Why Remote Work Thrives In America
This post is from the archive=backNumber
Someone asked me the other day, “Why do so many people in America work remotely?” I didn’t have much time, and looking back, I don’t think I gave a very good answer, so I’m writing it out properly here.
Let me say up front, though: just as I couldn’t come up with anything interesting on the spot, taking the time to write it out doesn’t guarantee I’ve come up with anything interesting now either. …that’s my excuse, anyway.
Part of this may just be that I worked in Silicon Valley, but a friend of mine running a startup in LA told me his whole team works remotely, and the remote employees at the company before my last one were based in Boston and Texas. I also had a friend who said “I want to live in a house with a yard,” switched to remote work without changing companies or departments, and moved to Arizona. Then there are cases like “that bridge gets jammed on my commute, so I work remote two days a week.” Honestly, the examples never stop, and my impression is that remote work has become standard across the entire United States.
This was a while back, but when Marissa Mayer, a former Google executive, became CEO of Yahoo, she made a move that revealed something interesting: America, or at least Silicon Valley, may have come full circle and reached a phase where the heavy tilt toward remote work is being reconsidered.
“Return to office for all employees starting in June” — Yahoo’s internal memo made headlines http://www.nikkei.com/article/DGXNASGM2600T_W3A220C1FF1000/
Still, the fact that this move sparked major controversy shows that remote work is still widely seen in America as a major social benefit.
So, on to the reasons for this. First, the textbook answer.
① Relative to its land area, the transportation network — including public transit — is poor ② Under a results-focused discretionary labor system, freedom in working style is guaranteed
① basically means commuting is inconvenient, leading to the extremely simple and rational idea that “if you’re going to make someone spend two hours commuting, it’s more productive to just let them work from home instead.”
② is about values around how work gets done, but in any case, I have never once seen a time card in America. People working hourly jobs at factories or stores are probably doing something close to that, but if you tried to introduce something like a “time card” for the kind of people who work in R&D or product development, you would almost certainly trigger this chain reaction:
- motivation drops
- some people start cheating
- the quality of output ends up falling and the whole thing would be scrapped in no time. The logic is simple: “If you’re telling me to commit to the short term (hours worked), then I’m not going to commit to mid- to long-term output. Because all that matters is clocking in, right?” In other words, commitment and output are the only things that matter, and no interference beyond that — whether from the company or from another individual — is acceptable. This comes from viewing the relationship between employer and employee purely as a “contractual relationship.” Take Japan as an example: say you’ve outsourced some drafting work, the deadline is this Friday, and you look at the contractor’s Facebook and it turns out they’ve been out drinking every night. Is it right to take some kind of action over that? Honestly, even in Japan that would probably be seen as overreach. The time to take action or press the person is when the drawing doesn’t show up on Friday, or when it does show up but it’s garbage. In America, the relationship between “company and employee” carries a sense that isn’t too far from this.
What I particularly felt in America was this underlying shared understanding: “The weak, the incompetent, and people who don’t use their heads have no right to survive.” It’s actually a very cold country. America may be the only developed country where people still die of pneumonia because they couldn’t afford treatment for a cold that got worse. (A certain other major country probably has plenty of that too, but I’ll leave that alone, lol.) But this same harshness is also what gives people their “market sense.” In other words, people become extremely sensitive to their own value and how the market evaluates them. They become sensitive about money, and sensitive to all kinds of benefits and discounts too. I think this is part of what keeps the American economy stable: because things are harsh, everyone keeps their antennae up. High labor mobility reinforces this as well. Changing jobs is easy, and the flip side is that layoffs are an everyday occurrence. So everyone is disciplined about raising their own value and correspondingly eager to earn a high salary, and conversely, everyone accepts as a given that a poor rating means a fall, and lives with it.
So that’s roughly the model answer.
What follows is strictly a comparison with Japanese people, but I want to raise one point about America that I’ve felt firsthand: this is why remote work works in America.
I don’t want this to be misunderstood: fundamentally, Americans are a warm, sociable people. People strike up conversations with you on the street like old friends, and if you’re picking something out at a coffee stand, some grandmother behind you will offer her recommendation. If you’re out with a kid in a stroller, probably one in ten people passing by will say something like “oh, he’s so cute.” If a pregnant woman or an elderly person is carrying something heavy, someone will always help them, and my wife says that once, when she was standing in a long line at the supermarket, everyone around her told her, “go on, go to the front!”
Being meddlesome, attentive, and full of volunteer spirit is the native temperament of Americans.
But once it comes to work, it’s as if a switch flips.
On the surface, nothing changes. People are still frank, warm, fond of communication, and friendly. But underneath that, a colleague is, in the end, a “teammate”: specifically, a fellow member of a shared fate within an organization built around a clearly defined goal, a plan, and the benefits that come from output.
Let me shift the angle for a moment: what kind of organization is actually capable of “coming together as one” to properly hit its targets?
An organization that gets along well and communicates closely?
No, that’s not it. An organization that truly comes together as one is “an organization where everyone is faithful to the mission.” Whether people get along, whether communication flows smoothly, whether everyone shows up to the drinking party, none of that matters.
Out of that comes the idea: “As long as I’m faithful to my own mission, I have no need to comment on the behavior of the person next to me.” Depending on the context, it might come out differently: “I don’t have time to comment on that.” “Rather than commenting on that, I should be working to raise the quality of my own work.” “I have no motivation to comment on that.”
This is the source of indifference in the good sense.
So when it comes to the typical shortcomings people associate with remote work, this is about as far as the thinking goes.
“It’s hard to communicate” → That excuse doesn’t fly, so people do everything they can — using tools well, breaking tasks down clearly — to make sure their own performance doesn’t drop, and they demand the same of others. Management is watching for exactly this, so people take it seriously and work hard at it.
“Discussion decreases” → Performance actually improves when discussion is cut down to the bare minimum anyway. Meetings, too, are largely unnecessary.
“You can’t tell if the other person is slacking off” → As long as the output is there, nobody cares.
“There’s no sense of team unity” → Surface-level unity isn’t needed. The real unity people are looking for exists at the crossing point reached once individual performance and output quality have been pushed to their limits. That’s enough.
When I said at the start that this “wouldn’t make for a very interesting story,” it may be because these sensibilities are so far removed from traditional Japanese organizational thinking that they come across as almost absurd.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2016/09/340/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.