Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Large Companies Give New Grads Deeper Tech, Startups Give Them Range

A junior from my university asked me about this, so I figured it was a good opportunity to organize my thoughts.
First, some background: I joined a large company as a new graduate. After eight years there, I moved to the US and joined a startup.
I’ve felt various things along the way, but to cut to the conclusion: both are valid, though in my case the flow of large company → startup happened to be the right fit.

So let me go through this item by item.

Technology

Here’s what I’d say: large companies give you more opportunities to touch technology beyond your station.

I deliberately wrote “beyond your station” because plenty of startups out there have amazing technology. But the new graduates who get into those startups are probably monsters.
A new graduate whose technical level doesn’t measure up can’t get into a startup like that, or if they do get in, they never get to touch its depths.
Large companies are different. From an “education” standpoint, they’ll have a raw newcomer do things beyond their station, with a veteran backing them up, or sometimes just letting them fail outright.
This comes down entirely to the difference in a company’s financial stamina.

This is especially true in fields that are hard to get off the ground without massive investment and long timeframes — semiconductors, materials development, pharmaceuticals, and the like — where the gap is stark.
In software, by contrast, the gap is small.

As a new graduate, I was essentially a software person. My major was electrical and electronic engineering, so of course I handled hardware, but it was a somewhat comprehensive and specialized field, and it was also an era when pure hardware-only research was hard to sustain without doing something unusual in software.
But I wanted to build hardware know-how and experience, so I took a job as an electrical engineer in line with my major. At that point I had knowledge but didn’t know how to use it — basically an amateur. So I think it was the right call to lean on a large company’s deep pockets at that stage.
I then spent eight years accumulating a variety of experience. I learned not just electrical engineering but mechanical engineering too, spent years dealing with networking and RTOSes on the software side, at times even got experience in marketing and product planning — fields completely outside my expertise — and then shipped a product as a project manager. That’s how I was able to join a startup as someone who could fight on multiple fronts.

Rules and social common sense

I don’t mean things like going barefoot in the office, or wearing jeans in front of clients. That stuff is fundamentally irrelevant.

What I mean is, for example:
When someone says a PO (purchase order), what needs to be written on it?
In a price negotiation, how high a number is it reasonable to push for?
Quotation, order, delivery — when is the right time to make payment?
Fixed assets, safety management, environmental measures, parts disposal — do you know the correct procedures?

These aren’t even at the level of know-how, really — they’re just “experience.” Large companies have models to follow, and senior colleagues who will carefully teach you. At a startup, especially an early-stage one, you’re left to figure this stuff out yourself.
Figuring it out yourself and failing is, in a way, good experience too, but startups often don’t have the slack to laugh off that kind of failure.

When I joined a startup in Silicon Valley, a lot of people didn’t have a handle on this stuff. If it had turned out that literally no one on the team understood any of it, that would have been terrifying. A company like that might struggle to ship a product — for a reason that trivial and dumb. It’s close to a basic skill, so there’s no harm in having it beforehand. That said, it’s a skill you can always pick up later, so when exactly it’s best to acquire it is a judgment call.

A broad perspective

Large companies have all kinds of people. There are bosses you deeply respect, and, on the flip side, colleagues who are just terrible. The former exist at startups too (well, of course — you’d choose a startup like that, wouldn’t you), so the latter is the real issue.
People who do nothing but slack off, people whose talk is big despite having no real ability, people who get promoted on sheer cunning alone — the list goes on. When you’re young, this kind of thing makes you restless or indignant, but if you can get through that indignation without falling into despair, it becomes a “good experience.” The world is full of all kinds of people, and even the ones who frustrate you have some sliver of a point, some motivation, some usable ability. Learning how to manage that is what matters — that’s how you come to develop a broad perspective.
But if you despair over it, or just get swept along, your career will probably end up disappointing. And the worst-case scenario arises: you’re surrounded by an environment and colleagues you hate, yet you can’t imagine leaving. At that point you’re basically dead as a working professional.
So developing a broad perspective at a large company takes relatively more patience.

At a startup, on the other hand, you’re already swimming in broad perspectives from the moment you start — and conversely, anyone who can’t maintain one won’t last.
The basic premise of a startup is that it’s a “mixed bag.” People gather there with different roots, different skills, completely different career histories. So differences in values are a given.
How do you make that work? You have no choice but to respect the other person. If you converse on that premise, differences of opinion become a chance for self-reflection, and differences in skill or career become a chance to absorb new skills and knowledge for yourself.
On top of that, people at startups are often constantly exposed to the outside world. This was especially true in Silicon Valley — people at startups, when introducing themselves, don’t say “I’m so-and-so from such-and-such company.” They say “I’m so-and-so. Oh, and I currently work at such-and-such company.” The individual comes first. As a result, you naturally get more raw exposure to information outside your specialty and to trends in other industries. Your perspective inevitably broadens.
Also, the environment around a large company is a relatively smoothed-out, “gentle world.” A startup, by contrast, is extreme in both directions.
A young person who was just spouting ridiculous fantasies might, in just a few years, rise to a life of traveling by corporate jet — while a company that raised tens of millions of dollars can burn through all of it in just six months, with its founder getting absolutely torn apart afterward. There are jaw-dropping fools, and there are admirable, accomplished people who’ve royally screwed up. This fierce dynamism is, in its own way, an extremely rich form of human activity.

Going abroad

I’ve written in another post about how to make your way to the US —

Seven Ways for a Japanese Salaryman to Get to Silicon Valley

If you want a career that includes working abroad, a large company gives you a far higher probability of that.
The best option is joining a huge foreign-owned company. There’s no room for doubt here.
Obviously, startups don’t have money. And posting employees overseas costs an extremely large amount of money. That’s really the whole story.

I myself took the bizarre career path of going abroad when I left a large company to join a startup, but because it was such a bizarre path, I was forced to endure a corresponding amount of hardship, and I honestly can’t recommend it at all. Frankly, I think the odds of it working out are very low.

Connections

The root of any network is an encounter. What you do with it afterward is up to you, but if you never have the encounter in the first place, nothing begins.
Opportunities for encounters broadly split into work and personal life.

On the work side, large companies give you more chances to work with “impressive companies.” That’s where you’re more likely to get to interact with celebrities or executives at major corporations. An early-stage startup is, socially speaking, basically nothing — for a while you get treated as beneath notice externally. Even if fundraising goes well and you try to ship a product, getting a major company’s cooperation is difficult, and even if you do negotiate, your position is extremely weak. But once you’ve joined a large company, you can borrow the company’s name to do almost anything. I remember talking with colleagues from my cohort a few years after joining a certain company, and the consensus was: “If we drop our company’s name, pretty much any company will open its front gate for us.” In other words, as long as you choose the right company to join, you’re essentially guaranteed not to be treated with contempt externally.

Startups, on the other hand, may give you more chances to work with “impressive individuals.” This is just my personal theory, but the sharpest people tend to be out in the wild — crazy technical talent paired with an eccentric personality, extraordinarily high-level knowledge paired with no grasp of social norms, an almost supernatural analytical ability paired with wildly irrational personal behavior. People like that tend not to surface in the mainstream.
Large companies won’t hire people like that, and frankly anyone with a questionable personality gets avoided by everyone and is hard to recommend to others. But I feel like you encounter a lot of people with genuinely special skills this way. That’s because people that eccentric ultimately either start their own company or end up settling into a startup full of equally crazy people.

Now, as for personal life — meaning a personal life that extends just a half-step beyond work — the connections you build at a startup tend to be thicker. What makes them thick is diversity and intensity. One advantage of a startup is being very close to the leadership. It’s hard to imagine at a large company, but at a startup, going out for drinks with the CEO is a regular occurrence. There just aren’t that many people, for one thing. And the CEO is often connected to other CEOs — ties that span industries, regions, and ages. That’s just what CEOs are like. Being close to them means you get to easily enjoy the benefits of those ties. In Japan especially, once someone has worked at a startup, they’ve essentially bet on a future of job-hopping. A diverse network is a necessary condition for navigating those rough seas enjoyably.
And then there’s intensity. The people at startups and in startup circles tend to fall into these patterns:
① They have dreams and ambition
② They want meaningful responsibility at a small company
③ They’re acting on a vague sense that “this seems fun somehow”
④ They fell for the CEO (or an executive), so there’s nothing to be done about it
⑤ They don’t fit in at a normal company
That’s roughly it. Setting aside ⑤, these are genuinely fascinating people to have around, because they carry an explosive “heat source” within them. If you want to connect with people like that, being in startup circles is the way to go.

Since I switched careers partway through, I have connections from both worlds.
The trust built in the connections from my large-company days is solid. It’s dependable, and there’s a clear sense of how we can rely on each other.
The connections I’ve built in startup life are looser, more hands-off — but there’s a sort of indefinable sense of expectation to them.
As a middle-aged man, I think it’s probably best to hold both kinds.

Well, I’ve written on and on without much structure, and I could keep going indefinitely if I wanted, but I wonder what the point of that would even be, so I’ll stop here. No one can fundamentally possess an answer to the future, and declaring one with a knowing look is, frankly, a buzzkill.
I have hopes for young people. But an old man’s experience isn’t something to rely on. Talking in terms of probability doesn’t get you anywhere. Trust your sensibility. Trust your instincts. Take responsibility for what you decide with your own will. Live so you wouldn’t regret it if you died tomorrow. That’s it.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2014/10/59/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.