CO2's role in warming is overstated, researchers argue
I recently read a book with a strikingly provocative title.
Global Warming: The “CO2 Culprit Theory” Is the Great Lie of the Century
The book is a compilation of contributions from several researchers, each writing from their own perspective, rather than a work built around a single coherent argument, so I’m putting together a loose summary here partly for my own understanding. I’m not an expert in this field, so I won’t try to adjudicate between the two camps. That would rather spoil the point.
I want to focus purely on digesting the authors’ intentions to some degree and laying them out. The authors, incidentally, are researchers at Tokyo Institute of Technology and several other universities and national research institutions. That said, some fairly one-sided views do crop up here and there. But that follows the tone of the work itself, and I won’t amplify or dampen it here.
[CO2 and Warming Are “Related”]
At the macro level, it’s undeniable that there’s a correlation between rising CO2 and warming. That’s a fact.
Still, there are several doubts worth raising. For example,
- Warming didn’t occur right after the Industrial Revolution
- There have been cold periods during times when CO2 rose dramatically
- CO2’s infrared absorption certainly holds true at high altitude, but near the surface water vapor’s influence is so much larger that CO2’s effect is small
- Looking back through history, the Earth has warmed and cooled repeatedly even in eras when no anthropogenic CO2 existed and so on. In short: “There may be some degree of correlation, but the claim that CO2 is the primary driver of warming — the claim that reducing CO2 would solve everything — can’t help but feel engineered.”
[The Influence of Clouds]
Where does the Earth’s surface heat mainly come from? The sun. How much of that solar heat gets absorbed can be expressed by a coefficient called “albedo.” The ocean, for instance, reflects most sunlight, so its albedo is 0.9. Soil is low, but deserts are surprisingly high. What dynamically changes the albedo figure is clouds. And what governs how clouds form is aerosols (airborne particulates). When there are abundant aerosols, clouds form, sunlight fails to reach the surface, and cooling progresses (the same story as the dinosaur extinction period).
Some researchers claim that the IPCC’s GCMs (general circulation models) underestimate Earth’s overall albedo, and as a result CO2’s contribution ends up looking artificially large.
Increased water vapor has a greater greenhouse effect than increased CO2. That’s a fact. And precisely because this is known, researchers have built models that link CO2 to warming through the logic that a slight temperature rise from increased CO2 raises atmospheric water vapor, which raises temperature further, which raises water vapor further, and so on. But the process of atmospheric water vapor formation — that is, cloud formation — remains very difficult to predict, and reliable data is lacking. And yet public opinion has somehow already settled the matter.
[Back and Forth Between Warm and Cold. Public Opinion Swings Too]
Looking back at public opinion: around 1900, a researcher named Ångström discovered that “CO2’s infrared absorption certainly holds true at high altitude, but near the surface water vapor’s influence is so overwhelming that CO2 has almost no effect,” and this once put an end to the “anthropogenic CO2 theory.” But later, when abnormal weather struck in the 1930s, a researcher named Callendar (an energy scholar, an outsider to meteorology) revived the CO2 global warming theory. Because it coincided exactly with a period of abnormal weather, it quickly won public support. However, in Callendar’s later years, contrary to his predictions, a cold period arrived, and he reportedly died in despair.
Around 1960–70, the theory of an approaching ice age was in vogue. Then in the 80s it flipped to the warming theory. A busy back-and-forth.
Around 1977, the climate entered another warming cycle, and the CO2 theory was once again spoken of with great conviction. But that too fell apart after 2006 as cooling resumed abruptly. Amid a string of heavy snowfalls and severe cold, IPCC-affiliated scholars struggled considerably to shape public opinion.
The cooling after 1990 was due to the eruption of Mount Pinatubo. In 1993, Japan suffered a rice shortage. A cool summer caused a 26% drop in harvest. Thai rice was imported to make up the shortfall.
In 2012, a study showed that changes in sea surface temperature could be explained almost entirely by ocean currents. Ocean currents, note, can be explained by Earth’s rotation, its orbit, and other gravitational effects. (CO2 doesn’t enter into it.) There’s also a hypothesis that if Greenland’s ice melts from warming, the resulting flood of fresh water into the ocean could halt the global thermohaline circulation (the premise behind The Day After Tomorrow), but researchers don’t consider it a dominant factor.
Ocean temperatures near Japan shift constantly due to El Niño and La Niña. CO2’s contribution is negligible by comparison.
Looking further back: temperatures began falling 65 million years ago, and an ice age began 2 million years ago. Ice ages alternate with relatively warm interglacial periods (on roughly a 100,000-year cycle). The current interglacial period began 12,000 years ago, and the Jōmon period 6,000 years ago was the warmest point. At that time, sea levels rose and the area now occupied by Tokyo is thought to have been submerged.
The Cretaceous period, from 145 million to 65 million years ago, was dramatically hotter, with no ice at either pole.
Japan’s Edo period saw a Little Ice Age. Little Ice Ages come packaged with famine and warfare. The fall of the Southern Song, the fall of the Ming, the French Revolution, Japan’s Sengoku period. Abnormal weather precedes a Little Ice Age. It actually fits better to view the present as the harbinger of one.
[The IPCC’s Overreach]
During the 2014 cold wave, an IPCC-aligned scholar explained it by saying “warming from CO2 melted Arctic ice, causing the cold westerly winds that should circle the Arctic to meander and come down into America.” But another IPCC-aligned scholar criticized this, saying “no one else holds the theory he’s proposing.” Running weather simulations several times with slightly varied conditions does produce cases where the westerlies meander. It falls within the range of natural phenomena. The jet stream circling the mid-latitudes separates warm air from cold air. Moscow, for instance, normally sits within the cold, Arctic air mass. If the westerlies meander and pass north of Moscow, it ends up on the warm side, and a sudden warming occurs (just for that year). It’s simply the whims of the westerlies. The IPCC-aligned scholar who raised that criticism nonetheless added, “Still, the heavy snow is because warming has increased water vapor.”
Dr. Manabe. Called the father of CO2 warming theory. The IPCC’s prediction models are extensions of the one-dimensional model he built. But that one-dimensional model relies on a rather forced assumption — a “constant lapse rate” (treating the temperature drop with altitude as constant) — and critics say researchers extended it directly into three dimensions without modification. Even Hansen, a leading figure who argues for CO2 warming, has raised sharp criticism on this point.
Doubts also surround whether the climate models can function at all, given that they ignore changes in solar energy, simplify ocean currents, and disregard biochemical changes. The “thermohaline circulation,” for example, is a major carrier of heat, and climate can’t properly be discussed while ignoring its influence. In fact, current models fail to correctly explain events that have actually occurred in the past.
The famous “hockey stick curve” presented in the IPCC’s 2001 report is false. Looking at temperature change from the year 1000 to 2000, it appears to spike alarmingly around the year 2000. Researchers link this to rising CO2, but if you zoom into the graph, the rise actually begins around 1900, and the only explanation offered is the unsatisfying claim that “the period after 1900 was natural variation, and after 1950 it was anthropogenic.”
Another troublesome issue: two-thirds of the IPCC’s reports consist of policy-discussion papers that don’t even require peer review, and some of this material is hard to call rigorous scientific knowledge. It’s a mixed bag. (Not to say all of it is wrong.)
Planetary boundaries (Earth’s limits). This is the foundation of the SDGs championed by the IPCC’s Johan Rockström — the claim that “if CO2 exceeds 400 ppm, it will trigger a runaway heating effect, eventually turning Earth into something like Venus” — but he has presented no clear numerical basis for it. Even among researchers thinking along similar lines, opinions differ on where the boundary actually lies. Given that, it’s strange that the figure “400 ppm” has taken on a life of its own. Those who strongly insist that “we are already at the CO2 limit” base their position on this Rockström theory.
The Lysenko affair. Soviet authorities backed Trofim Lysenko, a 20th-century biologist who rejected genetics and Mendel’s laws, and suppressed and executed scholars who criticized him (that is, who supported genetics and Mendel’s laws). This is said to have set Soviet genetic science back 40 years. Some worry that something similar is now at risk of happening in climate science.
Reducing oil consumption does have value. Technology to capture CO2 might become necessary in the future, but not now. SOx, meanwhile, promotes cooling and should absolutely be reduced (if cooling occurs, mass die-offs of living things follow).
Shale gas. Because organic matter (the remains of living things) is lighter in specific gravity, fossil fuels have traditionally been extracted from deposits relatively near the surface, within geological folds. Advances in extraction technology have made it possible to extract smaller deposits trapped within narrower folds — shale layers. That’s shale gas. Factoring this in, fossil fuels are said to be good for another 200 years.
[Doubts About Measurement]
Among NOAA’s observation stations, which are ranked on a 5-tier quality scale, most fall into rank 4 (second from the bottom), and the IPCC uses this data. If you gather data only from rank-1 stations, the conclusion is that temperatures have barely risen since 1930.
Sea level rise isn’t easy to measure. Wind and air pressure alone can shift readings by roughly 1,000 centimeters almost instantly. Sea level is also highly susceptible to ocean currents, and to eddies. No one has adequately explained how researchers derive a legitimate value from this.
Global average temperatures from before satellite observation began in the 1980s also carry many doubts, yet people treat them as though they were simply established fact. Arbitrary corrections can be applied.
[CO2 and the Food Crisis]
Warming helps relieve food shortages. In the 1990s, the IPCC began making statements linking food crises to warming. But experimental results show the opposite. At around a 2-degree rise, yields actually increase. CO2 is welcomed too. But since that’s inconvenient for funding, researchers quietly published those results in obscure journals. So, to make the food-crisis narrative work, warming has to be linked to desertification instead. But the regions with zero rainfall are limited to begin with, and while rising temperatures increase evaporation from land surfaces, two-thirds of the Earth is ocean, so the effect is minor.
And in any case, global crop yields per unit area keep rising. This is purely due to technological progress. Countries like Australia show large swings up and down. That’s because, rather than relying on technology, they continue relying on vast farmland and comparatively crude farming methods, making them more vulnerable to weather.
With warming, Russia could become a major breadbasket. In Japan, rice couldn’t once be grown in Hokkaido; now it can.
Meanwhile, global population is nearly flat in developed countries. It’s projected to rise dramatically in Africa before settling, a century from now, at a level not too different from today. The food crisis may be temporary, and overproduction, rather than crisis, may be what actually awaits.
[Things That Actually Won’t Happen Even If Warming Occurs]
Several things commonly assumed to follow from warming are simply wrong.
Polar bears won’t go extinct. If they were going to die from the degree of warming happening now, they’d already have gone extinct during the medieval warm period. Biologically speaking, polar bears and brown bears are the same species anyway — it’s like the difference between white people and Black people. Would white people go extinct if they moved to Southeast Asia? Polar bears are actually increasing, causing various problems (attacking people, raiding food supplies).
Coral bleaching has nothing to do with warming. Corals catch plankton on their own, but that’s not enough nutrition, so they also keep algae living inside their bodies. That’s what gives coral its color. As coastal development progresses, agriculture develops too, and nutrients get scattered, flowing into the sea via rivers. The result is abundant nutrients, which ends the symbiosis between coral and algae. In other words, bleaching is a phenomenon that occurs under conditions that are actually lucky for coral — abundant nutrients. Warming has nothing whatsoever to do with it. If warming caused coral bleaching, bleaching would start in the equatorial tropics.
The methane released even if Arctic ice melts is negligible. Even if Arctic ice melts and methane hydrates are released, not much methane gas actually results, because methane-oxidizing bacteria consume it.
The rise in felt temperature is due to the urban heat island effect from asphalt. Buildings now line Tokyo Bay too, so the cooling effect of the sea can no longer be relied on. One should live in the suburbs. That said, the summer rise is under 1 degree while the winter rise is over 3 degrees — arguably making the climate more comfortable overall.
[The SDGs]
France’s Yellow Vest movement. “The elites talk about the end of the world (environmental problems), but our problem is whether we’ll get paid at the end of the month.” In a UN awareness survey conducted as part of the SDGs, the environment ranked last.
The root of environmental problems is population growth. A population of 10 billion is projected for 2050, but it’s expected to start declining once that peak is reached.
The SDGs’ contradiction. About half of the 17 goals are unrealistic pie-in-the-sky, and the rest get tied to climate — which smells like a strategy.
Hunger. If solving the food problem is the goal, warming should be welcome. Yet somehow CO2, treated as its “primary cause,” is what gets reduced.
[The Dangers of Clean Energy]
Clean energy sounds good, but it ignores the fossil fuels used in building facilities and developing components. And energy efficiency is still poor. As a result, the energy obtained from 1,000 solar panels can barely produce even 2 new solar panels.
Eco-products ultimately come into existence only through the heavy use of fossil fuels somewhere along the line. It’s an optical illusion — making someone else use the fossil fuels while keeping your own hands clean.
The sustainability of renewable energy subsidies. People overstate the benefits of solar and wind power and understate their costs. Bird deaths and the deforestation caused by biomass use also go ignored.
Environmental destruction caused by renewable energy. To generate energy equivalent to one cubic meter of fossil fuel, you’d need to build a dam dropping 40,000 cubic meters of water 100 meters. Wind power requires 5 times the land of hydropower, and solar requires 4 times.
The 2015 Kinugawa River flood. Workers were cutting away natural levees to install a megasolar facility, with a new levee under construction further out, when the flood occurred.
Geothermal power’s energy efficiency is 1/50 that of heavy oil. And it’s still relatively one of the better options.
Securities firms’ deception. They recommend fuel-cell stocks to clients while taking contrarian positions themselves.
Germany’s environmentalism. Historically, Germany has held the view that humans should adapt to nature. But having pushed to phase out nuclear power, it ended up increasing reliance on thermal power, and is now suffering for it.
[Agitation Through Misinformation]
The world is full of agitation that is either baseless or built on entirely mistaken grounds. Some examples follow.
No one has proven a causal link between warming and abnormal weather events like typhoons, heat waves, and wildfires, and the correlation is weak to begin with.
Tuvalu’s apparent sinking into the sea is due to land subsidence from unplanned groundwater pumping. The same thing happened in various parts of postwar Japan and became a problem there too.
The mass extinction of the Paleozoic era, roughly 250 million years ago. We know that the largest sea-level regression in history occurred around that time. As any elementary-school science student knows, regression happens when ice forms — so an ice age is the natural inference. And yet some scholars construct the hypothesis that the period was actually warm, in order to curry favor with the IPCC and secure research funding.
The Club of Rome. Around 1972, researchers pursued a field of “warning studies.” They made numerous negative predictions, predictions that would ideally turn out wrong. Of them, only the population growth prediction actually came true. In other words, of the warnings issued 50 years ago, population growth is the only one that played out as forecast.
[CO2 and Politics]
As a basic premise, a country can control the tone of its researchers’ arguments. Whether a researcher can secure outside funding affects their career advancement. Publishing a paper also requires peer review. Controlling scholarly opinion is, in that sense, surprisingly easy.
The environment as a diplomatic tool in the post-nuclear-weapons era. In 1990, the IPCC was established as an analytical body to gather material for drafting treaties at COP. Up until the Kyoto Protocol in 1997, the IPCC had not actually been asserting anthropogenic greenhouse effects very strongly. In other words, it isn’t simply “all the IPCC’s fault” — nations had reached an underlying agreement. The thinking went, “the next diplomatic tool will be the environment.” The UN, too, saw environmental issues as ideal for fostering peaceful international cooperation and rode this wave.
From an energy-policy standpoint, reducing CO2 makes sense enough. But there’s also a persistent story that Thatcher, in the past, promoted the “CO2 is the villain” narrative to help shift away from coal, and that the IPCC was created as an institution to serve that purpose.
The circumstances of German reunification. In 1987, the Bundestag decided to tackle global warming. This was partly necessary to signal to Britain and France that “Germany will not pursue military expansion (it will spend its money on other things instead),” smoothing the path toward reunification and EU membership.
The EU has in mind the idea of a carbon tariff — an added tariff on countries that haven’t cut CO2 emissions. This is bound to provoke backlash, but the EU needs to recoup the upfront investments it has already made. Note that the targets under the Kyoto Protocol were met only thanks to the Lehman Shock. Put another way, this proves that emissions would never have dropped that quickly without an economic downturn. Demanding CO2 cuts, in effect, amounts to demanding “cut your own national strength.” On that point, it’s developing countries whose CO2 emissions will rise going forward. Developed countries, in fact, will barely change. So is the plan to tell developing countries that have only just escaped the ranks of the poorest, “All you talk about is money — think about the planet! How dare you!”?
The environmental left. Their actual enemy is the power structure of their own country. As noted above, if you’re going to blame fossil fuels, everyone thinks you should go after China and India first. Developed countries have already made their efforts; it’s harsh to say the same to developing countries right now. The most reasonable targets would be the “former developing countries” that have already become sufficiently wealthy.
Trump withdrew from the Paris Agreement in 2019. China had risen to become the largest emitter. There was no longer any reason for the old guard of developed countries to keep straining to cut emissions on their own.
[Summary]
The IPCC’s lies:
- That CO2 determines Earth’s temperature
- That we cannot be happy unless the SDGs are achieved
- The baseless and unrealistic goal of maintaining modern society without using fossil fuels
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/10/362/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.