Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Americans Are Not Actually Good at Discussion

This is a reprint of a past post.

It happened the other day. An acquaintance of mine here tweeted something along the lines of “a situation where multiple discussions — differing greatly in quality and kind — get tangled together, and people just say whatever they want based purely on intuition” being lamentable, or maybe a step on the road to Westernization. It got me thinking.

I want to write down what occurred to me from the keyword “a culture of saying whatever you want.”

Japanese people, I think, believe that “Americans are good at discussion.”

I want to say that’s true, but it’s fundamentally wrong.

What they’re mostly good at isn’t discussion itself. It’s “steering the conversation toward the conclusion they want” and “shifting the point of contention to talk only about what’s convenient for them.”

That’s the basic pattern, anyway.

Of course there are plenty of fair-minded people too: people who listen to what you have to say, properly identify the issues, offer counterproposals, evaluate each option, and ultimately arrive at a correct, well-reasoned conclusion that everyone can accept.

But these people aren’t what’s commonly called “good at discussion.” They’re simply “smart people.”

I’d rather only associate with the latter kind if I could, but unfortunately the former type is more common, and in America there’s a prevailing sense that living as the former is the right way to be. I have to say that much.

You could call “being smart” basic physical fitness and a healthy body.

“Being strong at discussion” is like a sharp knife.

Having both is obviously best, since you can survive any situation, but the reality is that most people only have the knife.

This may not be unique to America to begin with.

I’m sure there are adults in Japan too who trained their bodies hard when young, honed a fine blade, and then — before they noticed — their bodies weakened, they could no longer wield the blade properly, and they end up just hurting people every chance they get.

But American society runs on this, and in many respects it has achieved remarkable development because of it.

Why that is has been one of my major interests since I first came to the US.

Take technical discussions. Everyone speaks with total confidence, as if they were a professional in the field, but in reality most of them are nearly amateurs just saying whatever they want based on bits of secondhand information and sheer intuition. It’s a situation that would make a Japanese person go pale, and it genuinely happens all the time.

So how on earth does the discussion ever get resolved? That was one of my interests from early on in the US, and lately I’ve started to see, vaguely, that there’s a kind of self-cleansing mechanism at work:

Everyone says whatever they want → unfortunately, whoever has the loudest voice or is best at working the room behind the scenes wins → some trouble occurs → it comes back on that person, but they have no ability to resolve it → they lose trust, and nobody listens to them anymore → they get pushed out of the organization

It’s built on “harsh evaluation” and “a culture that unhesitatingly excludes people who are no good.”

In other words, it’s risk-taking.

Whoever is good at controlling that survives, and whoever is bad at it stumbles somewhere along the way.

Criticizing, excluding, ignoring: it won’t be easy for these to take root in Japan as legitimate practices.

If this self-cleansing mechanism were to fail instead, you’d get this:

Everyone says whatever they want → unfortunately, whoever has the loudest voice or is best at working the room behind the scenes wins → some trouble occurs → what should come back on that person instead gets glossed over depending on the circumstances → that person is never made to take responsibility and just keeps repeating the same thing → the person who’s merely loud somehow ends up looking like the important person at the center of things → they get promoted, and you end up with an incompetent boss surrounded by yes-men to their face and badmouthed behind their back

It’s a world that looks like one we’ve seen somewhere before.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2014/04/338/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.