Skipping investment and an IPO is the better path for founders
The hardest thing in the early stage of a startup is probably fundraising. Something like “XX raised $YY million through a third-party allocation of new shares to ZZ.” Sounds cool, doesn’t it. It really does. But you’re better off not taking outside investment. You might think “come on, are you an idiot,” but that’s the truth. Absolute fact number one. There are a few points here, so let me lay them out.
Taking investment is like getting married. Actually, sometimes it’s worse
Taking investment is like a marriage where polygamy is allowed. Calling it a shared fate sounds nice, but you take on responsibility to a family, you have to spend time on the household, and you have to listen sincerely to your wife’s requests or there’s no domestic peace. But if the wife is heading in the wrong direction, you have to point it out — you can’t just let it slide. You end up carrying the whole bundle of hurdles, troubles, and noise that comes with an ordinary household. With some other guy’s old man thrown in. Lol. This takes a fair amount of courage, but depending on how it goes, you can end up with a wonderful encounter and a happy, peaceful future — if you focus on the good parts. Focus on the bad parts instead, and the other side’s “well-meaning” actions become an unwelcome burden, their “well-meaning” intervention becomes a brake, or their “well-meaning” move is to liquidate the company. Lol. Communication between spouses matters. You have to align direction, make clear what you can compromise on and what you can’t, and always move forward hand in hand, trusting each other. It’s genuinely hard work. And divorce isn’t easy.
Giving up shares is like shaving off a piece of your life
Ask founders to compare shares to something, and most would probably say they’re the company’s life. You have to protect them, but unless you bet your life, life never opens up. That’s probably how everyone feels. Shares carry various rights depending on their class and ratio. An easy example is “veto power” over resolutions — a situation where a major resolution can’t pass without that person’s consent. There’s also “voting rights,” the right to participate in resolutions, though the influence depends on the share ratio. There’s also “the right to propose resolutions.” And to get more granular, some people have “the right to attend board meetings,” while others only have “the right to read the board minutes.” Authority within a company is defined by shares, and the company runs based on that. That’s what a “stock corporation” is. Conversely, there are obligations like “must be included in consolidated accounting,” but I’ll leave that to specialist books. When a company is founded, the founder holds all the shares. As investment comes in, the ratio gradually shrinks — up to 51% it’s still the founder’s company, but once you’ve been through a certain number of rounds, that drops below 50%. The moment no single person holds a majority, politics is born. In the first round, the founder will still hold most of the shares. But that’s the moment the founder commits to that path. Unless you’re prepared to fight your way through your own political stage round after round, with whatever strategy that takes, you shouldn’t transfer shares. Well, I’ve written some scary-sounding stuff, but the point is also: if it’s worth that level of risk, go ahead and take the investment. One complaint: in a situation like “won a contest and got tens of thousands of dollars in investment,” handing over 20% or 30% of your shares is the height of folly. It’s like someone drowning in debt borrowing from a loan shark against their own organs just to cover the interest on a current loan. Maybe it’s a different story if you’re pushed to the point where your life is at stake tomorrow or the day after, but at the very least, starting a company isn’t that kind of situation. Watch out for selling yourself cheap. For anyone who’s followed the logic so far, there’s nothing new to say about IPOs. It’s exactly the same story. And compared to taking investment, with an IPO your marriage partner becomes “an unspecified multitude.” That’s an enormous risk.
IPO or not?
So why does everyone IPO? There are two reasons. One is that fundraising through any means other than an IPO has become difficult. A few reasons can produce this situation. A wonderful one, often seen in Silicon Valley, is that the company has gotten so big that no one can invest anymore. For example, once a company reaches the scale of pre-IPO Facebook, even investing hundreds of millions of dollars wouldn’t get you even 1% of the shares. For the investor, there’s barely any merit left in investing in such a company. And Facebook, for its part, doesn’t want just hundreds of millions either — if it’s going to take money, it wants more. At that point the amount needed becomes something no one can provide. So an IPO becomes the only option. That’s a very healthy case. So, is fundraising really necessary? That’s something you need to think about seriously. For a reasonably mature company, the answer is probably no in most cases. If you need cash on hand, borrowing is generally preferable. For a company with some track record, that shouldn’t be a problem. For an early-stage company, there are options like grants. If you’re aiming for a major pivot in the business and need large-scale funding for it, you should first consider selling off part of the business. Anyone who wants the convenient outcome of keeping both isn’t suited to taking on risk capital in the first place. So why IPO even in such cases? That’s the other reason: EXIT. There are more varied meanings and structures within the definition of EXIT, but what I mean here is essentially that founders and early-stage shareholders sell off their shares. As I said earlier, shares are equivalent to life itself. Selling them off means — to put it kindly, setting off for the next phase, or to put it bluntly, the founder has no more attachment to the company. What’s commonly called a “listing as the goal” is exactly this. I don’t deny this feeling at all. Starting a company and running an early-stage business is no ordinary hardship. Reaching the goal after nearly breaking down countless times, nearly giving up countless times, wanting to just quit already countless times — it’s completely understandable to want to finally take it easy. And the company gets reorganized once and heads toward its next phase. Whether it survives that can’t be judged from its pre-listing self, because by then it’s effectively a different company. Of course there are cases where this doesn’t happen. Cases where the founder and other major shareholders barely let go of shares at the time of the IPO, so the management environment is unaffected. Or cases where the founder didn’t hold much of a stake to begin with, but continues to reign unchanged through sheer charisma and trust. Incidentally, the earlier case of “the company got too big” often falls into the latter category. Which makes sense when you think about it. Depending on the pattern, the decision to IPO is extremely difficult. Many companies start sinking right after their IPO. So if your own company is in a solid state — the business is doing well and you can fund forward investment out of your own surplus cash — there’s basically no need to even consider an IPO. An IPO as a goal certainly exists. But whether it leads the company to sustained growth or becomes a brake instead is the real question. An IPO is not some sufficient condition for making the company, or yourself, happy.
Think about the other side’s feelings
But… Let’s go back to the marriage analogy. What does the marriage partner think? Investment is executed by weighing the sum — no, the product, no, the least common multiple — of various intentions. The intention topping the list, of course, is capital gain. If I start listing the other intentions there’s no end to it, so I’ll skip that. What do you need to do to get capital gain? Sell the shares. And what do you need to do to sell the shares? Unlisted shares aren’t something you can just casually sell off whenever you like. Naturally, following the proper procedures and proper consents usually means you need “a sufficient reason to sell.” Thinking simply about it, reasons like “I’ve lost interest in this company’s business and want to pull out” or “our fund’s term is approaching and we want to liquidate and be done with it here” aren’t a cool story. Not something that makes everyone happy. When it comes to unlisted share transactions, a common example is an MBO, but an MBO’s purpose is usually “capital separation from a large corporation or holding company,” which is a bit different from what we’re discussing here. So the marriage partner’s real feeling is: “I kind of wish you’d EXIT around the 5- or 6-year mark since founding…” Even if the wife says “one child is enough,” she might see young siblings happily playing together at the park and find herself wanting another one after all. The husband might say “I always put family first” while secretly wanting to go drinking with coworkers once in a while and throw up on the platform at Shimbashi Station. Well, you’ve got to pick up on that sort of thing. A bit of a tangent, but a VC’s mission, outwardly, is to buy a company’s shares cheap, grow them, sell them off, and profit. But the people inside don’t think of it that way and wouldn’t say so either. They do their work feeling the social significance of properly circulating financial assets by helping people who are opening up new business frontiers. That dilemma sometimes shows through, and of course there are VCs who don’t even bother hiding it. I heard about a friend’s past startup that took seed funding (a few hundred thousand dollars) from a Singapore-based VC, and about a month later was asked, with a completely straight face, “So, when’s the IPO?” — apparently quite a shock. So once you’re married, you can’t decide the number of children purely on your own will, and the couple should properly discuss together when it’s okay to go drinking and when it’s not. That’s basically the situation.
In the first place,
I think the motivation for becoming a startup CEO, or getting involved in running a startup, differs from person to person. But what’s commonly at the base is probably the desire to realize a feeling like “this is how I’d do it,” “I think this would sell in this field if it were me,” “this is the kind of organization I’d build.” It’s just that the shape of that “feeling” differs for each person. “This is how I’d change the world” — maybe it can be summed up in one line like that. Needless to say, choosing the right partners is extremely important to realizing it. Co-founders, launch team members, executives, engineers, partner companies, advisors, and also VCs and investors. You want to find someone you can respect, someone who can share the vision with you. If, unluckily, you can’t find such a person, there’s no option of just settling for whoever happens to be nearby.
Does a startup fly while carrying the burden of investment? Does an IPO become a stepping stone to becoming a big corporation?
You hear all sorts of stories about good marriages in various places. “XX is the lead of our seed round, but they never interfere with our decision-making at all, which really helps. On top of that, they’ve said they want to participate in the next round too. We’ve built a relationship of trust.” “When we first launched, we didn’t have anyone on the team with hardware know-how, but through investment from XX we got connected to a network, and in the end we were able to find a good EMS.” “If XX hadn’t come in, there’s no way we could have IPO’d. Their know-how is amazing.” And so on. Marriage is a natural part of life, with both good and bad sides. That’s why everyone does it. But the decisive difference between a company’s investment relationships and a human marriage is this: “A child (a product) can come into being without a marriage partner (an investment partner).” If you thought “isn’t that true for people too?” — you might be French. Lol. Actually this is a good point. The reason there are so many common-law marriages in France (and in Western countries more broadly, not just France) is that you can get sufficient social security through a common-law marriage without marrying at all. Things like how easy it is for single mothers with children to work are also worlds apart from Japan. In other words: if social support (financial breathing room, people, technology) is sufficient, a child (product) can be created without marriage (investment) at all. This is an obvious thing. Why bother stating something so obvious? It’s to avoid narrowing your field of vision by thinking in terms of “investment first.” Let me add one more obvious thing at the end. A business started with its own funds hits one success after another and quickly becomes profitable. After running it for a year, the surplus funds generated get put into a new business, which is a hit again. Repeat this cycle a few times and you end up as one of the world’s leading companies — but never IPO, because there’s just no merit in it. Needless to say, this is the highest form of success. In other words, you’re happier without either investment or an IPO. That’s the absolute fact.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2017/05/428/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.