Seven Easy Ways To Sound Like You Know Football
This article was originally written in February 2014 on the old blog mixture-art.net. It has been moved here as-is, with the same writing style and information from that time.
Getting excited only at goals or near-misses when watching football is, needless to say, the mark of a ‘casual fan.’
Football isn’t a game where many goals go in over the course of a match (↑ this is the line basketball and baseball fans love to throw out as their “anti-football” argument) and the real enjoyment lies somewhere deeper than that.
In countries with a long football history, like England with its famous Premier League, applause often breaks out during a match. In scenes that have nothing to do with goals at all. Of course a goal brings deafening roars, as you’d expect, but applause is the crowd’s way of expressing “ooh, that was subtle, nice play.” Conversely, even fans will jeer a passive play from the team they’re supporting.
This is what’s known as having a “trained eye.”
Here, for those who think: “I admire that kind of thing, but I don’t have the knowledge or much experience watching matches, so honestly I don’t get it, and I’m scared of saying something off the mark and getting glared at by people around me…” let me introduce a few simple ‘things to watch for’ and ‘comment points,’ along with example phrases.
There’s no need to get too worked up about it. As the Japanese proverb “okame hachimoku” (an outside observer sees eight moves ahead) goes, people watching from outside (on TV) can surprisingly often hit the mark better than those inside the game.
① Focus on the fullbacks’ positioning
Example: “In the second half, Nagatomo’s position has been quite high.” Example: “The battle on Japan’s left side is the key to this match.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆☆☆☆
This line of commentary works best when the formation is 4-4-2 against 4-4-2.
Fullbacks naturally do a lot of up-and-down running, so honestly it’s not easy to tell at a glance whether their positioning is high or not lol.
So it helps to focus on a few points.
① How many times has the fullback managed to reach the opponent’s corner flag ② When one fullback pushes up, how far up has the opposite fullback gone ③ Let’s count the win rate in one-on-ones
① is easy to understand. Reaching the corner flag area is proof that that team has the upper hand. If they can get there about once every 10 minutes, that’s a fairly dominant performance. If it only happens once or twice in the first half, that’s honestly a disadvantage. ② is proof of aggressiveness. Normally, when one side pushes up, the opposite side holds back. But a good fullback is one who goes all out when they sense a decisive moment. ③ Fullbacks in particular often end up in one-on-ones against the opposing team’s dribblers. If there are many one-on-ones to begin with, there’s a higher chance a goal will result depending on how those duels go, and if a fullback is dominating those one-on-ones, that obviously favors their team.
② Comment on the coordination of the pressing up front
Example: “They’re doing a solid job of pinning down where to win the ball.” Example: “The line is too stretched out, so there’s no pressure being applied.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆☆
This is a very easy point to comment on. Basically there are only two things to watch for. In a scene where the opposing team’s defensive line has the ball and a forward goes to press them, the forward will always chase the ball from one particular direction — in other words, they almost never charge straight in. This is called a ‘one-side cut.’
Now, if the forward chases from the right, the opponent will naturally play the ball to the left where the passing lane is open, and then the next player over on the left will go in to win the ball. This is coordination. So for example, if a forward chases the ball from the right, the thing to watch is whether the midfielder on the left side senses that and goes to win the ‘next ball.’ That’s all you need to watch for.
To take it up a level, a second point worth watching is the depth of the defensive line at the moment that coordinated press happens — paying attention to this lets you make an even better comment. That’s because when coordination is poor, it’s usually because the line is too deep. A deep defensive line means each player is farther apart from the others. Naturally the coordination breaks down, and even if the first and second players manage to coordinate, the third and fourth will inevitably be late.
③ Check where the defensive midfielder was during moments of danger and chance
Example: “Endo just covered a really long distance there.” Example: “The balance of the defensive midfielders is off today.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆☆☆☆☆
This is a point that’s easy to miss entirely if you’re only watching the player who shoots or the ball, so it’s hard to master. But making this comment makes you look like quite the ‘expert.’
First, in attack, one standard for judging whether a good attacking move has been made is “how many players made it into the penalty area by the time the shot was taken?” Four is a very good attack, three is a decent chance, two is a thin chance, and if there’s only one, it’s a pretty thin attack, so you should give a harsh comment.
Now, to talk about the four-player case, suppose the formation is 4-2-3-1 and the attack is coming from the left side. In most cases, the first player would be the lone forward, the second the attacking midfielder, and the third would be the midfielder on the opposite side — in this case, the right side. So who’s the fourth?
Naturally, that would be the defensive midfielder.
In other words, if the defensive midfielder makes it into the penalty area, you can call it a ‘really good attack.’ But to do that, the defensive midfielder has to cover quite a long distance. Whether or not they actually touch the ball is secondary. If a defensive midfielder has run all the way into the penalty area, praise them right away.
If you’re not sure what to say, just go with something like “Hasebe’s late run there was a real decoy move.”
Now let’s think about defensive scenes instead. In slow buildup play (when the opponent circulates the ball slowly to attack), the defensive midfielders are, in most cases, defending properly, but it’s when a team gets hit on the counter that the positioning of the defensive midfielders is worth watching.
When a team gets caught on the counter, the center backs often get pulled out wide. Center backs should, in principle, stay glued to the center no matter what, but when the defense is thin, sometimes they have no choice but to go out wide. This, however, means there’s no one left to protect the center (near the goal), so frankly, it’s a crisis.
It’s not an exaggeration to say that a defensive midfielder’s true worth is tested by how they act in that crisis. In this situation, the battle between the center back who went out wide and the opponent’s wide player doesn’t matter much, so immediately check the positioning of the defensive midfielders and the opposing forward in the center.
If one defensive midfielder has dropped fully back into the defensive line to cover the center back’s position, and the other is running alongside the opponent’s attacking midfielder, that’s perfect. Praise the beauty of that shape. They’ll surely keep a clean sheet today.
If one defensive midfielder is contesting the opponent’s attacking midfielder or forward, and the other hasn’t gotten back yet and is off-screen — that’s probably the most common case. Well, it can’t be helped. No comment. If this keeps happening too much, mutter something like “Is the defensive midfield work rate low today?”
If neither defensive midfielder has made it back on defense, criticize it right away.
④ Mention positional changes in midfield
Example: “Positional changes have increased since the second half started.” Example: “There’s no fluidity up front.” Example: “Oh, they’ve switched up the matchups.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆☆☆
This is a point that tends to get overlooked when you’re watching a match too intently, but unless the formation is something like a ‘4-4-2 box,’ midfield basically has a division of roles into ‘right midfielder’ and ‘left midfielder.’ Flexibly swapping these around during the flow of the match is the mark of mature tactics.
For example, as mentioned in ①, there are many one-on-one situations out wide. In a one-on-one, if you keep facing the same opponent, the defense gradually gains the advantage, because they learn the opponent’s habits. But if the opponent keeps changing, the defense’s rhythm gets disrupted. Especially if there’s a left-footed player and a right-footed player, just swapping them throws the defense into considerable confusion. The same goes for a passer and a dribbler, for instance. Conversely, a team with few positional changes among its players isn’t scary. I can say that with confidence.
If you’ve got the formation properly memorized, you should be able to spot these ‘swaps.’
⑤ Jeer at play in and around the penalty area
Example: “If they’re not going to shoot from distance there, the defense can relax.” Example: “I think there’s room for a simpler cross too.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆
This basically comes down to the example lines themselves. It’s human psychology: the more you want to score for certain, the more cautious — i.e., passive — you become. When there’s a lack of aggressiveness and the mood turns bad, it’s almost certainly one of the two example lines that applies.
⑥ Praise a seemingly unremarkable play by the back line
Example: “Uchida slowing things down there is what let the defensive line reorganize.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆☆
Specifically, this praises a play where the player chose not to go for the ball.
This actually applies in almost every scene, so it’s easy to use. Conversely, almost anyone who understands football to some degree already has this point covered. You could call it a basic.
Let me explain the reasoning a bit.
The basic principle of defense is to corner the opponent into a ‘many against one.’ Several players surround one to win the ball. A one-on-one duel is certainly exciting, but what’s the actual win rate there? A defense’s thinking about win rate has to be extremely conservative. In other words, for a defense, anything short of ‘undefeated’ is basically equivalent to a loss. So repeatedly gambling everything on one-on-ones isn’t a great idea.
And when you think about the numbers on defense, there are often cases, depending on the match situation, where an attacking teammate has to track back on defense. But it’s rare during a match for the opposing center back to push forward into the attack many times. Usually that only happens on set pieces, where a center back who went up stays up afterward. There’s no risk at all in a forward tracking back to defend, but a center back pushing forward carries a big risk if the team gets caught on the counter afterward. In other words, even though there are 11 against 11 players on the pitch, in practice the defense should, in most cases, be able to achieve a numerical advantage.
But the defensive shape often collapses anyway. What’s needed at that moment is a ‘delay.’ Buy time, and use it to reorganize the defense. Do that, and the defending side basically has the numerical advantage, so they won’t easily be beaten.
But of course the forward knows this too, and tries to force the issue early. Holding them off with just the right balance — not too close, not too far — and buying time that way is truly a subtle, understated fine play. Applause.
⑦ Praise a goalkeeper’s decision to punch the ball away
Example: “Yeah, that was the right call not to go for the catch there.” Example: “That had a bit of a wobble to it.”
Plausibility: ☆☆☆☆ Difficulty: ☆☆☆☆
You need to know something about the shooter, so the difficulty is on the higher side.
Since the 2010 World Cup in South Africa, the official match ball has apparently been relatively easier to kick with a knuckling effect. A number of players, Keisuke Honda and Cristiano Ronaldo among them, deliberately aim to produce that knuckling effect in situations like free kicks where they can take careful aim, but for a player with real shooting power, it’s not uncommon for an ordinary-intention strike to end up knuckling by chance.
Players who bend the ball with curve, or who strike low grounders, are unlikely to produce a knuckling shot, but if you look closely at players hitting mid-range shots from a bit farther out, you’ll sometimes see a wobble.
For instance, a mid-range shot heading straight at the keeper is something you’d normally want the keeper to catch. But doing that against a knuckling shot carries considerable risk. It might deflect straight back in, or a loose rebound might get pounced on.
Earlier I wrote about the way of thinking regarding a defense’s ‘win rate’ — the same applies to goalkeepers. To stay ‘undefeated,’ you can’t afford to overlook even small risks.
“Oh, this one might wobble.”
When that thought crosses their mind, the right call is to give up on the catch and punch it away decisively. Naturally, a good goalkeeper keeps in mind “who’s likely to hit a knuckling shot.” When a goalkeeper ‘decisively’ punches away what looks like a harmless shot, that’s exactly the situation.
If there’s an awkward silence after a punch, with people wondering “huh? Couldn’t they catch that?”, jump right in and say: “No, that guy sometimes hits a knuckler. Smart decision.”
Just mastering the above should let you make comments that sound pretty convincing.
And, you may not have realized it, but mastering these points actually raises your level of match-watching considerably too. You should now have a bit more knowledge for getting closer to the essence of football.
I hope whoever reads this gets to enjoy a fulfilling football-watching life.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2014/02/1991/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.