Prioritize self-efficacy over self-esteem
The other day, someone told me, “I have low self-esteem.”
They’d gone to an arts-focused high school and were surrounded by people so exceptionally talented that they came to feel acutely how unremarkable they themselves were. Ever since then, they said, their self-esteem has basically been low.
It’s true that people who excel in the arts are often unusual in some fundamental way. A junior high classmate of mine is now a hugely successful manga artist, and back then he used to draw strange doodles during class while muttering to himself.
In my notebook, no less, since I sat behind him. Ha.
I thought he was a weird guy, but a while after graduation I heard he was working as an assistant on one of Magazine’s bestselling manga series, and not long after that he made his own debut. In the early days, he said, he had no assistants of his own and drew everything himself. He once told me he cut his own finger trying to get the color of blood just right, thought “this is it!” when it looked good, only for it to quickly turn blackish-red and ruin the effect — still the same slightly unhinged guy as ever.
I also played a fair amount of football. I was never anywhere near a high level myself, but having played alongside them, I have some feel for what level the prefectural and metropolitan selections, the players with national tournament experience, and the regular starters at the so-called elite national powerhouse schools are at. Once you get to national-team level, though, I honestly have no idea. All I know is, “ah, so even those guys don’t measure up.”
Once, back when I was a graduate student, I played in a practice match between “a team of Tokyo Verdy OBs” and “a fun ragtag team.” A friend of mine who had been on the Tokyo metropolitan selection organized the ragtag team. Most of its members were from J-League youth academies or top university teams, and it’s still a little funny to me that a single first-year master’s student from the Department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering at Tokyo Institute of Technology somehow got mixed in. In the match, the ragtag team thoroughly beat the Verdy OBs. Even though they were called “OBs,” most of them looked to be around the same age as active players, and some looked like they might be former foreign signings. We beat them anyway. Really, there wasn’t even an opening — we beat them completely. And yet, not one person from that “ragtag team” went on to make it in the J-League (or at least, not visibly enough for anyone to notice).
So as this shows, the idea of building your sense of self-worth on “some achievement” is a trap people easily fall into, and it’s genuinely difficult.
First, as I just described, it’s technically difficult.
Around 4,000 schools take part in the national high school football tournament. One of those schools becomes champion, and behind it stands a football population of more than 170,000 people. Add club teams to that denominator as well, and from all of that only a dozen or so players per age group get selected for the youth national teams — and depending on the generation, there may end up being nobody at all chosen for the full national team. And even so, Japan is still, by world standards, only a mid-tier footballing nation. It’s an absurdly steep pyramid.
Van Gogh is a famous painter today, but it’s said he was barely recognized during his lifetime. Franz Kafka is one of the defining writers of the 20th century, but in his own lifetime, far from being celebrated, he was just a gloomy office worker, and when he was dying he told a friend to burn all of his manuscripts. Surely their lives were steeped in a sense of self-negation.
It may sound surprising, but among successful business executives, it’s quite common to find people with low self-esteem. This isn’t some tip like “low self-esteem leads to success” — it’s the rather heavy realization that they are afflicted with a kind of disease called “never being satisfied.” (laughs)
Let’s stop relying on self-esteem.
Self-esteem is nothing more than one decorative flourish on your personality.
Even if you come first in a nationwide mock exam, that’s nothing more than a personal trait. Even if you pass the bar exam on your first attempt while still in college, that’s nothing more than a personal trait. Whether you bench press 200kg or run 100m in under 10 seconds, that’s nothing more than a personal trait.
So then, by what measure should we praise others, or come to terms with ourselves?
Let’s shift to a sense of efficacy instead.
The term “self-efficacy” isn’t very common in everyday usage, but I believe it’s a proper term in psychology.
In short, it refers to the feeling that “I am of use.”
My fundamental view is that “a person’s happiness exists only right in front of them.” I don’t mean to criticize people who work hard every day for the sake of someone, somewhere in the world, whom they’ve never met — but focusing purely on sustainability, very few people can keep going indefinitely working for “someone, somewhere, who I don’t even know.” And I doubt many people can keep working hard “for the sake of the world” in some macro, abstract sense either.
After all, there’s no direct feedback, no sense of impact.
Far more than that, it’s the feeling of making the person right in front of you happy, or of having been helpful to them, that genuinely lifts a person’s spirits.
Suppose you were a celebrity. Even so — as I’ve written in another post — information that faces outward toward the public is, to some degree, always controlled. Being praised based on that can give you a sense of accomplishment that doesn’t match reality, and may even mislead you.
In other words: “evaluation from people you have no direct connection to will not make you happy.”
Rather than being tossed around by that kind of thing, pay more attention to how the person right in front of you feels about you.
If someone is in trouble, help them. If you have a solution, don’t be stingy — share it.
If someone is struggling, listen to them. Sometimes you’ll be able to offer advice from your own experience, and sometimes you’ll have nothing to say at all and can only listen. Either way, having been listened to will have lifted their spirits somewhat. Isn’t that a wonderful thing?
Try your best. The person watching beside you might draw strength from it.
Do things carefully and with care. The person watching beside you might reflect on their own conduct because of it.
Even when you act with someone’s best interests in mind, sometimes it gets rejected, or even thrown back at you as a bad outcome. But giving up over that accomplishes nothing. Just keep doing things for the person in front of you, steadily, without fanfare. This is something Mother Teresa once said.
If you can’t find any sense that “I exist here and I am of use,” then changing “where you are” is also an option. With 7 billion people in humanity, it’s not simply “7 billion different ways” — 7 billion Combination 2 ≈ 2.5 x 10^19 relationships ought to exist, that many kinds. If there’s something tormenting you, it isn’t some absolute thing — it’s something relative. As I said earlier, your skills and abilities are nothing more than a small decorative flourish on your personality. Think of it the same way as having a nice nose or clear skin. It has little bearing on whether you can be happy.
Make the person in front of you happy. There’s an anecdote that Jack Dorsey, CEO of Twitter and Square, built Twitter thinking it would make his “mother” happy, and built Square thinking it would make his “glassblower friend” happy. His business acumen is remarkable, but the motivation at the very start was something that simple.
**Self-esteem looks dependable at first glance, but it’s actually unstable — something troublesome that can be self-generated through performance, or can turn into needless dependence.
Self-efficacy, by contrast, doesn’t waver as much, and steadily, bit by bit, bears solid fruit — it’s the more mature of the two.**
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/02/342/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.