Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Incorporating Early Pays Off Even Before the Startup Decision Is Final

You have an idea. You’re torn about whether to start a startup. You want to try some prototyping and experiments.

If that’s your situation, you should go ahead and incorporate for now.

There are several clear benefits, and the only downside is that it costs money.

First, let’s clear up a few things that a lot of people seem to misunderstand.

< Registration barely takes any time >

For the specifics, there are plenty of blog posts and local government explainer pages you can check, but roughly speaking the annoying parts are: making a company seal, thinking up a company name, and opening a corporate bank account. For reference, I decided “I’d better do it” on April 3rd and had the company registered by April 5th.

< If all you’ve done is form the company, the tax paperwork isn’t hard >

If your company has just launched, you don’t even need to hire a tax accountant yet. You should file blue-form returns, so you do need to keep proper books, but an existing service like Money Forward or freee handles that just fine. Filing corporate tax returns is something you should hand off to a professional once things get more complex, but up until that point you can handle it yourself. Going into more detail here would start to look like tax advice, which is illegal, so I’ll leave it at that.

So incorporation itself isn’t that big a deal. The roughly $1,800 or so for the general procedures is probably the biggest cost of it.

Now, let’s organize the benefits. Broadly speaking they break down into:

< Practical benefits >

Once you incorporate, your stakeholders become clear from the outside. Suppose someone takes an interest in your business plan and considers investing. No matter how many engineer team members or advisors you have, what they ultimately need to check first is who the shareholders and founding members are. Registering a company means recording all of that clearly in numbers, so there’s no room left for argument.

But if your status is instead “I’m planning to start a company at some point, timing TBD,” outside people can’t read who the stakeholders are, and it’s not immediately clear to them what kind of support would actually help your company.

That causes real practical confusion. Deciding on something — even provisionally — and changing it later is far better than deciding nothing at all. That’s the standard playbook for most things in the world.

< Tax benefits >

I’ll leave the details to specialist books, but the big benefit is carrying forward losses.

Deficits can be carried forward for the next 10 years. Once you start a company you realize that a surprising number of things count as expenses — that is, deductible losses.

In other words, if you start a company this year, your spending on goods, travel, technical research costs, conference registration fees, and so on are all deductible losses. Naturally, you won’t have any revenue at first, so you’ll run a clear deficit, but even if you succeed the following year and turn a profit, last year’s accumulated losses can be deducted from this year’s profit. So if the numbers line up well, you end up not having to pay corporate tax. The important thing is that incorporating means being ready to take advantage of the benefits incorporation offers, and that’s a huge difference from operating at the level of mere individual activity. The basic idea behind this is simple:

if people stop starting companies, the economy ends.

Government officials, including bureaucrats, know this very well, so in that sense incorporation comes loaded with preferential treatment. I really hope people make good use of it.

From another angle, there’s also the benefit of consumption tax exemption for the first two fiscal periods when you set up a company, and this is something you definitely want to grab if you have solid prospects of generating revenue right away. But if a startup with no near-term revenue prospects decides, with great fanfare, “Now’s the time — two periods of exemption!” and then doesn’t actually generate meaningful revenue, that ends up looking pretty embarrassing. And since revenue under $92,000 is continuously exempt from consumption tax anyway, shifting the timing of founding your company just to capture this benefit seems a bit pointless.

< Psychological benefits >

One point is getting used to it.

Generally, “starting a company” sounds like you’re stepping into something outrageous, but in reality, incorporating is something that’s been repeated routinely, countless times, throughout the history of human activity, everywhere.

I once read in some book that, aside from “line employee = no title,” the most common title among Japan’s population is “representative director and president.” I don’t know if that’s true or not (it was that kind of reliability of a book), but it’s an apt way of putting it regardless. Apparently Japan sees somewhere between 100,000 and 130,000 new business registrations a year. That means roughly 1 in 1,000 people in the population starts a company this year. Narrow the age range somewhat and it’s more like 1 in 500–600 people starting a company this year. My middle school had around 200 students per grade, which works out to roughly one of my middle school classmates starting a company every 2 or 3 years. That’s the scale of thing we’re talking about.

It’s not a big deal. Just go ahead and incorporate and become president.

Also, by forming a company, you come to genuinely understand, through firsthand experience, the benefits of forming a company, as already mentioned. That’s an asset you can use for life. Once you become president, plenty of people go on to form one subsidiary after another, or joint ventures and so on. Once you’re used to it, it’s no big deal, and since there are real benefits, everyone realizes there’s no reason not to use them.

Another point is preventing “all talk, no action” syndrome.

I spent my own stretch as a corporate salaryman, so I understand this well: there are plenty of talented people all around you, and quite a few people who are full of hope, ambitious, able to see the big picture, and skilled at looking ahead to the future. But even among them, a huge gap opens up.

It’s “people who do” versus “people who don’t.”

People who do, keep doing. As if it were the most natural thing in the world. As if there were no other option.

People who don’t, just talk about it and never actually do it. Every single time, they don’t do it. They always find some excuse not to.

People who do sometimes bail after starting, sometimes fail spectacularly and laugh it off sheepishly, and sometimes suddenly pivot in a completely different direction while “still” pressing on.

People who don’t, stagnate. They don’t change. This year, next year, the year after — nothing changes. Forever unchanging.

Just do it first, reflect later. That’s it.

I know perfectly well that reading a piece of writing like this isn’t going to make 9 out of 10 people think “I’ll start a company tomorrow!” (if it somehow did, I’d love for the Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry to fund my activities). So I’ll be happy if this serves as even a small message to those who don’t yet know about the idea of just going ahead and incorporating.

On the benefits of “just going ahead and incorporating”


Author Profile

Yuichiro Kuzuryu, Engineer/Executive. Has fallen into every kind of valley of death imaginable, from launching new businesses at major Japanese corporations to Silicon Valley startups. CEO & Founder, ClayTech Inc. Director, EYS-STYLE Inc. Director, 144Lab Inc. Visiting Professor, Tohoku University. Also serves as technical advisor/advisor for several other companies. https://twitter.com/qzuryu https://www.facebook.com/qzuryu https://www.linkedin.com/in/yuichiro-kuzuryu-kuz-27b92838/

Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2019/09/241/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.