Why Liberalism Failed, Part 1: A Strong State, Weak Citizens
Why Liberalism Failed
The author is Patrick J. Deneen. He is a professor in the political science department at the University of Notre Dame and has also taught at Princeton University and Georgetown University.
I have come to feel that in recent years, phrases like “the failure of capitalism” and “the collapse of democracy” keep showing up in more and more places, and I wanted to get a firm grasp on this.
I went through several books, and this one struck me as the most reasonable and rationally argued, so I liked it. I’ll put together notes here for my own reference.
Since the content is dense and will run long, I’ll split it into several parts.
The argument
Liberalism (or liberal democracy) arose after the medieval aristocratic order and swallowed the world. In the 19th century a current hostile to liberalism explored various alternative systems of rule (communism among them), but liberalism prevailed over all of them and appeared to seize sole hegemony as the world’s political system. Even so, a number of distortions have surfaced one after another in recent years, and the moment has come again when liberalism is shaking. The main points are “ever-widening inequality,” “individuals growing ever weaker while the state grows ever stronger,” and “declining morals.” There is a deeply serious concern that these are not the result of liberalism’s failure but rather the outcome of liberalism’s success itself — that liberalism was destined from the start to end up this way, yet the world has arrived here without discarding it or building a sufficient alternative, and if left alone it will surely continue on exactly this course.
Here I’ll organize things around the point that individuals keep growing weaker while the state keeps growing stronger.
The clouding of liberalism
Liberalism took root in the Renaissance. An idea that had existed for 500 years found realization 250 years ago in the founding of America, and then spread to other countries. When liberal democracy rose to prominence, people believed that representatives chosen by everyone through elections would drive out the aristocratic class, and they put that belief into practice.
The achievements of liberalism:
- The elimination of arbitrary inequality
- The fall of monarchy and aristocracy
- The advance of modern technology
- The end of religious wars
- The advance of globalization
- Progress on sexism, racism, and LGBT issues
Francis Fukuyama said in 1989 that the long debate over the ideal system had ended. But from the 2000s onward he began writing things that contradict that claim.
Citizens now regard the new ruling class as far worse than the old aristocracy ever was.
Ever since liberalism was established, it has gone on destroying one social norm and religious custom after another. It is a meritocratic society in which only those who hold power feel grateful for it, and the era in which Americans enjoyed that freedom is fading: 70% of Americans feel that America’s peak is over.
Statism and individualism are the same thing
Put into words it may sound strange, but statism and individualism are the same thing. Or rather, they are two wheels moving in the same direction. In fact, statism and individualism have grown by propping each other up. Both of them advance liberalism.
What American politics calls conservatives and progressives can be relabeled classical liberals and progressive liberals. Conservatives believe in market principles and aim at small government, seeking to achieve individualism that way. Progressives reject that and push for greater state involvement, believing that this, too, ultimately achieves individualism. But both share the same base.
Hobbes, Leviathan (1651): Individuals who have been liberated come to expect the state to enforce social norms. In a state made up only of self-reliant individuals, the individual ends up restrained by the state.
Tocqueville, Democracy in America (1835): Individualism is the cause of statism. Individualism, in the end, leaves a person with no one to turn to when they are in trouble.
What was feared from the very founding of liberalism is now actually happening to us.
Relying on the state
It is hard for an individual to protect themselves alone, which is why people form groups. The very ability to control groups well is said to be the reason Homo sapiens survived. But in a society where liberalism has fully taken hold, individuals remain exposed to all sorts of threats. No group is left to rely on, no trustworthy cultural norm remains standing, and people come to believe that the state, as the only thing left to rely on, ought to control everything through law.
In other words, as ties to local organizations grow thin, loneliness and confusion drive people to merge instead with something far more distant: the state. Bonds with family, community, religion, and culture get singled out as the evils blocking economic independence, and avoiding them only deepens the loneliness, until finally people end up heavily dependent on the one organization that still seems legitimate: the state. This happens gradually.
That is why, 150 years after liberalism spread, fascism swept through the first half of the 20th century.
Madison’s “extended orbit” argument explained that pitting citizens against one another and making solidarity difficult serves to advance particular interests. Without cohesion, people have no choice but to leave everything to the ruling class. People are made to give up on the public good and pushed toward pursuing nothing but personal ambition, and the state promotes and supports exactly that. A country whose wealth grows this way then has to fear invasion from other countries. The scale of that threat is unpredictable, so the state must be granted unlimited power, or it cannot respond when the emergency comes.
Human beings are naturally inclined to feel affection for what is close to them. Local government should matter more than central government; that’s how it ought to be. But when “superior state management” makes it impossible for localities to be appealing, by controlling taxation and budgets, talented people naturally gravitate to the center, and that imbalance keeps reinforcing itself. Weakening local government moves a society that much closer to statism, and this is believed to benefit individualism as well.
In recent years, the possibilities of technology, and in a sense its menace, have become a perfect motif for this.
The Amish
The Amish are a Protestant sect known for rejecting technology. Theirs is a community that prizes self-reliance, and within it, building a barn together is an event that cements the bonds of the community. Whether to adopt a technology is decided by whether it serves the community. Some choices, like zippers or cars, may seem puzzling, but what’s interesting is insurance. They believe the community itself is insurance, and that insurance run by a business is unnecessary. Under the conventional structure of insurance, you have no way of seeing whose needs the premiums you paid actually go toward, no way of seeing to whom you owe an obligation or responsibility. It’s an extremely irresponsible structure, in that sense.
Liberalism’s naive misconception: human beings are inherently good
The people who drove early liberalism half-innocently believed that placing people in a philosophical “state of nature” would lead to the right outcome.
In other words, they argued that there was no problem at all in shifting from ancient freedom (freedom grounded in virtue) to modern freedom (the pursuit of every liberated freedom). This is nothing but the naivety of believing that human beings are by nature free and self-sufficient. They must have had no children, and must have forgotten their own childhoods.
The “individual detached from all entanglements” never actually existed in the state of nature to begin with; it has been artificially manufactured by the power of the liberal state. Can such individuals hold proper norms and act with order? Can they act in a way that contributes to humanity and the state over the long term? The results are being thrust in front of us right now.
The decline of norms around courtship and marriage, systems that support individual independence regardless of whether one is married or unmarried, children becoming an ever-greater burden, and falling birth rates.
The absence of norms makes the strengthening of law inevitable, and makes a surveillance society inevitable.
The Soviet novelist Solzhenitsyn wrote in 1979: “You cannot criticize someone who has broken no law. We have built a society with no voluntary self-restraint.”
Community as the remedy
The thinker Wendell Berry argues that a community is built on trust, goodwill, self-restraint, patience, empathy, and tolerance. It is a place of limits. A healthy family life is essential; the discipline of family life keeps people from drifting into narrow self-sufficiency. Educational institutions grounded in community can also resist the sovereignty of the state. A community worries together, as a whole, about the upbringing of the children born into it. The public good can only hold together within a narrow community. Once it grows larger, it is inevitably abstracted, and distortions inevitably appear in reality.
When Tocqueville visited America in 1830, he was struck by Americans’ devotion to local civic activity. His township theory holds that self-government is something achieved only through long practice and debate. The handling of public affairs by ordinary people is indeed sometimes clumsy. But unless people repeat that practice and train at it, they can never escape subjugation to a distant government. The outcome decided by democracy is actually unlikely to be the right one, Tocqueville argued, but without staying engaged in politics that way, people will eventually find themselves no different from slaves. Life as a citizen of the polis means the discipline of solving local problems through self-government, the habit of self-restraint and self-discipline, and the cultivation of political judgment.
Running a household economy means thrift and frugality. Making things yourself, doing things yourself. The home vegetable garden is a good example. Understanding nature’s gifts and humanity’s limits. Joining the rhythms of nature as a human being, and celebrating them.
Moving away from abstraction and indifference: Consumption grows ever more anonymous. When you keep money circulating in the local economy, you can see plainly who it goes to and what it’s used for. You can properly grasp the structure of society.
The cultivated, acquired ability to sacrifice one’s own narrow personal interest for the sake of others.
The achievement of self-government and mutual education.
In the language of contemporary political philosophy, this is communitarianism, republicanism, or Burkeanism, a way of life that values old customs.
Rod Dreher’s The Benedict Option calls for resistance to counterculture and the rebuilding of culture and community, such as through large-scale farms.
Freedom is exhausting
Young people are raised with only two options: compete, or fall into the abyss. The winner is both the one who deceives and the one who is deceived. People deceive others in order to win, while being deceived themselves by the notion that winning is right.
Liberalism, in fact, offers no real choice. Universities mass-produce graduates given a practical education stripped of religion and human-rights questions; those graduates grow dissatisfied with society and inequality even as they land high-paying jobs, and universities respond by lining up the next batch of similar material, whatever seems practical at the moment, to make it look like reform.
Living inside liberalism, we only get to choose between an iPhone and a Galaxy, having half given up on the choice of whether a smartphone is useful at all. Which of those is really freedom?
Hobbes put it this way: man goes on seeking more and more, and it is only in death that the seeking finally ends.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/10/369/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.