I Dislike the Sharing Economy

I hold what you might call a negative attitude toward the sharing economy. What follows is long. If the title already irritated you, don’t read on, because it will only irritate you more. When I wrote “what you might call” at the start, I meant it weakly as “in a limited sense” and strongly as “mostly negative, with some exceptions.” This will be hard to read unless I unpack that first, so let’s start there. The sharing economy can be broadly divided into two categories.
- the sharing of assets
- the sharing of labor I won’t accept the objection “isn’t labor also a kind of asset the worker holds?” here. The two are fundamentally different in both ideology and economic structure, and it is precisely that boundary that cleanly divides my “like” from my “dislike.” Asset sharing began with the idea of “making use of idle assets.” The archetype of this is AirBnB. AirBnB gave people who owned multiple properties a new way to monetize them, and it gave users a relatively cheap way to find lodging. Gradually, all sorts of variations emerged: properties bought purely as investments and then listed on AirBnB, vacant units in apartment buildings being rented out, and so on. This is the growth of a genuinely new business category, the product of the market’s own ingenuity and effort, and it’s beautiful. A closely related offshoot is shared office space, and extending the concept further, the same conceptual lineage produced bike-sharing and scooter-sharing — the idea of renting out “practical assets someone has already bought,” not limited to real estate. These could be described as an evolution of the rental business rather than something wholly new, but it’s hard not to admire how “rent-a-whatever,” once confined to narrow physical constraints, expanded through technology to a scale capable of capturing a much larger market. Some categories succeed and some don’t. Market fit matters enormously (bike-sharing, for instance, is absurdly popular in China but still has a long way to go in Japan), but watching all sorts of people take on all sorts of challenges, refining these ideas as they go, is genuinely satisfying to watch. So, as should be clear by now, these fall into the “like” category. I wouldn’t go so far as to start one myself, but I respect the people who came up with these businesses, and I want to cheer on the people dreaming up new variations right now. So what I want to take issue with here is the latter category. “The sharing of labor.” The archetype here is Uber, but the list of examples that followed is endless. That’s because the sharing of labor is, at bottom, built on the idea that “work that professionals used to do is now done by amateurs in their spare time,” and that concept can encroach on any domain whatsoever. Taxis, like Uber. Food delivery, like DoorDash. Valet parking. Cleaning. Laundry. Dry cleaning. Line-waiting. And so on. Everything imaginable became a target for this kind of sharing service. I got sick of it. This was around 2014 to 2016. It’s one of the reasons I stopped feeling much resistance to leaving Silicon Valley — the engineer’s paradise and battlefield both. I don’t sense dignity in these businesses. First, most of the workers supplying the labor aren’t ending up happy. (I knew a fair number of people who actually worked as drivers, so while there’s some bias in my sample, I don’t think this is an unfounded generalization.) As I’ve written in another post, getting every stakeholder on board is the heart of business, and I believe a business that manages that is a beautiful one. Take Uber, for instance. The first thing that strikes you when you actually use it is how overwhelmingly cheap it is. Taking a licensed taxi from SFO (San Francisco International Airport) to my apartment at the time cost, as I recall, at least the high $40s, sometimes as much as $60. With Uber, it was $20–30. That was the pattern throughout. From the nearest CalTrain station to my apartment, Uber almost never exceeded $10. What makes this overwhelming cheapness possible is Uber’s system — advanced, or at least reasonably useful — combined with low wages for workers. In Japan recently, fewer people have been choosing to work for companies under contract arrangements or to live as freelancers. There’s an implicit understanding behind this: “irregular, unstable employment should pay somewhat more than regular employment.” Contract work can be terminated far more easily than regular employment, and sole proprietors generally have to cover insurance, pension contributions, and every other overhead cost themselves. So unless they’re paid more, they’re in trouble. Yet Uber drivers receive wages below the going rate. Why? One reason is that they haven’t received professional training, so service quality isn’t necessarily high. Just the other day, someone posted on social media about a $30 bento they’d ordered through Uber Eats arriving completely flipped over and smashed to pieces, and it went viral. Trouble like this is always going to happen. But here’s the crucial point — one that anyone who has actually used a service like Uber on the ground will recognize immediately. Many of the drivers are immigrants, and a striking number of them have no steady job. I don’t mean people who have chosen not to have one. I mean people who can’t get one — the unemployed. Framed as a nice story, you could dress this up as “giving the unemployed a new way to earn income,” but that’s not what’s actually happening. My memory of the US isn’t updated with much frequency after 2016, so what I’m describing is mainly from before that, but the key issue I want to raise here — the unease, the inarticulate resentment — is this: “isn’t there an invisible coercion built into this free market?” To put it more bluntly: exploitation. They make the decision to do this work under something close to a kind of forced non-thinking, having had the choice taken away from them except for “low wages, but better than nothing.” Eventually they weigh the effort against the payoff, grow disheartened, and either rise up in protest or sink into a further kind of resignation. I understand the objection rooted in personal responsibility: “they chose it themselves, so that’s that.” But when you see that so many of them are Hispanic or immigrants from other marginalized countries, it’s hard to believe this is a market shaped by pure free will. Some people might say, “so what’s wrong with that?” Exploitation wearing the mask of free will, built on inequality, has existed throughout history. During the American Civil War, for example, there was a draft, but apparently you could pay someone else to take your place. As a result, many of the figures who later became prominent in American business and politics had used that option. Naturally, it was the poor and the immigrants — those with the least power — who took their place. That “commutation” arrangement, understandably, earned a terrible reputation, and what came next was a volunteer system that nonetheless allowed non-citizens to volunteer — another scheme that, once again, targeted immigrants. Serving in combat led directly to a green card. And yet I don’t think there’s quite enough material to openly accuse these practices of “degrading the value of these people’s lives and constituting exploitation.” Still, something doesn’t sit right. This nagging feeling closely resembles the distaste I feel toward the labor-sharing economy. For anyone who’s read this far and still doesn’t feel the same unease I do, let me pose this question. Would an engineer who works at Uber ever think, “maybe I’ll drive for Uber after hours too”? A quick aside. Among the Uber drivers I actually met myself, there was one elderly man who said he’d started driving thinking, “maybe there’s something more I can do in retirement.” Long drives tired him out, so he only drove locally, from after lunch until around 3pm, before the evening rush (which meant he usually had one or two passengers, three at most). He said what he enjoyed was chatting with the strangers who rode along with him. If I recall, he was a Dutch immigrant who had been a physics professor. He was clearly doing this without any concern for whether it paid. If this had been built into a “service that sells a lovely experience,” I think it could have landed somewhere a bit better. In that sense, maybe Lyft (my neighbor from the Miselu days) shows one such possibility. Now, let’s shift perspective a little and think about what “sharing” actually means in the first place. This whole line of thinking — or rather, this encounter with an old memory and the sorting-out of a concept — actually started with a question a friend once put to me. “Share,” in Japanese, would be 共有 — dividing something with someone else. A common context for the word with children is during a toy dispute: “you need to share.” You might also encounter a “shared folder” at work — a folder containing files anyone can freely view, and in some cases, freely modify. Already there’s a sense of something like “free, unlimited, open” embedded in the word. Looking up “share” in an English dictionary, I found this: a part or portion of a larger amount which is divided among a number of people, or to which a number of people contribute. So there, too, I sense the implication of something extra, or something too large for one person, being divided among many. That is exactly the sense I get from asset sharing. With AirBnB (there are plenty of exceptions, surely), it started with people holding idle assets thinking, we’re not using this anyway, so why not let someone else use it — the “share” mindset at the heart of the service. That matched up with consumer needs like “hotels are too expensive” or “I can’t find a hotel,” and the business clicked into place. But what about the sharing of labor? These people (again, there will be exceptions) aren’t comfortably indifferent to profit. Most would prefer steady employment, but they ended up here with no real freedom of choice. If this work paid well enough that they could genuinely think “this is far better than having a steady job,” that would be worth examining — but unfortunately, that hasn’t been the case. (Perhaps there’s been some improvement lately.) In fact, Uber has repeatedly run into serious problems in its relationship with drivers — one of the most important stakeholder groups it has. But in a labor market governed by structural inequality, the service will probably keep running fine on the logic of “there’s always someone lower down the ladder; even if you won’t do it, someone else will.” If anything, competitive pressure only widens the house’s margin. Thinking about the needs side, another negative point emerges. How often, really, do we hear social debate about taxi fares spiraling out of control, or about the taxi supply-demand balance breaking down to the point that you can’t find a cab? I won’t say it’s never happened (there’s seasonality around events, regional variation, and so on), but it’s hard to believe there was ever a critical social problem there. In other words, most of these services look like they came in to disrupt an existing market by offering “a bit more convenient” or “a bit cheaper,” while their contribution to stakeholders is limited and unbalanced. Deeply regrettable. But later services follow the successful examples that came before them. Inevitably, everyone copies everyone — including the style of exploitation. Evaluating whether something is socially right or wrong is, to begin with, a divisive matter, because it drags you into philosophy. (Incidentally, philosophy is a troublesome discipline defined by the fact that it never, ever concludes.) A typical split, for example, is “libertarianism” versus “utilitarianism.” I’ll leave the fine-grained definitions to specialized books, but put simply, it’s a question of whether you prioritize “freedom” or “utility.” From the libertarian standpoint, the only thing that matters is whether anyone’s freedom is being obstructed. From that view, the service provider, the drivers who use it, and the passengers who use it are all choosing “it” in a situation where other options exist, so nobody’s freedom is being obstructed. The drivers aren’t professional drivers to begin with, so they’re just as free to take a part-time job at In-N-Out or go clean office buildings. They could just as easily get a scholarship, go to Stanford, and become software engineers. Passengers, of course, are equally free to take public transit, an unlicensed cab, hitchhike, or get around however they like. So nobody’s freedom is being obstructed or constrained. Hail libertarianism, hail capitalism. From the utilitarian standpoint, on the other hand, what matters is whether overall utility, viewed as a whole, has increased. The service provider has clearly built a massive business, so utility has risen there without question. Passengers get a cheap way to get around and are happy about it. Drivers may have some complaints, but they’re earning some amount of money properly. There may be further demands, like social security, but the utility lost by not meeting those demands is small relative to the whole. Add it all up, and the net effect is presumably positive. Some complaints and some sacrifice are acceptable costs in optimizing overall utility. Society is improving. Hail utility. Hm. Neither framework quite snags on what’s bothering me. So what exactly is it that I’m stuck on? I think this is, in fact, a matter of morality and reason. But words like that sound a bit grandiose, and they put whoever I’m talking to on guard, as if I’m about to hit them with some thorny unsolvable puzzle. So when I bring up this kind of argument, I try to phrase it instead as “is everyone happy?” (depending on the situation). Where any given person finds happiness varies, so you can’t know without listening. And if you do get that feedback, you should take it extremely seriously. This is a matter of philosophy. A business founded from the start on that kind of philosophy wouldn’t get caught up in these problems in the first place — and even if it did, its response would surely be excellent. Some companies raise their reputation through how well they handle defective products. Others badly damage their reputation by covering problems up. That’s not a calculation made with an abacus — it’s behavior grounded in morality and reason. Ford’s Pinto defect is a very famous case: the engineers knew about the flaw, but management chose to ship the car anyway, preferring the risk of occasional fires to the cost of a fix. It’s startling that they really did run the numbers that way. In the end, far more accidents occurred than anticipated, many people were killed or injured, and it became a massive scandal. From the perspective of an individual user, this is an utterly irrational story, but from the standpoint of the executives who ran the numbers, it might be said to have fit economic rationality (had it worked out). But that’s not where the unease lies. It really is a matter of morality and reason. Imagine sitting beside someone dying from this accident, at their deathbed, and saying: “Well, I’m sorry, you’ve had bad luck and you’re about to die, but overall, by being able to sell the Pinto cheaply, we managed to get cars into wide use all over the world. Many ordinary families who could never have afforded a car before now have one — look, this weekend your family could go camping in the mountains. Isn’t that wonderful? Isn’t that happiness?” Could you say that and mean it? If you could mean it, you’d have to be pretty crazy. Although, well, Elon Musk has said things like that. The sharing economy for labor strikes me as having a deeply troubling character in exactly this respect. Knowing, somewhere, that a problem is brewing, the business deliberately looks away and barrels forward for short-term profit, right up until the day the ladder is pulled out from under it. As long as the headline P&L and cash flow look good, money pours in. And once money pours in, everyone imitates it. This kind of failure has repeated itself again and again throughout human history. Still fresh in memory: subprime mortgages. And in this kind of story, whoever got out early wins, and most of the people who jumped on the trend later fail to get out in time and go down with it. Everyone surely knows this, and yet they get on board anyway. “Is everyone happy?” By skimping on asking that simple, fundamental question, these businesses destroy themselves through cracks that were obvious all along. If you have the money and effort you’re pouring into that, couldn’t you do something more useful for the world instead? That’s why I dislike it. Let me close by naming the one thing within labor-sharing that I do think is “fine.” It’s a service built around people who hold professional skills — in other words, a service that improves the rate at which they encounter clients. In certain professions, particularly ones tied to a fixed physical location, many people with professional skills end up confined within that space. In my own experience, that’s cram-school instructors. Others include doctors, nurses, hairdressers, teachers, caregivers, counselors, and so on. The scope of the service they can offer is limited, because the work happens inside a fixed location. Customer flow is fixed and changes little. And managing that flow — whether to advertise, whether to partner with someone, and so on — is the employer’s job, not the individual professional’s. But in reality, I think there are plenty of situations where professional skill goes to waste as idle time. If some kind of paradigm shift — a change in awareness and understanding — were applied here, it could become a wonderful service, one that opens the industry’s eyes. In other words, this isn’t simple labor-sharing — it’s putting a skill, an idle asset, to use. What’s the actual difference, someone might reasonably ask. So let me add a slightly deeper explanation from libertarianism to clarify. The proper definition of a functioning free market is that transactions occur at prices both parties find acceptable. But in reality, most market transactions don’t work that way. The price tag is set in advance, and the choice is “buy or don’t buy” — yes or no. I wouldn’t call that oppressive or coercive, but the degree of freedom involved is clearly low. Consumers often don’t have enough range of choice to determine the price of what they’re buying, and sellers, too, are often denied real freedom by things like excessive cost-cutting competition. Professional skill is what can break that pre-arranged balance. A hairdresser in high demand among Hollywood celebrities, for instance, is said to earn over $10,000 for a single appointment. Whether that fee actually matches their skill isn’t really the libertarian’s concern. As long as the market offers sufficient choice and the transaction rests on mutual agreement between both parties, that’s precisely an example of “long live capitalism.” In the hairdresser’s case, I think that explanation suffices. The same is largely true for engineers (in America, at least). I see a real possibility here. But I won’t go further into it than that for now. Well then. I’ve twisted this argument around in all sorts of directions, but if it helps sort out the thinking of anyone who’s felt a similar unease, I’ll be glad.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2020/02/330/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.