Liberalism's Moral Decline Is Proof of Its Own Success
As a trend over the past few years, phrases like “the failure of capitalism” and “the collapse of democracy” seem to be showing up in more and more places. I wanted to get a proper grip on this.
I went through several books on the subject, and this one struck me as the most reasonable and rational. I’m putting together notes here as a memo for myself.
Why Liberalism Failed
The author is Patrick J. Deneen. He is a professor in the Department of Political Science at the University of Notre Dame. He has previously taught at Princeton University and Georgetown University as well.
Since the content is dense and this will run long, I’m splitting it into several parts.
The argument
Liberalism (or liberal democracy) emerged after the medieval aristocratic order and swallowed the world. In the 19th century a current hostile to liberalism explored various alternative systems of rule (communism was one of them), but liberalism defeated all of them and seized hegemony as the world’s only political system. Even so, a number of distortions have recently surfaced one after another, and the time has come once again for liberalism to be shaken. The main points are “ever-widening inequality,” “individuals growing ever weaker while the state grows ever stronger,” and “moral decline.” And there is a deeply serious concern here: these are not circumstances brought about because liberalism failed — they are happening precisely because liberalism succeeded. In other words, liberalism was destined from the start to end up this way, and yet the world has arrived at this point without discarding it and without managing to construct a sufficient alternative. Left alone, it will surely continue just as it is.
Here I’ll focus on organizing my notes around the point of “moral decline.”
The sheer impossibility of democratic politics
Plato, Socrates — the “noble lie.” The ideal regime is one where the ruling class deceives the lower citizenry and deceives itself as well. Liberalism was the realization of this.
Edward Purcell Jr. (1973) He pointed to the low intelligence scores of soldiers during World War I, warning of the fragility of democracy. The decline in citizens’ education and the thinning of public spirit are precisely proof of liberalism’s success. Having produced a foolish populace this way, the system hands them only freedom while tilting actual politics toward elite control. Bureaucratic rule.
Aristotle described democracy as “degeneration.” Among recent liberal elites there are those who have taken up this same claim — that voters are uninformed and ignorant, and that a system fully managed by elites might be the ideal one.
Political conflict as strategic entertainment for wasting energy
For example, progressive liberalism works to exclude classical liberalism and designs state interference so that the new state can advance individualism in an ideal way, while insisting on a strict hands-off approach toward morals and lifestyle habits.
Isn’t it about time we noticed that both sides are, in the end, doing the same thing?
The waste generated by exploiting this oppositional structure is used to control citizens so their gaze never turns toward what actually matters. The prime example of this is “the periodic squandering of popular energy through elections.” People throw themselves into choosing between one of two major parties, and that lets them feel as though everything has been settled.
The fateful confrontation between liberal democracy and nature
Francis Bacon The idea that humans dominate nature.
John Dewey The savage and the civilized. The savage merely adapts to nature. The civilized overcome it.
Postmodernism Nature doesn’t amount to much, and we can escape its influence. Therefore differences such as race or birth carry no meaning (this sounds good on the surface but gets the reasoning wrong). It is unjust for the defeated to blame anything else — in the end it’s their own fault. In other words, this affirms that those who are discriminated against are not entirely blameless themselves.
The 19th century Rousseau, Marx, James Mill, Richard Rorty The plasticity of human beings. The affirmation of biotechnology that improves people.
Triumphing over nature was believed to require technological progress, and the correct path to advancing technology was to unleash self-interest. As a result, the age has arrived in which we must pay the price for technology’s victory. And yet we still believe that science will ultimately triumph over nature.
The loneliness liberalism brings
Stephen Marche We are choosing to become lonely. Separation into suburbs. The front porch has disappeared, and the backyard patio has become popular.
Smartphones have made it extremely difficult to secure time for reading, reflection, and meditation. Technology that was supposed to connect us instead produces isolation. Freedom, in practice, leaves people feeling powerless, lacking confidence, and lonely.
Sherry Turkle Social media. Connected yet lonely. It undermines the physical proximity and shared responsibility that community requires. People even lose the ability to form bonds at all.
Liberal education as prescription
Clark Kerr, Chancellor of the University of California (1963) The disappearance of the university’s founding ideal. Research outcomes get screened solely by whether they’re useful or not.
Top universities were originally meant to serve as the front line of anti-culture.
What universities were originally “supposed to do” Study epics, masterpieces of tragedy and comedy, the thought of philosophers and theologians, scripture, and so on. Instead, the curriculum exists purely to produce talent that the practical market demands.
“Refinement” requires cultivation (from the Latin root).
Aristotle, “Politics” Correct practices around food and sexual conduct must first take root as custom.
It is because of the convention we call culture that people can engage with nature responsibly.
Anti-culture, which places weight on custom rather than theory, is itself one countermeasure.
Do universities feel any responsibility for the Lehman Shock or economic crises? Students who graduated from top universities with excellent grades, got jobs at top companies, and faithfully carried out the template that these very universities themselves believed was “for the best” pulled the trigger.
Universities pull promising talent out of the regions, process it, and then export it elsewhere or abroad. The regions grow weaker and lose their strength.
Liberal arts
The liberal arts were originally meant to be something that free citizens, liberated from various constraints, pursued above all else. Now they are dismissed as a discipline for slaves, while people spend all their time learning how to make money and the various techniques for doing so. Before the modern era, freedom was believed to be something produced only at the end of a discipline: the cultivation of virtue through acquiring a liberal education. Plato, Aristotle, Christianity, Cicero, Dante — despite some differences among them, they all point to the same thing. Human beings are not born free. Acting purely as one pleases is, rather, a state of servitude — selfish and in defiance of conscience.
I found a strong awareness of the liberal arts reflected in the remarks of America’s second president and in the founding mottos of early public universities.
The degradation of character
Gratitude toward the past and obligation toward the future vanish, and pursuing immediate gratification becomes the norm. Far from being the wellspring of cultivated virtue, “culture” collapses into a synonym for pleasure, vulgarity, and distraction, promoting consumption, desire, and indifference, and overflowing with harmful behavior aimed at maximizing the self.
To despise the past is to throw the present and ourselves into the trash can, as far as future people are concerned — telling them we were garbage. And yet liberalists do exactly this.
Tocqueville, “the fragmentation of time” It becomes difficult to build anything toward the distant future. Gaining much in the short term aligns with human instinct, so it tends to be prioritized. Individualism makes it impossible for people of the future to know what one is — the broken chain.
Hobbes, “social contract theory” Tradition and culture are excluded as illegitimate. Norms disappear and disorder follows.
Nicholas Carr As time spent on the internet increases, synaptic rewiring in the brain accelerates, and patience disappears (people get irritated if screens don’t switch smoothly). Decline in language ability, memory, and concentration.
People turn to racism precisely because there is no longer anything to confront — no healthy conflict between communities, no disagreement within a community that needs to be worked through (and because it is within the community, it does need to be worked through). The only conflict left that’s easy to grasp is conflict based on skin color or race, so people turn to that.
When hearts drift away from democracy, politics comes to be perceived as something remote, a symbol of corruption. This stress gets directed into opposition movements, but those involved don’t actually hold any alternative social vision — they are simply venting anger and indignation.
None of this stems from liberalism being poorly upheld or incomplete. Rather, this is an entirely predictable negative spiral: the more faithfully liberalism is followed, the sicker things become.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/10/371/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.