Irrationality Can Be Forgiven, Inconsistency Cannot
Irrationality and inconsistency are both generally disliked, but when it comes to whether someone can be trusted, they are completely different things.
Here’s how an irrational person tends to be disliked. If it’s a superior: unreasonable, abuse of power, impossible targets, plans whose purpose is unclear, “that guy just acts important but doesn’t actually understand anything.” If it’s a subordinate: inefficient, doesn’t follow the boss’s instructions, keeps doing unrelated things, hard to manage.
Here’s how an inconsistent person tends to be disliked. All talk and no action, “that guy’s story keeps changing depending on the time and place,” or: last week the boss said “make a more detailed document,” so you made one, and now he barely glances at it and says “just tell me the conclusion in a nutshell.”
That’s the general pattern.
The word “irrational” (不合理) negates “rational” (合理), and “rational” literally means being in accordance with “logic” (理). That logic might be mathematical, physical, or psychological depending on the time and situation, or some combination of these. In fact, it’s a very unstable thing.
The word “inconsistent” (不整合) negates “consistent” (整合), but consistency just means being coherent from start to finish. Whether the act or choice is right or wrong, whether it benefits society or not, falls outside the discussion. In other words, this one is actually a very simple thing.
Whether something is irrational depends on your point of view. Facebook, famously, started as a service open only to Harvard students. From the perspective of “growing the user base,” that’s clearly irrational. But the result was that it expanded to the Ivy League next, then further, and eventually — as you know — became a global service. Airbnb didn’t use the internet or social media to find its first hosts. Sales team members visited landlords one by one, door to door, to negotiate. There’s no shortage of examples where taking an action that’s obviously irrational for the sake of scaling turned out, conversely, to be exactly what enabled the scaling.
In other words, these are only “apparently irrational.” Within the person themselves, the logic holds together. It’s just that other people can’t understand it, or can’t accept it. But in most cases, ignorant critics dismiss situations like this outright as “irrational.” In other words, when it comes to approaches to problems without clear answers, matters concerning the future, or unknown challenges, there’s no need to worry about whether other people find it irrational. Frankly, that worry is wasted effort.
Believe in yourself. That’s it.
Inconsistency, on the other hand, is very serious. Your character gets called into question, and no one trusts you. And more often than not, the inconsistent person doesn’t notice their own inconsistency. That’s because they’ve fabricated “consistency” inside their own head. For example, even an inconsistency like “saying something different yesterday than today” might feel, to that person, consistent — consistent with a rule like “always say whatever puts my own interest first.” Someone who readily steals other people’s ideas and achievements might also, in their own mind, feel it’s consistent with something like “whose achievement it was isn’t the essential question — the only thing that matters is reliably launching a good service for society.”
What these actually are is this:
A mix-up between “consistency” and “rationality.”
They push through, crushing and ignoring their own inconsistency with some plausible-sounding “logic.” Living this way is, naturally, full of contradictions and close to collapse. People who got promoted but are hated by their subordinates, people who succeeded socially but have terrible family relationships — in most cases, I think they’re just paying the price for inconsistencies they sowed somewhere along the way. Inconsistency is betrayal, and it is self-protection. It produces nothing.
Irrationality: fine. Inconsistency: not fine.
And most of what the world calls innovation lies within irrationality.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2016/10/87/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.