Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Bad rumors about startups spread fast

Let me write about something hardly anyone talks about, even though everyone in the industry knows it.

Bad rumors about startups spread fast.

“So-and-so is about to run out of cash.” “I hear such-and-such, the key person there, is quitting.” “They said they’d close the funding round last month, but the lead investor pulled out and it fell apart.”

There are many variations, but this kind of information circulates extremely fast.

It runs one or two years ahead of the public.

That’s how it works. Impressive, right? Ha.

The reason the information moves so fast is mainly because the world is small. And because for people who care about speed, information matters enormously.

Information is only worth something when it circulates. People who just hoard information for themselves eventually stop receiving any. People who properly share useful information — and I don’t mean leaking confidential material, that’s a different and much lower-grade thing — are the ones who keep getting useful information back.

Bad rumors can actually be useful.

A rumor that someone is quitting is a juicy piece of advance information for another company that wants to hire someone with that person’s profile. Startup executives (and other key people) are mostly all connected to each other. Meeting up or grabbing a meal one-on-one is easy. And naturally, when they do, talk of what so-and-so is planning to do next comes up as a matter of course.

Information about a funding round that fell through is useful for shaping your own fundraising strategy. You learn things like: so this VC doesn’t actually invest in this category after all, or it looks like there’s too much capital chasing too few deals at that firm, and here’s how money moved from there to here and so on.

Someone else’s management failure becomes a cautionary tale for your own management. Failure patterns tend to look alike across companies (even though, saying this, I end up repeating them myself).

That said, the fact that rumors or inside information circulate at all means the startup in question counts as a “hot startup.” Rumors about a brand-new company nobody’s heard of, or a company everyone stopped caring about ages ago, have little value to pass around.

And here’s the genuinely interesting part:

Hearing the bad news privately while watching the good news play out publicly

happens extremely, extremely often. This is what I meant earlier by “one or two years ahead.”

Behind a funding press release, you hear that the chance of launching within the year is already gone. (Why? Wasn’t the funding raised for exactly that purpose? Well, there’s a proper answer to that.)

Behind a Facebook post bragging about poaching a bunch of highly skilled people, you hear that the lead engineer burned out mentally and quit. (Wait, wasn’t the company held together by him? What are they going to do now? Well, that’s exactly the situation.)

Watching some company win an award on WBS, behind the scenes you hear they’re in financial trouble and probably won’t make it to the end of the year. (Are they okay? Well, no, they’re not.)

There are plenty of companies that look great from the outside while actually being finished. The fragility of startups is such that a single bad decision or the loss of a single person can end things just like that. Generally speaking, though, a company that has already raised tens of millions of dollars won’t die that easily within a year or so unless it really screws up badly. Especially in Japan, where personnel costs haven’t inflated nearly as much as elsewhere.

In other words, the company dies one or two years after the information first starts circulating.

But at the same time, what’s interesting is that none of this circulation of information has a gossipy feel to it — everyone handles it in an earnest, gentlemanly way. There’s a shared attitude of focusing on your own footing first rather than getting worked up over other people’s good or bad news, and when something unfortunate happens, an attitude of “thanks for finding the pitfall on behalf of the rest of us.” That too is, in its own strange way, a very startup kind of thing, don’t you think?


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/02/346/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.