Don't let your shares get taken
Share ratio matters enormously to every stock company’s management, not just startups.
Even an elementary school student knows that much. The important thing is
what you should do when you receive an investment.
Naturally it depends on the stage. Let me briefly state my definitions of the stages (I’ll leave the academic ones to the textbooks), roughly:
- Seed (nobody really understands the market yet, but my concept is amazing!)
- Series A (market launch is possible or right around the corner)
- Series B (launch is done, now you want to scale. Business-wise, this means overseas expansion or new business challenges)
- Series C and beyond (from here it’s just convenience labeling. There’s no particular meaning to C, D, E, etc.)
From Series B onward there’s a degree of just going with the flow, but there’s no need to be too guarded, because the investors who led your Seed or Series A round (the investors or VCs who ran point on each stage) will support you. (I’ll say that much here. There are fears specific to Series B onward too, but that’s a topic for another time.)
In other words, let’s target Seed and, at most, Series A here. The people who come to me for advice are mostly at this stage, so I trust this is consistent with the needs of readers of this blog too.
First, one important point:
Consult someone who has no stake in the outcome.
This means: seek an objective opinion. Put bluntly, most startup founders hand over their early shares at a far too disadvantageous ratio. This is where the gap between those with experience and those without becomes overwhelming. When I’m asked for advice and I respond with something like “hmm, if the prototype is at this level now and the investment is this much, around this percentage should be fine,” I often get asked “Huh? Is that really okay?” Sometimes people even get defensive and snap back, in the tone of: “There’s no way that’s possible! If I say that, the investor I finally landed will run away! What are you talking about!”
This is a textbook case of sunk cost falla— (I won’t spell it all out).
A startup founded by student friends, each of whom was thriving as a promising young employee at a major company with a bright future ahead, throws all that away to jump into the startup world. The business model is solid, they’ve secured engineers they trust, and the prototype is on track — but the money, they just need to raise it somehow right now. This happens all the time.
I get it, I really do. But that’s exactly where patience is required.
Investors are financiers, a kind of market professional. The essence of their business is buying cheap in bulk and selling high at the right time, and that itself is a quintessentially capitalist act. Since the East India Company, without the power of aristocrats and conglomerates investing in the risk-sharing system called the “joint-stock company,” the accelerating technological innovation after the Industrial Revolution would never have happened, and without the development of investment banking, capitalism might well have suffered an unexpected setback during the era when socialist thinking once ran rampant. These things deserve great respect, and they’re a wonderful part of history.
But here, they are your business counterparty, so you must stay shrewd. Yet being told to “stay shrewd” probably doesn’t help much. So ask someone. Someone with experience.
It’s simple. If you’re a startup founder, there’s probably someone close to you who recently succeeded in raising funds. There may even be a senior figure who has already gone through Series A and B. Ask them. Ask about their own failures and successes. Doing so will give you a sense of market rates and clarify what you do and don’t actually want. I don’t want to spell out the answer, so please go find it yourself.
Next, one important point:
Don’t assume equity funding is everything.
Taken literally, this means not just raising funds by handing over shares, but also keeping debt financing in view, and also making use of grants and various subsidies. The importance of angel investor support in the early stage can’t be ignored either. Some angels call themselves that explicitly (though apparently there are few in Japan), while others are simply wealthy individuals in substance. The reason they’re called “angels” is that they take almost no equity. (This is purely my personal view, but if someone calling themselves an angel wants 30% or 40% of the company for a Seed investment of a few million yen, that is without question a devil wearing an angel’s skin. I’d bet on it.) Looking at the Series A or B stage, after some dilution has occurred, they typically hold only around 1%, or at most a few percent, of the shares. And yet they may have invested a few million, or in some cases tens of millions, of yen. They really are nothing short of angels. (Well, some care is needed not to inflate the valuation too much.) So, the important thing, in short, is this:
The money you need right in front of you is, in the end, mere “pocket change,” and it isn’t worth selling your soul — your shares — in exchange for it. Well, even if hearing that doesn’t immediately click into place, read this and stop to think for a moment.
That’s the point. There are also other options, like equity loans (if you repay the money you don’t lose shares, and the repayment terms and interest rates are extremely favorable), or taking on outsourced work for a while as a stopgap. Starting a company while staying a salaried employee is also a perfectly legitimate option. Be careful not to narrow your view too much and sell yourself short.
Next, let me close by answering the question (complaint): “Why do I need to care about this so much (what a hassle).” First, from a general perspective:
Nobody knows exactly when or how they’ll hit the 33% wall, so be excessively cautious about it in the early stage.
33% is veto power. Falling below a simple majority is one thing, but losing your veto power means that if the other shareholders ever band together, they can not only fire you at any time but even overturn the entire direction of the business. This is an extremely frightening prospect. Of course, many company executives hold well under 33%. But that’s only true of “companies that are generating stable profits.” If you’re betting everything each year on make-or-break outcomes while thinking “I might get fired this year,” you can’t take the bold risks needed. That’s out of the question.
Now, next, from a personal perspective:
Forget about VCs or random individual investor guys — you all should become millionaires and billionaires.
When a company IPOs, the shareholder registry and ratios become public. If you want to look, you can see it from end to end (that’s exactly what “public” means). It’s not something I particularly enjoy looking at, so I only glance at it occasionally when I happen to be curious. And fairly often, it leaves me feeling rather gloomy, which is why I don’t really want to look. In short, it comes down to: “Why does this person hold such a ratio?” and “Why does this person hold such a low ratio?” Very simple. Of course, I know nothing about the internal circumstances of the company, nor its history — at most I know whatever rumors circulate in the industry. But it’s clear that sometimes a VC holds an outrageously large block of shares (since the investment amount and timing are usually already public, you can form a rough mental picture), while a student founder — the “brilliant young engineer!” — holds an unbelievably tiny sliver.
It’s deeply unfortunate.
Of course, from a business standpoint, “the one who ended up holding more” simply “played it well” and deserves credit for that (having made it all the way to an IPO, that evaluation isn’t going to waver). But since I very rarely get asked for advice by people on that side of the table, I’ll basically speak from the founder’s side here. And from that standpoint, I have to say it’s deeply unfortunate. The startup industry as a whole has something of a mutual-aid quality to it — someone once said “there’s no such thing as a startup industry,” but I think Silicon Valley actually had one. The circulation of talent, the circulation of capital, the sharing of information, a framework that builds trends together almost like a community. In other words, a robust “ecosystem” existed. In that respect too, support on the funding side in particular is a form of risk diversification, and a mechanism where those with capital shoulder that risk is the very philosophy of the joint-stock company itself. So why can’t “investment in the future” be built into that philosophy as well?
Forget about VCs or random individual investor guys — you all should become millionaires and billionaires.
Americans — Silicon Valley people, at least — liked the concept of risk and reward. So who is taking on the biggest risk when a startup is founded? Naturally, the answer differs depending on which axis you use for comparison, so it isn’t a simple question in general. But here I want to deliberately simplify it as follows:
how much of what you have did you put on the line
Founders, in most cases, have neither money nor status. What they have is only time and possibility. We must never forget to respect those who bet 100% of that. Conversely, what about a guy with tens of billions of yen in total assets who puts in, say, $280,000? $280,000 is a huge sum for an ordinary person, and for a newly founded startup it’s precious cash to keep it running for a while. But for that wealthy guy, it’s unmistakably pocket change. That’s not quite the right phrase — it’s unmistakably “a tiny fraction of his investment funds.” For example, if at that moment the share ratio ended up at 6:4, how would that look in everyone’s eyes? It’s like slapping someone’s cheek with a wad of cash. It’s hard to greet that with much respect.
I’m well aware that, from the fundamental principles of capitalism, this feels like an odd thing to say. But in the “startup industry,” where the central concern is “how do we make things succeed” and “how do we create the future,” I believe we should seriously think, day to day, about how to accumulate success stories and plant seeds for the future.
That’s what grows the ecosystem and builds competitiveness.
It’s said that most of Google’s early members became angel investors using the fortunes they gained at IPO.
That’s the kind of depth that makes the difference.
Author Profile
![]() | Yuichiro Kuzuryu, Engineer/Executive Has fallen into numerous valleys of death, from launching new businesses at major Japanese corporations to Silicon Valley startups. CEO, Founder, ClayTech Inc. Director, EYS-STYLE Inc. Director, 144Lab Inc. Visiting Professor, Tohoku University Also serves as technical advisor to several other companies https://twitter.com/qzuryu https://www.facebook.com/qzuryu https://www.linkedin.com/in/yuichiro-kuzuryu-kuz-27b92838/ |
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2019/09/195/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.
