American email culture still puzzles me after a year and a half
It has been a year and a half since I started working at what I suppose counts as an American company.
Some colleagues are Japanese, German, Turkish, and so on, but most are American.
There’s one thing I still can’t quite wrap my head around.
It’s “how conversations get carried forward.”
You could also call it “how work gets carried forward.”
As a general tendency, when it comes to moving work along through email, Americans carry a certain “formal mediocrity.” Or maybe it’s that Japanese people and other “meticulous peoples” have an exceptionally refined skill here.
A good example is the use of inline quoting.
I’m not an IT literacy instructor or anything like that, just an ordinary salaryman, but precisely because I’m just an ordinary salaryman, I’ve internalized how important “form” is in email.
Let me give an example of what I mean.
Say there’s an exchange between Person A and Person B. Below is a model example.
Also, we understand your company’s proposal has several variations, so it would help if you could show us the candidates. What we currently have on record is AAA-0001 and its derivative, BBB-0009. It would help to have information on the differences between these as well.
Thank you in advance.
<B’s reply> Thank you for reaching out. Thank you also for taking the trouble to visit the other day.
First, about the pricing — would it be possible to have it to us sometime this week?
Understood. We’ll proceed accordingly.
On that note, I’d like to ask you a few things.
Production start: January 1 of next year
Would the delivery deadline be the usual two months prior, as before? It would help if we could receive the order a further two months before that (September 1).
Expected annual volume: 1 million units
What monthly production volume are you anticipating?
What we currently have on record is AAA-0001 and its derivative, BBB-0009. It would help to have information on the differences between these as well.
There is also CCC-0007 as a derivative of BBB-0009. I’ve attached PDF datasheets for each, along with an Excel file summarizing the differences. Please have a look.
Thank you, and best regards.
Something like that.
What I want to point out here is that in this exchange, “no topic gets dropped.”
Proper use of quoting (inline) means nothing in the questions or replies slips through the cracks. Maybe this is Japanese meticulousness at work.
This culture doesn’t exist among Americans, as far as I can tell.
At least not among anyone I’ve dealt with.
Indians and Taiwanese, incidentally, often used inline quoting. Singaporeans, not so much, as I recall.
What I find endlessly strange is that nobody seems to worry about “is it okay not to use inline quoting?”
Let’s imagine, for instance, how an American, Person C, might reply to A’s email above.
Hi A-san
Thanks for the other day. We’ll move forward on getting you pricing this week. To do that, please let us know the monthly volume. Our delivery takes two months from order, so working backward as usual, please place the order by September 1.
I’ve attached CCC-0007 along with the other datasheets and the differences. Let me know if you have any questions.
Have a great weekend! American C
Something along those lines, probably.
Note that no topic has actually been dropped here, deliberately. The content is exactly the same as B’s.
But doesn’t it feel somehow uneasy?
Let me break down a few characteristics.
First, because it’s written as one continuous block without line breaks, it’s hard to grasp the topics. Second, it’s common to cram multiple topics into a single sentence without any hesitation. On top of that, since inline quoting is never used, if the reply comes after some time has passed, the content can become hard to follow.
Below, I’ve tried analyzing, in my own way, why things end up like this.
Before the analysis, let me clarify one thing: America has surely been running this way for a very, very long time.
And as a world-class industrial nation, at that.
In other words, it would be easy to simply reject this habitual “method of exchange” of theirs on its own terms: “It doesn’t match my way of doing things (my experience). So it’s wrong.”
No, that’s not it.
That kind of attitude is foolish.
Given that results are being produced, there must be something to learn here, and to do that, we have to read what lies behind it.
With that intention, I’ll continue below.
As a basic premise, I’m setting aside linguistic factors. Indians use English too, and my exchanges with Taiwanese colleagues are also in English. So that’s not what this is about.
Now then, the first, easy explanation that comes to mind is
The habit of being a talker
This may be playing some role as a contributing factor.
Americans, on the whole, tend to be talkers.
I wrote in another post that this is a culture of “eloquence is gold, silence is elimination in the qualifiers.” (insert link)
In other words, it’s easy to imagine that even when repeating something or quoting it, there’s an underlying desire to “say it in my own words.” This tendency also shows up among Japanese people who happen to be talkers.
What benefit does this bring?
I think it might be “new discovery.”
By chewing over the same thing once and spinning it into your own words, isn’t it possible to find a new perspective or direction?
In other words, this “rephrasing” might help both sender and receiver alike develop a multi-angled way of seeing things.
In America, there tends to be a lot of tolerance for clashing opinions.
It’s taken for granted that people have different opinions, and that alone is no reason to casually reject them. If you have time to reject someone else, better spend it affirming yourself.
To Japanese eyes this might look at first glance like “isn’t that the same thing?” but it’s quite different.
What matters is “accepting another person’s opinion as it is.”
That doesn’t mean being convinced by it, much less changing your own thinking because of it. It’s “that’s that, this is this.”
Because of this, people don’t fall into the trap of chasing some singular, complete answer within a given setting — the kind of reasoning that goes “this is wrong, this is wrong, this is wrong, so what’s left, my own idea, must be right.”
It’s taken for granted that opinions differ — this one is correct, and so is that one, and so is the other one.
So, to put it in extreme terms, not answering part of someone’s question can also be read as the assertion, “I don’t consider that an important question worth answering.”
Whatever friction or argument arises from that is welcome.
This may be a bit of an overstatement, but “picking something up by dropping something else” — an equal exchange — can serve as a guiding principle anywhere, in anything.
Here, I suppose, it comes down to shedding meticulousness in exchange for gaining creativity and room to grow.
Now, let’s move on to the next hypothesis.
The habit of survival of the fittest
Earlier, I deliberately wrote Person C’s reply with “nothing dropped,” but someone sharp enough could presumably go on operating that way, without dropping anything, indefinitely.
In other words, anyone who drops something or makes a mistake over something this trivial is naturally weeded out.
Even writing it all out as one continuous block without line breaks, a sharp person should still be able to pick out the topics correctly.
This survival of the fittest can also be derived as a keyword from another angle.
That is,
Dislike of email
I’d like to take a slightly different approach from the “talkativeness” angle just now.
Now then, come to think of it, even in Japan, when writing ordinary prose, people tend to just write it all out as one continuous block without a lot of line breaks.
The style of writing emails or blog posts is, in the end, something constructed culturally, after the fact.
In other words, one could think of it this way: because Japanese people love email and have written a great many of them, easy-to-read, easy-to-understand, efficient email writing has been cultivated that way over time.
An old culture of letter-writing (“fumi”)? Maybe that’s too grand a framing.
Seen that way, Americans clearly “dislike email.”
They’ll talk to you about the most trivial things. They’ll talk to you even when you’re pretty clearly in the middle of something.
Even for procedures too complicated to remember, they’ll call you on the phone.
Meetings, too, often get decided purely through conversation, with no digitized log left behind.
Not using email means more conversation happens instead. In Japan too, the decline in communication caused by overreliance on email has been a topic of concern for quite some time. There are probably companies that have taken concrete countermeasures against it.
That said, frankly, this tendency probably irritates Japanese people quite a bit. Spoken words vanish the moment they’re spoken, but with email, the history of what was sent and received remains as a log, as is.
Proceeding with work without a log can, in many cases, end up like having your walking stick pulled away in the middle of a desert.
A light example: say there’s some kind of trouble. “Hey, did you buy XX like I asked? I need it today.” “Huh? Chief, I wasn’t asked to do that?” “But so-and-so says they asked you to.” You dig through the email logs. “Let’s see… last Friday, so-and-so replied saying they’d buy it themselves. After that I was on a business trip, so I never saw so-and-so or called them.” “Oh, you’re right. My mistake, my mistake.” Something like that — if you’ve kept the exchange in email, you avoid being falsely blamed.
Conversely, if it were purely verbal, surely whoever has the louder voice wins.
“No, I told XX from the very start. I remember it clearly. Last time too, with the delivery of such-and-such, he forgot to place the order, didn’t he. What a hassle. Well, fine. Chief, I’ll arrange it urgently myself.”
If you get steamrolled like that behind the scenes, it’s the worst.
The worst.
But America has a culture in which that’s entirely possible.
Things just aren’t that tightly managed.
And the culture I mentioned earlier, where the louder voice wins, has become entrenched to the point where it’s practically fair to call it a core part of American identity.
This survival of the fittest, fairly unpleasant as it is when you look at it from one economic angle, does seem to produce a significant effect, in a roundabout way.
Assertive people speak up more and more, and through that, being right sometimes and wrong other times, they accumulate a great deal of experience, constantly changing jobs, getting involved in all kinds of projects, and building up their skills. And they keep giving that accumulated skill back to the world, one project after another. Assertiveness is, after all, almost synonymous with wanting to stand out.
“Mere attention-seeking” and “mere talkativeness” on their own produce nothing, but a person who can reliably extract solid feedback from that process can presumably grow far more than “a passive person with the same level of ability as them.”
Now, the last hypothesis is
Speed
No line breaks, no inline quoting — aren’t these things meant to increase speed?
Programmers, for instance, use line breaks as needed to keep their code properly organized. That’s taken for granted, but there’s a “literacy” (rules, common sense) established behind it.
In other words, as long as there are rules, they’ll follow them.
But prose (email) has no rules.
Given that, writing prose out as one continuous block is, naturally, the fastest way to do it.
Figuring out what part to quote, rereading the email, copying and pasting it, writing a comment, then searching for the next part to quote, copying and pasting it, writing a comment again…
Way too tedious!
That might be what’s going on.
My impression is that Americans carry both impatience and easygoingness within them.
They switch between the two depending on the scene.
Driving on surface streets: easygoing. Driving on the freeway: impatient.
Buying something at a register: easygoing. Buying something from a vending machine: impatient.
At work: easygoing. Heading home: impatient.
Before they start talking: easygoing. Once they start talking: impatient.
I’ve never stared closely at a colleague in the middle of writing an email, but I’m willing to bet email falls on the impatient side.
Now then, let me return a bit to the premise I set out earlier: from this line of thinking, I want to try to polish out whatever advantage Americans might have here.
Thinking about it that way, perhaps this switching between impatience and easygoingness is exactly the good part.
Japanese people tend to be a consistent sort of people, so they can be neatly sorted into “impatient people” or “easygoing people.”
In other words, they don’t switch between the two.
This builds up stress. Someone who’s impatient about everything will just keep accumulating it, and someone who’s easygoing about everything… the people around them are probably accumulating stress instead.
You see that exquisite American easygoingness in all kinds of situations.
Their looseness with time, needless to say. But once that becomes entrenched as “culture,” it does a lot to reduce overall stress. Being too strict about time, for instance, raises stress not only for the person who’s about to be or has been late, but for the people around them too. “I showed up on time, but so-and-so is always…” If the very notion of “time” has already lost its weight to begin with, there’s no need to get worked up about that kind of thing.
Apple, for instance: companies that deal with Apple often say they “go back on their word.” This isn’t the kind of thing that gets put in writing; it’s more of a “verbal promise/plan” kind of matter. From a Japanese sensibility, that’s exactly the sort of thing you’d swear firmly to keep, but apparently Apple is different. And yet this is also, apparently, an unavoidable bit of mud necessary for the clear output of “making something good.”
Products shelved right after the start of production, parts that remain undecided even past the order deadline — that kind of thing is routine.
You could make it sound impressive and say that in every case, it’s a judgment made with the “end customer” in mind.
If, right before a contract deadline, someone says “Hmm, let me think about it a bit more,” a Japanese sensibility might think, “Hey now, is it really okay to be so easygoing about this?” But if that kind of thinking turns out, surprisingly often, to lead to eventual success, it might be worth learning from it to some degree, and bracing yourself to get a little muddy too.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/06/53/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.