Startups Should Embrace Looking Unpolished
“Trying too hard to seem switched-on” usually describes someone who fusses over every little detail, picks branded or stylish items even for small accessories or near-disposable tools, eats lunch at upscale cafés, and invests heavily in self-improvement, cultural refinement, and health with intense interest and self-consciousness — and who makes no attempt to hide any of it. In fact, they show it off proudly.
The character trait that naturally comes attached to this, I think, is something like “brimming with confidence, sailing smoothly.”
I especially want people at startups to be the opposite — not switched-on but “switched-off.” That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t own anything branded, or that instant noodles are fine for lunch, or that you should write code instead of wasting time on self-improvement.
What I want to touch on is mainly a matter of mentality, and it concerns
stumbling, which is inseparable from startups.
The “learning through validation” that gets talked about so much in concepts like Lean Startup isn’t limited to early-stage startups. It’s essential, inevitable really, a baptismal gate that any “organization that takes on uncertain things” has to pass through. But learning is often accompanied by pain, by setbacks. At that moment the switched-on type thinks
“This isn’t how it was supposed to go.”
The switched-off type is fine with it.
“Well, this is about where we’re at right now. We’re still just getting started!”
Which of the two actually believes in themselves, in their team, more? The former is close to mere arrogance. Everyone fails somewhere, and the probability of failure naturally rises the more recklessly you take on uncertain territory. Everyone knows this.
To think “but we’ll be fine” is exactly the thinking of a gambling addict. “There’s no way this can go any lower.” “There’s no way I miss all 12 races.” “Someone’s bound to scratch this horse.” That kind of thinking, when facing uncertain outcomes, is a sickness — a sickness unto death.
You will fail. So will I. So will we. We’ll end up looking pathetic. We’ll get hurt. We’ll get cursed out. That’s just how it is.
Even a startup that has raised tens of millions of dollars within a few years of founding and ballooned to 50 employees is, as an organization, still a toddler a few years old at best. No matter how skillful, accomplished, or polished a team you assemble, poke around inside and you’ll find the reality is bound to be a complete mess. Mistake that for “we’re the real deal” and it hurts badly when you fall into a hole. In other words, the recommendation to stay switched-off isn’t about dragging yourself down with negative thinking. It’s essentially a startup-specific discipline, born from the self-admonition “don’t get carried away,” which in turn says “if you don’t properly build up what needs building up, there’s no tomorrow.”
Hold onto hunger together with ambition and a low self-assessment, and that actually becomes your strongest weapon.
I once had the chance to go to Israel and met various people there. One thing they all had in common was a “low self-assessment” paired with the conviction “but when it comes to innovation, we won’t lose.” The self-assessment here is about the country as a whole. They genuinely seemed to think their own country was in a precarious state. That’s different from pride — pride is sometimes groundless, something already inherent rather than built up through achievement. Their sense that Israel as a country is at risk was simply the conclusion of objective insight. They think the country itself is in danger. So they work hard. If they don’t, they believe the country will simply vanish — and that they themselves will die along with it.
As I wrote in the piece about Paolo Maldini —
https://clazytech.com/2014/02/89/
— it’s a very good thing to constantly be losing, or on the verge of losing. You can see the heights still ahead precisely because of it.
Still not there.
Not good enough.
Still to come.
This is the correct, innovative mentality.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2018/02/435/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.