Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

A six-question diagnosis picks your team's best formation

This article was moved from the old blog mixture-art.net, where it was written in May 2013. The writing style and information remain as they were at the time.

I made a post like this somewhere the other day, and since I’d already done the work, I figured I’d leave a master copy here. With diagrams too, while I’m at it.

——————————–

For those of you agonizing over which tactic is right for your team. How about deciding it this way?

Q1. Does your team have experienced members with a high level of tactical understanding? Yes → Go to Q2 No → I recommend a 4-4-2.

Q2. Do you have full-backs on both sides who can handle defense and offense in good balance? Yes → Go to Q5 No → Go to Q3

Q3. Do you have a midfielder who likes to stick to the flank? Yes → Go to Q4 No → Please go ahead and build a great team with a 4-4-2

Q4. A player who sticks to the flank. Do you think that’s undesirable because it lacks tactical fluidity? Yes → Go to Q5 No → The tactic suited to you is 4-3-3. Hollow out the midfield and break through on the flanks with individual ability

Q5. Do you have two or more midfielders capable of making runs past the forward? Yes → You have the potential to build a wonderful team with a 4-4-1-1 No → Go to Q6

Q6. Do you have a forward who can handle hold-up play, decoy runs, and drifting out to the flank all in good balance? Yes → There’s room for some improvement, but you can still run a 4-4-1-1 No → Let’s go with a 4-4-2

Here’s the explanation.

The 4-4-2 is, first of all, a very common formation that everyone understands. It's a shape you could call the very basics of tactics.

「This is the standard “4-4-2″」 http://mixture-art.net/?tag=4-4-2

The 4-4-1-1, on the other hand, looks simple but actually demands complex things from each individual player. So the 4-4-1-1 doesn’t function unless the members have a fairly high level of tactical understanding.

20130502-005406.jpg

20130502-005444.jpg

In a 4-4-2, the full-backs are a very important factor. If you have good full-backs and no one in midfield sticking to the flank — meaning you have fluidity — there's a good chance you can build a great team with a 4-4-2.

20130502-005456.jpg

There are rare cases of a player who sticks to the flank but is given license to do so. A player who tears up the flank regardless of the tactical framework. If you also have good full-backs on top of that, a tactic where 2 or 3 players break down the flank is also an option. One condition for the 4-4-1-1 is this: "To score goals, midfielders have to get into the penalty area." You need midfielders who are always conscious of scoring, like Shinji Kagawa or Inui.

20130502-005505.jpg

In a one-striker formation, the burden on the striker naturally increases. The player also has to handle every kind of play in good balance while having a reasonably good physique, and as the national team shows, very few players meet that bar. One of the strengths of the 4-4-2, by contrast, is that it doesn't demand much of a particular type from its forwards.

20130502-005512.jpg


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/05/1988/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.