Here's how to actually think about Zoom's security

Everyone’s using Zoom these days. I keep hearing “there’s a bunch of security problems with it, right!?” and getting asked about it. So I’m writing this down.
By the way, professionals have already covered the details elsewhere. Here’s one example. https://www.itmedia.co.jp/business/articles/2004/22/news026.html
https://wired.jp/2020/04/21/keep-zoom-chats-private-secure/
So in this post I want to write about my own stance — how I personally deal with this kind of problem. In an era when software gets updated every day, chasing the latest details isn’t very useful coming from someone like me, who isn’t a professional writer on the subject. For that, “just go search it” is the honest answer.
That said, since I’m using Zoom as my example, I’ll touch on a few specifics. Think of it as working from the concrete toward the abstract.
I’m not a cybersecurity expert, by the way, so please don’t take everything here at face value.
First, security problems break down into a few distinct tiers. Mix these up and the discussion goes nowhere.
- Content at the level of outright design mistakes — indefensible, and things that should simply be fixed
- Content closer to a cat-and-mouse game with skilled hackers
- Content at the level of literacy that anyone living in the modern world should be looking after themselves
Watching the articles and the back-and-forth online, I’ve noticed that several things I thought “that’s clearly bad” about have already been fixed in the latest version. In fact, fixes seem to have gone out almost the moment people called them out. Some concrete examples:
- If you installed the Zoom app and left it running in the background, it would keep a web server running on its own without you knowing
- Some portion of the data (unclear how much) was being routed through servers in China
- User data was being sent to Facebook without consent
I was relieved to see these get fixed.
Given this string of events, some people will say “I’ll never use tools from a company that makes mistakes this serious again!” while others will say “they fixed it fast and acted in good faith — well done!” This isn’t really about who has higher or lower security awareness. It’s a difference in values. I’m in the latter camp, by the way, probably because I know firsthand just how hard it is to build and launch a product or a business.
To be a bit of a backseat driver about it: I actually wasn’t using Zoom to begin with. A few years ago an investor in the Bay Area recommended it to me, and I tried it, but I felt resistance at the “install this app” step, so I used it once and then uninstalled it. Were my concerns justified? I suppose they were. Was that predictable? It was predictable. Either way I didn’t find it all that surprising. But given that they fixed it immediately, my gut reaction was more “huh, nice work.” That’s really all this is, for me.
Design mistakes happen. Anyone who can’t accept that has no choice but to shut themselves off from everything and live in a shell. Driving somewhere is a risk. Taking a walk along the beach is a risk too (easy to say in this day and age). That’s just how it is.
Let me skip over point 2 for a moment and write about point 3. Zoom recently introduced passwords, for instance, but if someone with low literacy is the one using them, that’s meaningless — the password just leaks along with everything else. So frankly, worrying about point 3 in general is mostly a waste of effort. Honestly, if someone can’t even manage that much on their own, it’s a bit embarrassing for them to be going on about “Zoom’s security is…” That’s just how it is these days. We’ve reached a point where you can’t live comfortably anymore unless you handle basic security yourself. I was impressed to see the word “infodemic” come into use recently, but can you really hold a social media platform responsible for people being misled by misinformation on it? If you catch a virus visiting an illegal porn site, do you ask the browser maker to do something about it? It’s been something like 20 years since the term “internet literacy” came into use, and the tug-of-war between how fast the times change and how fast literacy catches up is still going on. On one point — that anyone who gets hold of an ID and password can just walk into a meeting — Zoom actually responded quite thoughtfully by adding a “waiting room.” I think that’s commendable. If it were me, I might have just ignored that kind of criticism with something like “secure it yourself. If you don’t like it, don’t use it.”
As for point 2, you could say Zoom took on, voluntarily, the role of “finding the pitfalls” that people talk about in the startup and new-business world. Mostly by circumstance, admittedly. Google, Facebook, and Amazon all have security problems surface constantly too, and developers everywhere use that information to harden their own tools. Sometimes a company goes under, and everyone around them learns a big lesson from it. That’s how society keeps turning. Unless someone plays cat-and-mouse with the hackers, the overall level of security never rises. And if someone still says “I don’t want to use a tool dangerous enough to be a hacker target,” you can just ask back, “so you don’t use Google, Facebook, or Amazon either?” I’d bet they use all three normally.
Try looking at a site like this one. It’s genuinely interesting.
List of personal information leak incidents and cases https://cybersecurity-jp.com/leakage-of-personal-information
You’ll see that security incidents happen by the truckload, every single year. Do we really respond diligently to each and every one of them with boycotts and protests? No. In other words, it’s an everyday occurrence. Overreacting specifically to this one Zoom incident doesn’t strike me as a particularly fair stance.
In other words, it’s just getting criticized right now because of the timing. This is probably growing pains on the way to becoming infrastructure everyone relies on. It reminds me a bit of the “harvest” mentality — leave your teenage son’s care to a butler and a housekeeper, then have him take over from you once he’s an adult — and I recall that attitude wasn’t well liked in the very village-society-like Bay Area (which is also why I think I’ll keep sticking with it, as much as I can). That said, for the average person, this is also clearly a situation where it’s fine to walk away. I suppose that just makes me the odd one out.
But here’s the important thing: other services are probably carrying around similar problems anyway. And tools locked down tight on security end up being a pain to use. In that sense, my personal view is that there’s a very good chance “Zoom, having overcome its current problems and grown from them” ends up being the easiest-to-use and safest tool out there.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/04/357/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.