Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Flinching at the word connections marks you as Japanese

This post is a reprint of an earlier post.

Connections matter enormously in American society.

I thought that to some extent even back in Japan, but once you move to America the importance of it shoots up.

That has to do with employment structures, with organizational structures that aren’t hierarchical the way they are in Japan, and a bunch of other things tangled together, but basically people here just don’t dislike that kind of thing.

You could call it culture.

Americans, who have long been broadly comfortable with the word “connections,” are good at using and managing them.

Connecting with the right people, building the right relationships, having the right exchanges.

In Japan, by contrast, “connections” is a word received with relative distaste.

The reason is basically the mirror image of what I just said: lifetime employment, hierarchical organizational structures, a kind of collectivism, a bunch of things tangled together into a culture, but basically people here are just not good at that kind of thing.

To put it briefly, connections can be reduced to two questions without much loss:

It’s a question of whether the neural pathway connecting one synapse to another is active.

There aren’t that many ways to keep it active.

Basically it comes down to “keep reliably reminding the other person of your existence at regular intervals” and “when the moment comes, have the courage to reach out even if you’re not all that close.”

Japanese people, I have to say, are relatively bad at both of these.

That’s probably why the image of “connections” = “calculating” has spread among Japanese people as a kind of self-fulfilling answer.

And yet there are plenty of situations in the world where “it’s impossible without connections.”

A big project can start from a throwaway conversation at an izakaya, and charging through the front door when you’re up against a big company is genuinely hard going.

Thinking about all this, two examples came to mind.

One was a comedy show.

It was an episode seriously discussing “how to avoid being a one-hit wonder.”

The point, in short, was this:

“No matter who, no matter which network, get yourself liked by at least one producer to the point where they’d invite you out privately.”

Most shows rotate their lineup once they’ve been through a cycle.

The important thing is for it to cross someone’s mind: “oh, maybe I’ll try bringing that guy in.”

Obvious, but true.

No matter how good your performance is or how much the audience likes you, that alone won’t keep you alive.

It’s the producer, after all, who decides the show’s lineup, nobody else.

Once a cycle is done, everyone thinks, “hm, people are probably getting tired of that guy by now.”

At that point, it’s apparently the producer who knows you on a private level who’ll pull out some further angle, saying “no, that guy’s got other sides to him” or “he could work in this kind of segment too.”

I see, I see.

This isn’t all that different in our own working world.

The people who get called in for new projects are usually the ones who crossed someone’s mind as “oh, maybe I’ll try bringing that guy in.”

There’s HR stuff layered on top, but that’s the basic mechanism, and it’s extremely pronounced in America.

The other example was also from a comedy show —

one doing a segment like “infiltrating a celebrity party,” where one of the self-proclaimed celebrity CEOs who appeared under his real name turned out, once people dug into it online, to be someone who had repeatedly run scam-like operations, shutting down companies in the middle of the night and disappearing with the money. (I looked into it a bit myself, and the information did seem to check out.)

The self-proclaimed “organizer” who planned the party — arranging the venue and coordinating the women (in old terms, something like a “ticket tout”) — was a student, and he said something like, “I’m doing this to build connections.”

No, no. That kid is absolutely going to end up as an accomplice to fraud someday.

Even just saying “connections,” without a clear vision you can get badly burned.

These are somewhat extreme examples, but connections are like that: you never know what will end up helping you, and you never know what will end up wrecking your life.

Sometimes you get a call from an unexpected person at an unexpected moment, and sometimes a relationship you never meant anything by brings a dramatic encounter or change.

If you went around in Japan chanting “Connections!” “Connections!” “Conneeeections!” people would definitely dislike you. lol

Japanese people, as typified by forced smiles and flattery, tend to make the other person feel annoyed, or end up encouraging the other person to get too full of themselves, and tend not to be very good at building relationships outside of “friends,” “family,” and “the workplace.”

For Japanese people like that, building connections is probably, deep down, something like:

“Honestly a pain, but if I think there’s something to gain down the road, I guess I have to do it.”

It’s “that vaguely grubby thing” that exists on the same spectrum as drinking with your boss or entertaining clients on the golf course.

How dull.

But Americans, who come with natural sociability built in, handle this kind of thing effortlessly.

They’re casual, they don’t grovel, and on the flip side they don’t come off as arrogant either.

By the way, Silicon Valley doesn’t have much of a business-card-exchanging custom.

There’s no point in becoming a business card collector.

A relationship that’s nothing more than holding someone’s business card is, in the terms I used earlier, a “relationship that isn’t active.”

If you ever need to get in touch, you can usually manage it somehow as long as you both know where to find each other — what matters is simply whether they remember you.

For example, say you meet B, who’s a friend of your coworker A.

Say a year ago B mentioned he runs his own company doing “some particular service.”

You had lunch together once near the office, and that was it.

Then one day, for work reasons, it occurs to you: “oh, right, A has a friend who does that service — let me go ask him about it as a reference.” Obviously, you don’t need to know B’s contact details for that; you just ask A.

It’s fine if you only half-remember the name, as long as you remember properly “what he does.”

That’s apparently considered enough, around these parts.

To begin with, how low the bar is for the word “friend” is probably distinctly American too.

Correspondingly, it seems there’s actually no good way to translate the word “connections” into English.

“A friend of a friend is a friend, isn’t that enough, got a problem with that?”

Maybe that’s a baseline that exists at the level of the language itself.

That said, Americans are not at all uninterested in building the kind of calculating, interest-laden relationships that the Japanese word “connections” implies.

If anything, Americans are more aggressive about it.

That’s because in America, “being liked by individuals matters more” than it does in Japan.

For one thing, there’s hiring, which individuals decide almost entirely.

Then there’s the system of raises and promotions, which, frankly, individuals decide too.

And the fluid employment system, where job-hunting and project staffing are nearly the same thing, probably plays a role as well. (In other words, a given individual holds nearly all the power.)

As I said at the start, by temperament Americans seem suited to building that kind of relationship.

It’s a chicken-and-egg situation, but that’s apparently how American society is built.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/10/332/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.