Prize-money pitch contests turn out to be investment in disguise
It’s been a while since I wrote in this series, but I just witnessed “the fruit of years of work,” so here goes.
Some background: my wife graduated from the nursing department of a medical university, worked as a nurse, then married me and got dragged off to America against her will — your standard “ordinary former nurse housewife.” She craves stability above all, is conservative, and would happily settle for a quiet life in the countryside. I do feel some guilt for having hauled a person like that all the way to America and forced her onto a rickety boat riding the rough waves of risk and reward. At least a bit. I think. Actually, probably more than a little.
By “ordinary” here I mean someone who doesn’t understand the internet, doesn’t understand manufacturing, obviously knows nothing about startups, and has zero otaku-like tendencies.
Maybe because I tell my wife everything about work, I’ve increasingly felt, especially these past few years, that what she says hits the mark. That’s where we stand on our 6th wedding anniversary. Amid all that, there was a particular conversation the other day.
Me: “Hey, our company was on TV earlier.” Wife: “Oh, what happened?” Me: “There’s this thing called Startup XX. We appeared because of that.” Wife: “That sounds like an impressive name.” Me: ”…The prize money was $X million.” Wife: “Prize money? Not investment?” Me: ”!!!”
I was moved by how precisely she’d nailed it. That’s right — in reality, this was investment.
For events that target this kind of startup and advertise “Prize money of $XX!”, the substance is almost always investment. At best, a grant. But grants usually come with conditions, most often in the retroactive form of “if you spend $280,000, we’ll grant you $93,000.” In other words, it amounts to: “Wait, we don’t have that kind of money to begin with!” “Ah, then shall we introduce you to a place with good interest rates?” It’s a pretty well-crafted scheme.
So what’s the difference between investment and prize money?
It’s as different as heaven and earth.
A friend of mine who’s a CEO once said: “Receiving investment is always the worst-case scenario.” I think that’s exactly right. Receiving investment means handing over shares. And what does handing over shares mean? People reach for various metaphors, but the one I find most apt is: it’s like getting married.
People often say “my wife changed after we got married,” but what changes isn’t the essential nature of either person — it’s the relationship between them. Simply dating and being affectionate is one thing; living together and building a household is quite another. In the latter, both people need to become partners bound by a shared fate, true comrades-in-arms in the real sense. That means there are parts where you can no longer lean on each other’s indulgence, and times when you must go toe-to-toe with harsh words. But it also means gaining a relationship in which you can exchange words that lay bare everything — weakness, bravado, all of it mixed together, with your guts on the table. Because of that, the bond between the two parties is strong, and it takes enormous effort to sever it.
In other words, this is how the relationship with an investor ought to be by nature. So receiving investment on a whim is as implausible as getting married on a whim. “Win the pitch contest and you can receive investment!” carries the same “it’s nice, but once you really think it through, it’s oddly uncomfortable” quality as “Win the variety show and marry XX (insert your favorite celebrity here, lol)!”
If, after an investor’s money comes in, you think “They’ll probably just complain and rush our schedule — let them talk, let them talk,” your understanding is far too naive. It really is marriage, so there’s no telling how long you’ll get to play the dominant husband, and before you know it, you might not just find yourself under your spouse’s thumb — you might find your own dinner portion has one less side dish than everyone else’s. Conversely, the view that “investors should just provide the money and nothing else” is also naive — or rather, a waste. It’s like saying “a wife just needs to keep the household running.” Marriage is, in the true sense, a shared fate. If so, it’s only natural that both sides offer ideas, sometimes act as watchdogs for each other, and provide hands-on support when needed.
The above captures only a slice of the relationship between investors and startup founders, but given all this, the act of “receiving investment” is extremely weighty. You need to carefully examine, together, whether your sensibilities and terms align in the short term, and whether you can share a vision in the long term. It’s by no means the case that “whoever has the money is superior,” nor is it the case that “while things are hot, it’s genuinely a feeding frenzy.” It’s not that simple a matter. This, too, is exactly like marriage.
One more thing before I close: in most cases, these “pitch contests with prize money” are problematic in the following respects.
- The relationship between the amount of money and the equity allocation at the time of investment is often skewed (excessively favorable to the investing side)
- The handling of intellectual property is often written in a way that is dangerous (excessively favorable to the organizer’s side) This is clearly an act of targeting and preying on startups that have technology but shallow knowledge and little experience. When I was in the US, I consulted a lawyer experienced in nurturing startups about this sort of thing, and when I showed him the documents, he said, “Are you planning to sell off your company?” That’s the level of thing casually written in there as if it were a matter of course.
Knowledge is power. If you equip yourself with enough logical armor to fight and enough toughness to withstand negotiation, and then participate in such an event with a degree of calculation — that kind of shrewdness — I think that could be worthwhile in its own right.
While writing this post at home, clacking away at my laptop in the living room— Wife: “What are you doing?” Me: “Writing a blog post.” Wife: “It’s been a while. You’re still doing that, huh (lol). So what’s the topic?” Me: “That Startup XX thing from the other day.” Wife: “The one about not winning?” Me: “No, the one about that prize-money contest.” Wife: “Ah, so it’s the story of my moment of glory (lol).” I don’t dislike this side of her. My comrade-in-arms.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2016/09/99/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.