Clarify Who Actually Owns The Project
A common pattern among early-stage companies built around a technical seed is that
it’s often unclear from the conversation who actually owns the project or product.
Ideally, one person should hold all of the following at once:
- the aptitude to make management decisions and bear responsibility for them
- the largest equity stake
- the highest level of commitment
- the deepest knowledge of industry information and customer needs
In a company that has matured to some degree, these roles are often split among different people, but in an early-stage company, especially a startup, it’s strongly desirable that one person hold them all. A spinout project, conversely, often underperforms precisely because some of the above (especially equity) stays with the parent company, leaving the team on the ground without enough to work with.
A company built around a technical seed can take many forms, but in most cases “the person most knowledgeable about industry information and customer needs” is simply whoever spent years accumulating that technology. A researcher stays with a single theme for five years, ten years, sometimes a whole career, so they inevitably become deeply versed in the industry and build a deep network.
The “capability” a manager needs also changes by stage. Note that I’m saying “capability,” not “aptitude.” Aptitude here means an innate trait or one cultivated over many years; capability simply means what that person can actually do.
Once revenue reaches a certain scale, the main capability a CEO needs becomes building financial strategy, or exercising sound judgment within that domain: how to raise capital, deploy it into investment, build a cycle to recover it, review that cycle, and keep improving it. Building a network, negotiating with large companies on equal footing, and securing deals favorable to one’s own company also start to matter.
The capability an early-stage manager needs is a bit different in kind:
- the judgment to handle all manner of events faster and more accurately than anyone else
- the drive to keep a project moving even if you end up completely alone
If you belong to a company that is still early-stage, and you’re not the one in the ownership position, and yet you find yourself thinking,
“Wait… all of this describes me,”
then the way your company was set up has already failed.
If it’s not too late, start by fixing that setup. If it is too late, get out, fast.
As a kind of “runner-up,” nice-to-have addendum, I’ll add:
- the power to get others fired up and pull them in (call it con-artist power, lol)
- the delusional power to surrender to a kind of obsession that says “I’m the only one who can do this”
Plenty of startup managers do more than fine without these, of course, but regardless of how they’re used, they’re favorable powers to have.
I’ve reached something of an old-timer’s age myself, and I’ve seen my fair share of people placed in unfortunate positions. One particular cluster among them stands out: every single one of them is being exploited.
A state of exploitation is one where the balance between risk and reward is unreasonably skewed. The typical case pushes excessive responsibility onto someone without giving them sufficient authority or reward in return, and frankly, that describes most cases.
If you reading this happen to be a salaried employee, let me offer one prescription that works well. If your position is genuinely that of a salaried employee, then “responsibility” in your case doesn’t actually amount to much, and your degree of freedom is, relatively speaking, far greater. All you need to do is notice that. Once you recognize it correctly, a happy salaryman life awaits.
But in a startup, where people sacrifice their career, income, time, lifestyle, and in some cases everything, it’s lamentable when the reality turns out to be exploitation. A company, organization, system, or project like that can’t possibly work out in the end, so there’s nothing to do but cut your losses quickly. Unfortunately.
So here’s the important point for avoiding that:
Don’t let the founding of the company be vague and unresolved.
Nobody wants to drag out endless discussion and lose all momentum, so the best approach is for someone to decisively grab hold of the “should be the same person” principle stated at the top.
Don’t split it fifty-fifty. Even 6:4 falls short. Take it as 9:1, or even 10:0. That’s what makes ownership clear. In other words, whoever accepts being the 1 or the 0 in that split is thereby resolving to always keep one hand on the “eject switch” from then on.
If an owner talks in nice-sounding platitudes, take that as a sign of future exploitation.
Something like, “We’re an equal team!”
I’d trust a manager far more who says it plainly instead:
“This is my company, so when push really comes to shove, I’m sorry but I’ll make the final call. There may be times my actions look unilateral. Anyone unhappy with that should leave now. But anyone who believes in me, please stay and lend a hand.”
That’s the kind of manager I’d trust. If it were me.
I don’t know an effective way to restore ownership that has been unjustly taken away to how it rightfully should be. It’s probably too case-by-case for anyone to have a formulated answer. In most cases there’s a gap in perception that can’t be closed.
That gap shows up on both the risk side and the reward side.
“Something this small doesn’t even count as risk.” “A reward this size is an exceptionally generous deal.” “It makes no sense to hand over this kind of right.” “Of course you’d bear this much responsibility.”
These usually depend heavily on past experience (the people who, in the past, agreed to that level of risk and reward with them) and on personal values. There’s some nonzero chance that, over a long stretch of time, through patient persuasion or by showing them a different world, after no end of struggle, they’ll change their mind.
But our lives are too short to wait patiently for that kind of miracle.
Author Profile
![]() | Yuichiro “kuz” Kuzuryu Engineer / Manager Has fallen into all manner of valleys of death, from launching new businesses inside major Japanese corporations to Silicon Valley startups. CEO, Founder, ClayTech Inc. Director, EYS-STYLE Inc. Director, 144Lab Inc. Visiting Professor, Tohoku University Also serves as technical advisor/advisor to several other companies https://twitter.com/qzuryu https://www.facebook.com/qzuryu https://www.linkedin.com/in/yuichiro-kuzuryu-kuz-27b92838/ |
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2019/10/249/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.
