the conversation with “Warming, warming, it’s all because of warming. Okay, dinner’s ready.”
What exactly is the spark behind a wildfire?
There’s no smoke without fire — or rather, without some spark, there’s no fire to begin with.
Looking at the statistics on forest fires in the Fire and Disaster Management White Paper for the Reiwa 1 edition: https://www.fdma.go.jp/publication/hakusho/r1/assets_c/2019/03/1-1-10hyo.html
“Campfires” top the list as a cause, but “unknown” outranks even that. Some of these may be arson cases where the culprit simply hasn’t been caught, but presumably some portion of them are “spontaneous combustion.” If that’s the case, does spontaneous combustion occur at a non-negligible rate even in a relatively humid country like Japan?
Curious, I searched for statistics from California, famous for its frequent wildfires, and the official data I found was from the US Fire Administration. There, Natural is listed at 3.2% (the “unknown” category being so small compared to Japan is striking). Here’s an easy-to-read table: https://www.usfa.fema.gov/data/statistics/#causesNR Here’s the detailed report: https://www.usfa.fema.gov/downloads/pdf/statistics/nonres_bldg_fire_estimates.pdf And this appears to be statistics put out by California’s insurance association: https://www.iii.org/fact-statistic/facts-statistics-wildfires#:~:text=2019%3A%20In%202019%20there%20were,Interagency%20Fire%20Center%20(NIFC).&text=The%20Mendocino%20Complex%20Fire%20broke,date%2C%20with%20459%2C000%20acres%20burned.
“Power Line” and “Lightning” and so on. Looking at the large-scale fires of the past, a fair proportion fall under unknown causes (which might include spontaneous combustion).
There’s also a passage in the following Los Angeles Times article stating that “84% are human-caused and 16% are from lightning strikes.” https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2019-10-29/how-do-wildfires-start
It also notes that arson is a rare case at most.
I couldn’t find official statistics specifically pinpointing causes in California, but in the end, it seems that in the United States, wildfires from spontaneous combustion are perceived as a rare case.
The situation in Australia, however, appears to be different. CSIRO, Australia’s national research organization, has published an analysis of the large-scale fires of 2019-2020. It’s very well organized and easy to read. https://www.csiro.au/en/research/natural-disasters/bushfires/2019-20-bushfires-explainer The cause of the large 2019-2020 fires was lightning, and apparently half of Australia’s fires are caused by lightning. There’s also a mechanism by which a fire itself can become a remote cause of the next lightning strike elsewhere. That’s supposedly how forest fires spread in a chain reaction. Here’s an easy-to-understand illustration from the BBC: https://ichef.bbci.co.uk/news/800/cpsprodpb/1407F/production/_110374028_pyrocumulonimbus_640_eng-nc.png
Incidentally, when people generally talk about “spontaneous combustion,” the mechanism is apparently “friction between leaves.” Intuitively, that sounds like it would take quite some persistence. It smells like a rare case to me.
Lightning and warming
By the way, is there a connection between lightning and warming?
In 2014, researchers at UC Berkeley published a paper in Science that drew attention.
Projected increase in lightning strikes in the United States due to global warming https://science.sciencemag.org/content/346/6211/851 According to this, a 1-degree rise in temperature raises the probability of lightning by 12%, and they projected that lightning would increase by 50% over the course of this century.
The logic runs as follows: atmospheric water vapor is like fuel for lightning, and warming is known to increase water vapor; once ignition occurs it spreads in a chain reaction, triggering a great deal of lightning. Also, as lightning increases, NOx in the atmosphere increases, which is itself a problem.
The same researchers had published research in 2011 on the correlation between rainfall, cloud buoyancy, and lightning, and this hypothesis builds on that. Updrafts increase water vapor and ice particles in the atmosphere, which trigger lightning. When they checked this hypothesis against data held by the US Weather Service, they could predict lightning with 77% accuracy. They then combined this model with 11 models projecting future climate to produce the lightning forecast through 2100 referenced at the outset.
This link has more details. https://news.berkeley.edu/2014/11/13/lightning-expected-to-increase-by-50-percent-with-global-warming/ This report has been cited quite widely in various places and appears to carry a fair amount of authority (there’s a Japanese-language article on it here https://www.afpbb.com/articles/-/3031736).
Nature, on the other hand, carried a 2018 report that reached the exact opposite conclusion.
A projected decrease in lightning under climate change https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-018-0072-6
Researchers at the University of Edinburgh, the University of Leeds, and Lancaster University compared the conventionally used CTH (Cloud-Top Height) approach against a new IFLUX (upward cloud Ice FLUX) approach that overcomes the limitations of the older approach, and found that the IFLUX approach showed a 15% decrease in lightning per 1-degree rise. They also argue that it’s difficult to accurately predict future lightning without a model that properly accounts for ice clouds and microscale physical phenomena.
At this point, the debate over lightning and warming remains unsettled.
Whether or not it spreads is the real question
Let’s get back on track.
The difference between “ignition” and “catching fire” is whether something sets itself alight or catches fire from something else. Here’s a page giving example values for the ignition point and flash point of common everyday substances. https://www.hakko.co.jp/qa/qakit/html/h01080.htm
Generally, the only substance whose “ignition point” could plausibly be reached at normal temperatures is “yellow phosphorus.” Phosphorus’s ignition point is 30°C, so under ordinary climate conditions it can in fact ignite spontaneously to begin with — the sort of thing that demands careful handling. Aside from yellow phosphorus, though, there’s hardly anything that spontaneously ignites at room temperature regardless of whether it’s hot or cold.
A spark, like lightning, occurs as a natural phenomenon as readily as you like. Forest fires presumably broke out and extinguished themselves naturally throughout prehistoric and primitive times as well. So when discussing the effects of human interference or changes in the climate environment, the focus should mainly be on whether such interference or change is making forest fires more prone to spreading.
That brings the question to the “flash point.” A spark alone just smolders a bit and that’s the end of it. A fire results when something catches alight from something else. It seems reasonable to think that the likelihood of a large-scale fire breaking out comes down to how much of the surrounding area is filled with substances with a high likelihood of catching fire.
Looking at the flash points in the table mentioned earlier, “kerosene,” “heavy fuel oil,” and “light fuel oil” are the ones where rising temperatures bring a possibility of ignition. From this one can reason: is the issue whether kerosene or heavy fuel oil is present somewhere in a concentrated form, and whether those catch fire?
The above concerned common substances found in everyday life, but I also found more detailed data on flammable gases here. http://www.nohken.com/japan/technology/reference/explosive_gas.pdf
Looking at these chemical substances makes clear that there’s no shortage of things that catch fire at room temperature. But the obvious question that follows is whether these substances are generally present in nature.
The Fire and Disaster Management Agency also explains low-temperature fires here. http://nrifd.fdma.go.jp/public_info/faq/teionhakka/index.html
The explanation is that while wood’s actual flash point is above 200°C, continued exposure to a lower temperature (around 100°C here) can cause moisture to evaporate, and as the wood becomes porous, it can catch fire. I see — this can be interpreted to mean that if dryness is a precondition, this change can occur rapidly. In other words, this provides a physical explanation for the commonly observed phenomenon that “fires during dry seasons spread more easily.”
The Fire and Disaster Management Agency’s data also shows a clear correlation between humidity and the number of fires.
Meanwhile, regarding fires involving fuel (meaning some combustible material), Australia’s national public information body comments that “when the ambient temperature is high, fire risk increases because it approaches the fuel’s flash point.” https://www.ga.gov.au/scientific-topics/community-safety/bushfire On this point, I’ve come across an argument that as forests are developed, people bring fuel into the mountains, and because its management isn’t thorough, forest fires become more prone to spreading. An op-ed from the Breakthrough Institute in Oakland was interesting on this point. https://thebreakthrough.org/issues/energy/wildfire-causes
There are several points worth summarizing.
“Rising temperatures have raised summer temperatures, bringing snowmelt earlier and pushing winter rains to the end of autumn (and ending them earlier); through these effects, the high-risk fire season is now 50 days longer than it was in 1979.”
The explanation is that it’s not that rising temperatures themselves cause burning, but that they lengthen the overall high-risk period, including dryness. That makes sense.
“The sharp decline of forests in the Sierra Nevadas due to drying, and the tendency for strong winds to occur more easily, are not factors directly tied to recent fires.”
“The movement of fossil fuel is the single biggest risk. The trend of housing moving closer to forests in search of a lower cost of living is clearly evident from WUI surveys.”
Forest fires — especially those with natural causes — are, after all, a fairly frequent natural phenomenon, one that would settle down on its own at a manageable level absent human interference. The argument here seems to be that it’s human activity encroaching on forests, combined with inadequate fuel management, that is raising the risk.
“Why California fires have become less frequent but larger over time.”
That’s the gist of it.
Conclusion
At this point, I think the argument strongly tying forest fires to warming (the claim that “it’s because of warming”) objectively lacks persuasiveness. A connection can’t be ruled out, but it falls short of being established as the dominant factor.
“It’s unclear” feels like a thin conclusion, so let me organize things with some sense of confidence level attached.
On ignition
- Spontaneous combustion accounts for a low proportion of fire causes in Japan and the US. In Australia, however, spontaneous combustion is a major factor.
- Among cases of spontaneous combustion, lightning-caused ones account for a fairly dominant share.
- It’s hard to imagine warming directly increasing the number of sparks (ignition temperatures are far removed from the scale of warming’s effects).
On catching fire
- The ease with which forest fires spread is affected, to a greater or lesser degree, by warming (through the promotion of porosity in wood, dead leaves, and so on).
- In California, the dry season has lengthened within the year due to the effects of warming.
- There are cases where fossil fuel brought in by people, present in the natural environment, makes fires more prone to spreading.
<Things that can’t be stated definitively>
- Lightning does appear to be related to warming, but whether the effect is positive or negative isn’t well understood at this point (either conclusion is possible depending on the climate model).
- It’s unclear whether warming is the primary factor increasing the ease with which forest fires spread.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/10/379/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.