Ideas mean nothing without refinement
“I just came up with a groundbreaking idea!!!”
I often want to do a little dance in the shower after thinking that.
But that “groundbreaking idea” almost never actually lives up to the word “groundbreaking.”
Look into it carefully and you’ll usually find something similar already exists, or someone else comes out with something similar while you’re still refining it.
What you should say at that point isn’t
“Damn it, I should have done it sooner!”
The right answer is
“Oh, if someone else is thinking of the same thing, maybe it’s a good idea after all.”
Even as I say that, I know I’m the type who wants to blurt out the former, so this post is really a warning to myself.
Watch “their” situation calmly, and check their feedback as if it were your own.
How is the market reacting?
Has a community formed around it?
How many people are developing it, and over what timeframe?
How much funding have they managed to raise for that idea?
From your own point of view, what are the good points and the bad points?
Then analyze.
What’s the difference between their idea and yours?
The relationship between an idea and refining it resembles the relationship between “talent” and “effort” in athletes.
Talent is, in most cases, something you’re born with, and even when it isn’t innate, it’s reasonable to assume it was cultivated quite early in childhood.
And in most cases it stays dormant for a while.
Take Yuto Nagatomo of the Japan national team, for example — a player known for incredible stamina. Apparently, through junior high school he was actually one of the less stamina-rich players on his team.
But after that, through various twists and turns and repeated effort, he became a player with stamina unmatched almost anywhere in the world.
His rise clearly wasn’t talent alone, but it can’t be explained by effort alone either.
What about the teammates who did the same training as Nagatomo back in junior high?
Weren’t there players in high school who trained even harder than he did?
We should think of it this way: he succeeded in unearthing talent he already had.
And he also succeeded in nurturing it carefully.
These two things can’t be separated — they only have meaning together.
So, back to the main topic.
Ideas sometimes lie dormant, sometimes pop out of nowhere, but by themselves they’re almost 100% useless.
Trying to win with nothing but a freshly popped-out idea is far too reckless.
A former delinquent who wants to become a boxer.
No matter how absurdly explosive his punching power is, if he debuts as a pro without proper training, he won’t reach a national ranking, let alone a world title.
We talk about ideas “welling up” as if that makes them sound valuable, but really they’re more like nuts falling to the ground and rolling in front of you — it’s completely normal for similar ones to be lying around everywhere.
It’s like a junior youth team packed with players who look like lumps of raw talent.
Talent itself really is impressive, but it’s actually not all that special — what follows is a process in which a great many talented people fall away. That’s effort.
An idea won’t shine, and won’t hold up in the real world, unless it’s refined.
So there’s no need to be pessimistic just because a similar idea already exists in the market.
Whether an idea turns into something remarkable depends, in the end, entirely on how it’s refined going forward.
Take Google, take Apple — both are now among the companies dominating the world, but HDD-based music players like the early iPod already had competitors, and attempts like the iTunes Store had been tried repeatedly, over and over, long before.
Search engines, too — Google was a latecomer into an industry crowded with competitors at the time, and there are still plenty of people loyal to other companies’ products.
So I imagine plenty of people, watching companies like these succeed now, grind their teeth and think, “Why them and not us…”
But just as no two talents are exactly alike, no two ideas are exactly alike either.
Just as there’s no single fixed way to put in effort, there’s no single fixed way to refine an idea.
Just as no two players are ever exactly the same, no two outputs are ever exactly the same either.
There’s a difference. That’s why a gap forms.
So when you find a similar idea already out there in the market, just think of it as a player with talent similar to yours having made their pro debut first.
The timing of a debut is tangled up with all kinds of factors — age, circumstances at the club — and over the long run, there’s no clear correlation between debuting early and becoming a great player.
There are great players who bloomed late, and there are precocious players who fade away.
Former Yomiuri Giants pitcher Koji Uehara is a good example — he spent a year as a ronin, debuted as a pro after graduating university, and went on to become a player who won MVP in the majors in his late thirties.
Conversely, former Japan national team player Yuki Morimoto debuted at 15 and drew huge attention, moved to Italy at a very young age, but never developed further after that, and now plays for Chiba in J2 without having put up any notable results even there.
Players who draw attention for being precocious and then simply fade away — that’s an everyday occurrence.
When you find a rival of a similar type to yourself, becoming exactly the same player as him won’t get you a starting spot, so you need to carefully find the difference between you and him. Then make your own strengths clear, and develop them.
His play will be a great point of reference at that stage.
There will be things to learn from, and things to avoid.
Before you know it, even though you both started from similar talent, you’ll have become a completely different player from him.
And that’s finally where the real contest begins.
Giving up rashly after comparing yourself to others is a bad human habit.
And the consolation “there’s no point comparing yourself to others” feels very comforting, but it’s nothing more than a sophistry that misses the point.
You should compare yourself — if you’re serious about pursuing it.
Other people give you the recognition of who you are; it’s simply unreasonable to imagine that recognition generates itself automatically, all on its own.
To begin with, it’s a mistake to treat the act of comparing yourself with others as something negative.
Comparison is a good opportunity for discovery, and it’s something genuinely fun and exciting.
Sure, you might find yourself sick of it, finding nothing but your own flaws — but even then, I want to focus on finding the point where you think, “oh, I’ve actually got something going for me here.”
I know that’s a hard thing to do.
People don’t want to get hurt, and they hate having a sore spot pointed out.
That’s why I said it: “You should do this if you’re serious about pursuing it.”
If you’re not, it’s better to stop.
Comparing yourself against others this way and that is stressful, and it’s not all pleasant.
On the other hand, wallowing in “I’m the best,” “my originality is unmatched” self-love feels, frankly, amazing.
So I’ll say it a third time.
“If you’re serious about pursuing it, do the comparative analysis. If you’re not, don’t bother.”
This is a message addressed to myself.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/12/95/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.