Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Liberalism's Success Made Inequality Inevitable, Deneen Argues

Why Liberalism Failed

Why Liberalism Failed

The author is Patrick J. Deneen. He is a professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Notre Dame and has also taught at Princeton University and Georgetown University.

The content is dense and runs long, so I’ll split it into several parts.

The Argument

Liberalism (or liberal democracy) emerged after the decline of medieval aristocracy and went on to swallow the world. In the 19th century a current of thought opposed liberalism, and various alternative systems of rule were explored (communism being one of them), but liberalism defeated all of them and seized hegemony as the world’s sole political system. Even so, a number of distortions have recently surfaced one after another, and the moment has arrived for liberalism to be shaken once again. The main points are “ever-widening inequality,” “individuals growing ever weaker while the state grows ever stronger,” and “declining morality.” The deeply serious concern here is this: these are not outcomes brought about by liberalism’s failure but outcomes that have come about precisely because liberalism succeeded. In other words, liberalism was destined from the start to end up this way, yet the world has arrived at this point without discarding it and without building an adequate alternative, and if left alone, it will surely continue exactly as it is.

Here I’ll focus on organizing my thoughts around the point of “ever-widening inequality.”

Inequality

John Locke, “Two Treatises of Government” He divides human beings into the “industrious and rational” and the “quarrelsome and contentious.” Aristocratic rule was not so bad when those at the top belonged to the former, but when they belonged to the latter, war inevitably followed. Liberalism was thought to raise the odds that the former type would end up at the top. It was also assumed that in a society ruled by industrious, rational people, the whole of society would grow materially rich, and even if inequality never disappeared, everyone would get along reasonably peacefully. In other words, it affirmed inequality while still promising happiness. President Kennedy quoted Locke when he said “a rising tide lifts all boats.”

Tyler Cowen, “Average Is Over” The majority get pushed into areas resembling Texas. There is cheap, shoddy housing and so-so employment, and government services don’t reach far enough. But the ending Cowen imagines carries a kind of hope. A utopia resembling the one Marx envisioned might be realized in a different form. For example, with free internet access and an abundance of free entertainment, the poor immerse themselves in it and are content to be kept alive but no better off.

John Stuart Mill (19th century) He was the midwife of the innovative liberalism that designed and argued for the very world we live in today. A society in which a handful of unpredictable geniuses, unbound by convention, accomplish revolutionary things. Jobs, Bezos, Gates, Elon Musk — the world has in fact turned out this way.

Marx Discontent arises not from inequality but from exclusion. Even the advance of the global economy produces a split between those who benefit from it and those who are shut out.

Liberalocracy A new aristocratic class. The family has collapsed, but various capitalist solutions have filled the gap. Gardeners, housekeepers, tutors, nannies — occupations that would be unnecessary if the family still functioned have been created. The conditions for success in a capitalist society are loose family ties, mobility, skills that carry over when jobs change, and transferable inherited wealth.

The winners of liberal society They cut ties with their hometowns and become rootless, pursue materialism while taking risks, and stall social change while accepting inequality as a given.

Liberalism Is Rooted in Human Nature

Niccolò Machiavelli, “The Prince” He acknowledges the deep-seated selfishness and greed in human beings and argues one should think about how to make use of them rather than suppress them.

Self-interest A byproduct of discarding traditional virtue. It works against the public good, promotes zero-sum thinking, and focuses attention on material things.

Human beings cannot be happy unless they cultivate self-restraint. Human desire is limitless, while the world is not.

Changes in the Market

Consumerism It convinces people that their place of belonging is not a narrow, limited culture but a broad, inclusive market. A kind of brainwashing. To that end, it severed the market from morality and pushed labor and natural resources to be treated as commodities. Concretely: the dismantling of the medieval guild, the industrialization of agriculture, and the way employers were given support against unionized workers.

A hollowing-out not through exclusion but through redefinition. Commercialized crafts. Music mass-produced for the general public. The more choice retail offers, the more culture declines. It’s a story that rings all too true.

Daniel Boorstin Technological development carries the risk of gradually flattening the world into sameness. Liberalism promotes homogenization, and economic rationality steadily squeezes out subcultures. Calls to promote diversity produce the advanced liberal worldview in which independent individuals rise in the world with the state’s support, and the state in turn tightens its control through that very support.

Competitive market capitalism pushes agriculture toward irresponsible, short-term solutions. Administering antibiotics to cattle produces bacterial mutations, and those bacteria become resistant to human antibiotics. Genetically modified crops resistant to pesticides have led to vast quantities of pesticide being sprayed over wide areas.

The bottleneck on capitalist market expansion is the depletion of resources. But that in turn drives the opening of new markets among the poor and a further reduction of labor through mechanization.

Subprime lending In the old days, mortgage lending was risky, and it simply wasn’t done in areas where there was no local representative who knew the area well (lenders wouldn’t sell where they had no branch). That wasn’t a matter of law but of custom. A bank’s profit depended on the area itself prospering. In essence, the subprime problem can be described like this: it’s as if a university campus declared open pick-up culture and unrestricted sex to be fine, and it turned into a disaster. When something like this happens, the public demands tighter regulation, and the power of the state grows. Here too, individualism ends up advancing statism. Bubbles, if anything, actually contribute to the advance of liberalism.

The Future Liberalism Brings

Friedrich Hayek Liberalism encourages inequality. Its survival requires accelerating economic growth. Inequality keeps widening, and even once it exceeds the gap between king and peasant in the age of aristocracy, liberalism will keep winning support because economic growth is guaranteed.

Tocqueville The gap between rich and poor creates a new aristocracy. But the medieval aristocratic class was obligated to support its retainers. The new ruling class does nothing but extract from the workers.

Socrates “Every man seems to live as if in a cave.” No political ideology lasts forever. The capable rulers of antiquity knew how to build systems of continuous moral training, and knew that no system made by human beings lasts forever.

Conclusion: The Lies of Liberalism Are Being Exposed

The ruling class follows it faithfully, but the new class liberalism itself has produced is beginning to see through the lie. The next phase may bring a more rigid, more coercive shadow state — one that forces a liberal order on people whether they like it or not.

But even if the system collapses, what comes after is difficult. Historically there is Germany, which moved from the collapse of the Weimar Republic into fascism, and Russia, which moved from a brief period of liberalism into forced communism. What should be done? First, affirm liberalism’s genuine achievements (this isn’t an argument for returning to some pastoral age). Second, think about how to cultivate a polis-like life without returning to an age of ideology (liberalism’s apparent victory came at an enormous cost). Third, hope that new thought will emerge from that great cauldron.

The ideals liberalism raised have been betrayed, but liberalism has evolved in ways that disguise the betrayal. Freedom is now quite constrained. Few people vote believing they actually have a say in government. The real motivation is casting a dissenting vote as an expression of discontent. You can choose which car to buy, but you have almost no choice over whether to escape a life that bores you to death.

It’s better not to stage a comprehensive debate as a counter to liberalism. After all, liberalism and other ideologies emerged out of exactly that kind of comprehensive debate, and everyone assumes a conclusion has already been reached. Naturally, anyone who tries to reopen that debate will be met with suspicion and crushed.

The Czechoslovak dissident Václav Havel: Improving the system does not improve people’s guaranteed livelihoods. Only once life itself begins to improve can an improved system develop. One should patiently devote oneself to building a refuge from impersonal order — that is, a new form of community.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/10/375/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.