I Spent a Year as a Silicon Valley Engineer Comparing Japan and America
This article was moved here from the old blog mixture-art.net, written in February 2013. The style and information are left as they were at the time.
It’s about time, actually it’s overdue, but a year has now passed since I started living in America.
The image I had before coming here, the first impressions I felt, have all been chewed over and overwritten again and again, and it finally feels like the time has come to sort them out.
So I’d like to compare Japan and America from various angles.
Most of this is abstract personal impression, and I’m not pointing at any specific person or thing to criticize, so bear that in mind.
First, a light comparison of
National scale metrics
to start with.

Population
- US: a bit over 300 million
- Japan: around 130 million
Land area
- US: about 30 times Japan
- Japan: about 8 million Tokyo Domes
Just comparing these numbers, you can imagine America’s population density must be far lower than Japan’s. 30 times the land, only 3 times the people. Except for a few cities like New York, that impression is basically correct.
Thanks to that, houses are huge. A house with a yard and a garage is pretty standard in America.
But there’s an inconsistency with that: rent and land prices are just as high as in Japan. In some places they’re far higher than even Tokyo’s market rates.
I imagine this has something to do with taxes. Most governments assume a kind of “typical household budget” and design taxation around that (if it’s a decent government, anyway). In America’s case, I’d guess the amount budgeted for “housing” is set fairly high.
That said, land is abundant, so detached houses are common. Most of them are single-story, which is rare in Japan. There might even be a generation in Japan that doesn’t recognize the word for “single-story house.” It just means a house with only one floor. That’s rare, in Japan.
So in America, you can easily rent a detached house, it’s very spacious, but the market rate itself is high.
A car-based society plays into this too, so a simple logic like “the farther from the station, the cheaper” doesn’t apply.
What determines price levels, apparently, is the educational level of the area. That’s because public schools are free in America, so everyone wants to send their kids to public school. But which school you can attend is determined by where you live, so moving to get your kids into a good school is standard practice in America.
I suspect this is a complicated circumstance that arises precisely because America is a “nation of immigrants.” That would get long, so I’ll cover it elsewhere.
As for market prices, obviously if you go out to the real countryside the above won’t apply everywhere, but that’s true in every country, so here I’m just describing the overall tendency.
Now let’s pick up the next topic by free association. Next is
Transportation
An Indian former colleague of mine once told me, “I’ve lived in America for over 20 years and I’ve never once ridden a train.” That’s hard to imagine in Japan. A huge difference.
The licensing system is also somewhat unusual. As you know, America is the “United States,” but driver’s licenses are managed by each individual state.
So while the base traffic rules are common, there’s a lot of variation between states in operations and the licensing process, which is confusing.
California is the most extreme example: it basically does not recognize international licenses or licenses from other regions, meaning people holding licenses from other states or other countries cannot simply drive in California as is.
This is a crazy story. The state’s own rules take priority even over the Geneva Convention, which establishes mutual recognition of international licenses among signatory countries — a remarkably bold stance.
So foreigners who move to the US, including Japanese people, all have to get their license again. The sheer pain of this process… tears.
Anyway, that’s how it is, but once you actually drive, America is extremely easy to drive in.
The roads are wide, there are many lanes, and the highways are free.
And surprisingly, America has a solid spirit of mutual yielding.
At intersections where both sides are supposed to stop, in most cases the other driver yields first.
This surprised me. America is, unexpectedly, a rather polite country.
Now, when it comes to public transportation, airplanes have a presence on a completely different scale from Japan.
There are four airports within a 30-minute drive of my house, and two of them are international airports.
What a bullet train to Osaka means for a Japanese person is, in America, equivalent to a business trip to Chicago by plane.
Within Japan, I’ve only ever flown when going to Hokkaido, Kanazawa, or Fukuoka.
But for Americans, flying is a thoroughly everyday mode of transport. My sister-in-law, who handles West Coast sales for a certain consumer product company, racks up an enormous number of miles from business trips. I’m jealous.
Now, let’s dig a bit deeper into
Temperament

I said earlier that America is “surprisingly polite,” and as far as I can tell living here, Americans have quite a commendable temperament.
Let me list a few examples. Read them imagining how it would be in Japan.
-
When entering a building, if the person ahead of you opens the door, they hold it open until the next person (you) has gone through
-
At crosswalks without traffic lights, drivers properly yield to pedestrians
-
When an elderly woman carrying luggage gets off a train or bus, a passing young guy in b-boy style fashion with rap blasting from his earbuds will casually lend a hand. Completely naturally
-
Nobody makes a sour face at a baby in an enclosed space. If anything, they’ll talk to it or try to soothe it
-
A man on a date will pull out the woman’s chair at mealtime. Even at a department store food court
-
People will casually strike up conversation with you at the supermarket checkout
In short, people are friendly and gentle.
I think this might be the culture of “Hi, how are you?”
Translated into Japanese, that phrase means something like “Hey, how’s it going? (How are you doing?)” but it’s basically a hollow formality with no real meaning.
In the beginning I didn’t understand that, and when things were going well I’d say “Good,” when things were going really well I’d say “Fine” or “Pretty good,” and when things were bad I’d say “Not so good,” explaining my situation in detail.
That’s fine in conversation between friends, but in America pretty much everyone says that stock phrase at the start of a conversation. It would be absurd and exhausting to explain your condition to every single person you meet.
So the correct answer is to more or less mechanically say “Good, good.”
The culture of “Hi, how are you?” is, as explained above, the custom of deliberately saying something meaningless to strike up conversation. On the positive side, this makes it easy to shorten the distance between people.
After all, people can’t treat an acquaintance too coldly, right?
To put it dramatically, one “How’s it going?” and suddenly everyone’s an acquaintance.
So people give up their seats, hold doors, soothe babies, and become gentlemen.
In Japan, how often do you talk to someone who’s not family, not a friend, not a coworker, and not even a friend of a friend?
It’s something worth emulating, but Japanese people tend to find it too embarrassing to do.
Even I still feel a bit hesitant when some lady next to me suddenly strikes up a conversation.
Shifting direction a bit, next is
Service
To sum it up in one line: rational business sense, irrational public service.
When it comes to commerce, America is extremely rational. It’s good at business in a way that precisely targets what makes the customer happy.
For example, you often see the words “Buy 1 Get 1 Free” at American supermarkets.
It means buy one, get another one free.
To a Japanese person this seems like some kind of clearance sale, but at most supermarkets something is Buy 1 Get 1 Free almost every single day. It’s become routine.
It’s not just supermarkets. The other day, a baby outfit worth about 20 dollars was also Buy 1 Get 1 Free.
This is effectively a 50% discount, a great deal, but also kind of absurd.
Because someone bought that same item yesterday at double the price.
But from the store’s perspective, this is actually very rational.
It breaks down into two points.
First, as many people know, inventory is recorded as a “loss” in accounting. In other words, the less inventory, the better. So if everything stocked sells out the same day, that’s ideal. But things don’t always go that smoothly. Obviously.
“Tomorrow we’re getting a new shipment of such-and-such… oh, we’re a bit overstocked on this” — and in that situation, Buy 1 Get 1 Free gets triggered immediately.
It’s a bit drastic, but nobody cares. This is America.
If the alternative is a loss or throwing the stuff away, better to sell it at 50% off.
Rational.
People who bought it at full price basically never complain. A tiny number might, but if hundreds or thousands of times that many people come to the store in exchange, the math works out.
Extremely rational.
And the other point is that they’re simply boldly executing on the question of how to make the customer happy.
In America you also often get “XX% OFF” flyers in your mailbox.
The “XX%” isn’t 3% or 5%.
It’s 30% or 40%.
My wife is the type who falls for that sort of thing pretty easily, so she bites. And once we get there, she ends up buying all sorts of stuff anyway.
Then on the way home: “Look how much we bought for only $XX! What a deal~♡” — and she goes home very satisfied.
It feels like a really good relationship has been established with the customer.
In America I often sense this kind of rationality baked into the bone in all sorts of places.
When people of various races and values come together and need to reach some conclusion, rationality was probably the only viable common standard.
Meanwhile, the public services are awful — people throw up their hands, complain, give up. I doubt there’s a single Japanese person living in America who feels positively about it.
It lacks rationality, and it lacks any spirit of service.
IRS, DMV, Social Security Office…
They’re really nothing good.
Specifically:
- You’re made to wait an absurdly long time
- The staff’s attitude is bad, no kindness at all
- What you’re told differs depending on the person in charge, and staff often lack proper knowledge of the procedures or laws
And the biggest problem is that despite these blatant issues, there’s no sign whatsoever of improvement.
For example, the IRS is what’s called the tax office in Japan. Of course it gets crowded during tax filing season. It happens every year.
And yet there’s still no online appointment booking system.
You go in person, stand in line, finally reach the entrance, go “ugh (´Д` )” as you get a numbered ticket, and then all you can do is wait.
Last time I waited four and a half hours.
As for the DMV, see a separate post.
Related link: Getting a license at the DMV
From a Japanese sensibility, they completely ignore small improvements, the kind of thing where if they just did this one thing here, the flow of people would improve, or everyone could wait more comfortably.
On top of that, staff will casually chat among themselves right in front of the people waiting, and when the scheduled break time comes, they’ll casually abandon the paperwork in progress and us along with it to go on break. Even though it’s a place where a huge number of people wait, the number of chairs in the waiting room doesn’t account for that at all, and the appointment system will book an absurd number of people for the exact same time slot. And in most cases, the idea that all the windows would be open and staffed at once is pure fantasy.
Document processing is also slow, and sometimes the whole process just vanishes. Licenses that never arrive, documents that never arrive, there’s no shortage of that kind of trouble.
I’m sure a considerable number of Americans are dissatisfied with this situation too.
But American thinking tends toward a particular idea: unless you spend a huge amount of money, meaning overhauling the system or hiring a new, capable manager, dramatic improvement is simply impossible.
That’s the mindset.
There’s no “KAIZEN” spirit here, the kind that starts from small, familiar steps.
For example, on especially busy days, just shifting the lunch break slightly to keep processing could go a long way toward relieving congestion.
For example, hiring experienced people on short-term contracts during busy periods could also work. You could offset that by reducing permanent staff accordingly.
I recently visited a government office in Japan and noticed all sorts of clever touches. At the reception desk, where lines tend to stack up, there were multiple staff members, and the sorting process, fill out this form and go to this window, was extremely fast. The subsequent steps were also broken down into smaller tasks, each with its own dedicated staff member. Turning it into an assembly-line process kept things fast with nothing backed up. Honestly, there was no stress at all.
I think there are plenty of other ways to improve things with a bit of ingenuity.
American rationalist thinking seems to move in a direction that limits possibilities in situations like this.
Suppose a certain individual’s performance needs improvement. The thinking goes, “he can’t do more than his ability allows.” If he can only handle 10 people an hour, nobody says “try to manage 12.” The choice comes down to firing him or looking the other way.
That’s the conclusion the thinking arrives at.
Nobody carefully reviews the workflow in detail or pays attention to progress. It’s “that’s just how it is. If it can’t be done, it can’t be done. End of story.”
And this is where the strength of “business instinct” shows up in a bad way too.
“Does processing more stuff increase profit? This is a government office, isn’t it?” So there’s apparently no need to improve.
Conversely, I suppose Japanese staff at government offices who cheerfully and kindly help customers must seem strange, incomprehensible to them.
Now, next is a somewhat serious topic:
Healthcare
America doesn’t have anything like Japan’s universal health insurance that everyone is enrolled in.
So each person has to choose and sign up for insurance on their own. Depending on the insurance, there are roughly two patterns: one where you can see any doctor within that group’s network of hospitals at a fixed price, and one where you can be seen at various hospitals, big or small, that accept that insurance company’s plan.
The former is the case with big medical groups. Both the insurance and the hospitals are run by the same company, and the insurance only applies at that company’s “branches.” In exchange, there’s a home doctor system, where your assigned primary care doctor manages everything, internal medicine, surgery, any other specialty, tracking your progress and prescriptions across the board.
My company’s insurance was like this at first, and I remember being completely confused about how it worked.
The latter, by contrast, is often a collection of smaller hospitals, including private practices. The insurance company just has agreements with a number of independent hospitals, and each is a completely separate organization. So there’s no coordination between them, and of course no home doctor system either, essentially unmanaged. Depending on how you look at it, the patient is free to choose whichever hospital and doctor they want.
Small clinics run by Japanese doctors locally are, in most cases, only covered by this latter type of insurance. If you want your wife to be able to take the kids to a clinic where Japanese is spoken, the former type makes that difficult.
Naturally, since America is a nation of immigrants, translation services are abundant. This is common in hospitals too: doctor plus patient plus interpreter on the other end of a phone line, and the consultation happens like a conference call. Japanese is supported too, which is convenient in its own way. But interpreters sometimes can’t handle detailed medical terminology, and most interpreters aren’t Japanese nationals but Japanese-Americans, so their Japanese isn’t always perfect.
Occasionally when the interpreter’s Japanese sounds a bit off, I, who can understand English, feel a bit awkward listening next to the patient.
With the former type, since you can go to any branch, it’s common to be told, “we don’t have an ultrasound machine here, so please go to such-and-such for your next checkup.” That’s rational in its own way, but still inconvenient since you can’t go outside that group.
With the latter, you can go to either a small Japanese clinic or a large hospital serving the local population, and you can casually switch hospitals any time. This is pretty close to how Japan’s health insurance feels. The latter might actually be more convenient.
Medical costs, like in Japan, are absurdly high if you’re uninsured.
And since America doesn’t have a mandatory universal health insurance system like Japan’s, low-income people often can’t access healthcare because they can’t afford insurance.
Insurance premiums are actually pretty high. For someone with relatively low income, maybe around 10% of their take-home monthly pay disappears into health insurance.
But America shows no leniency on that front.
Work hard enough to afford it. Otherwise, leave.
That seems to be the attitude.
That’s the attitude of a nation built by immigrants.
Related link: [On the American Road] You should know that every “American” is an outsider
One more small detail: American hospitals have a lot of private rooms. This isn’t about hospitalization, just regular checkups. The patient doesn’t go to the doctor’s office; the doctor makes the rounds to the patient’s room.
Very rational and fast.
You go into the room, a nurse comes in, quickly handles the intake questions and blood draw, says “please change into this before the doctor arrives,” and leaves.
Then the doctor comes in, examines you, and says, “Alright, take care,” and heads to the next patient’s room.
The room for writing charts and doing paperwork is apparently separate, and patients don’t go in and out of there.
I thought it was a really rational system. It shortens the patient’s wait time, and rather than being left standing around outside doing nothing, you spend the time usefully in small pieces, do this, next we’ll do that, which makes waiting much less stressful. I wondered why Japan doesn’t do this.
Think about how much space a hospital would need for that, is probably the reality in Japan, though.
Next, something a bit more complex:
“Forms,” “patterns,” “common sense”
This kind of abstract fixed notion.
America has a negotiation culture.
It’s exactly like “eloquence is silver, silence is golden,” but inverted: eloquence is gold, silence gets you eliminated.
Those who don’t push back lose out, and rules themselves shift depending on negotiation.
This is both a symbol of freedom and proof of disorder.
I can’t help but feel this comes from being a nation of immigrants.
Indians tend to be assertive and often come across as self-centered.
Hispanic people tend to be high-energy and emotional.
Chinese people tend to be calculating and greedy.
Koreans are skilled at business and smoothly switch between friendliness and intensity.
Europeans tend to be relatively calm but get bored easily and aren’t always great about staying in touch.
Japanese people are shy, smile a lot out of politeness, and come across as mysterious because you can’t tell what they’re thinking.
Let’s say that’s roughly the tendency.
Now, if a group has one person from each of these backgrounds working together, how could you possibly define what’s normal or what counts as common sense in such a group?
You can’t.
Forcing Japanese values onto the group would be pure self-indulgence, but at the same time, there’s no need to discard Japanese values either.
Tying this back to negotiation, a basic tactic in Japanese discussions is often said to be: if you talk too much, you lose; if you speak first, you lose.
That’s because talking increases the chance of getting caught in a slip-up, and if you do get caught, the rest of the discussion becomes overwhelmingly disadvantageous.
Conversely, if you seize the initiative and steamroll the other party without giving them any room to respond, rather than persuading anyone, you just leave a bad impression on everyone around: “hey, what’s with this guy.”
That’s how it works in Japan.
Reading the air, as they say.
But in America, that kind of air to be read is already stagnant. Murky, even.
Nobody can accurately read that air.
So that air never unifies the impressions or perceptions of the people around you.
In other words, there’s no need to read the air.
If you can prepare a weapon that seems, at least on the surface, overwhelmingly persuasive enough to crush the other side in one blow, you don’t need to listen to what they have to say at all.
Just steamroll through, giving them no room for rebuttal, and push it through.
Force wins out over reason, and reason, what even is that? Can you eat it?
That’s America.
The usual saying goes “when force prevails, reason retreats.”
Concretely, this kind of negotiation comes up in all sorts of situations.
At a government office counter, being told something you should be able to do “can’t be done.”
Your apartment lease renewal, and they raise the rent after just one year, come on, seriously?
Your credit card gets used fraudulently, and you have to insist that wasn’t me.
In every case, if you back down even a little, you just get stuck eating the loss.
I said earlier that there’s no common sense, but there was exactly one universal logic.
Whoever speaks up benefits. Whoever stays silent loses.
That is the one and only common sense in America.
Finally, last is
Work
Job content varies a lot depending on the role and the company, so here I’ll touch on hiring customs instead.
As some of you may know, America has no fixed hiring season.
Unlike Japan, where companies hold simultaneous entrance ceremonies nationwide on April 2nd.
People who land a position sometimes start working while still students, and conversely, plenty of people go back to school, to take the classes they want, after graduating from college. In that pattern, they might do an internship somewhere along the way, finish the classes six months later, and just join that company directly.
America has grade-skipping, and the reverse also happens, where kids are held back to match their development. That’s never treated as something extraordinary; it’s quite common.
That’s part of why asking someone’s age in America doesn’t mean much. If someone says they’re 23, in Japan you’d assume they must have just graduated from college, but in America it might be:
“I graduated college once at 20, worked for a year and a half, then decided to take two more years of classes in a different major, so I’m currently a student, and I’ve been interning at such-and-such for the past six months. So I’m 23 now.”
That kind of story is common.
And since people like that are all around, everyone moves at their own pace in their own direction, seriously accumulating the experience they need to build their own career.
In that sense, Japan should feel deeply ashamed of the period when the fiction that graduating from a prestigious university guarantees your job hunting works itself out circulated as if it were basically fact.
One thing that’s confusing when talking with people who grew up in this environment is that concepts like “classmates from the same year” or “colleagues who joined the company the same year” don’t register with them at all, no matter how you explain it. As a workaround, “same class,” meaning we took a class together, is the one phrase that somehow conveys roughly the right nuance to them.
If anyone knows a better way to put it, let me know.
Continuing with the differences: American companies don’t have anything like an HR recruiting department either.
HR strictly manages services needed for employees, like payroll and insurance, while hiring itself is left to each individual department.
Each department, on its own responsibility and its own budget, hires exactly the people it needs.
So there’s basically no transferring between departments, and when a department gets shut down due to a company decision, basically everyone in it gets let go.
In fact, there’s even a vibe of “once this project wraps up, maybe I’ll switch jobs.”
Once a product you’re building gets safely on track in production, you move to a company that’s working on the next interesting product.
This labor mobility is a big difference between Japan and America.
In Japan people talk about “new graduates” versus “mid-career hires,” but in America that distinction doesn’t exist because it would be absurd.
The job-hunting process is shared between the two groups, and it’s extremely simple.
- Look for a position that seems like a good fit, through acquaintances, an internship, or sometimes through a newspaper or specialized job site listing.
- Get your foot in the door with someone at the manager level there, either directly or through a connection. The “Resume” you send at this stage is what’s called a rirekisho, résumé, in Japan.
- If they like you, it becomes “alright, how about we do an interview?”
- Usually a phone interview plus an in-person interview decides whether you’re hired.
There’s no job fair, no SPI aptitude test, no group discussion, no HR interview, no executive interview.
It’s an extremely fast and efficient job-hunting process. Companies barely have to spend any money on recruiting either.
They hire the people they want, when they want them, and put them to work right away.
In exchange, they also let people go just as quickly.
American employment contracts are quite alarming. They state outright that the company can terminate you without particular cause.
I was so surprised the first time I saw this that I asked an American friend about it.
Apparently this is a very standard clause.
And symmetrically, it also says you may quit the company without particular cause. Apparently that’s what keeps it balanced, in the American sense.
From a Japanese perspective, it probably feels like there’s no upside at all.
Sometimes you hear the claim that “America is a meritocracy” is actually wrong, that if anything the opposite is true.
In some respects, that’s largely correct.
Take this job-hunting process, for example.
What’s symbolic of job hunting in America is the practice of references. Concretely, this means interviewing the candidate’s previous boss or similar figures about how that person performed at work.
At first glance this looks like a classic meritocratic method, but it actually lacks real validity.
In the end, few people will say bad things about someone they had a good relationship with.
It’s an unconventional form, but in a sense, this is a kind of connections-based hiring.
Having a good relationship with your previous boss gives you an advantage in your next job search too.
That’s the reality in America.
In other scenes of work in America too, personal relationships and connections often have real effect.
The earlier point about being fireable without cause also means, in other words, that if you upset your boss’s mood, you’re fired, and the initial “wedge” used at the start of job hunting, item 1 in the earlier list, is, in most cases, a personal connection.
What’s more, clear alumni networks apparently exist even at large companies.
Personal checks are another example: America has a surprisingly analog side in odd places.
Japan emphasizes human feeling, reading the air, and sensitive interpersonal relationships, while matters of work and organization are, surprisingly, quite logical and dry.
America, on the other hand, might give the impression of being fairly self-centered, but as mentioned above, people get involved in each other’s business to a degree that’s decidedly “wet” emotionally. Even in work, there are parts swayed by personal relationships and connections, making it surprisingly not so logical.
It might feel unexpected, but there it is.
Now, as a bonus, something specific to California:
Climate
I’ll say this with full conviction: is there anywhere on this planet more comfortable than California?
Not too hot, not too cold, basically clear skies year-round.
Places with clear skies year-round are usually tropical countries near the equator, but unfortunately I have zero interest in marine sports, and practically speaking, few countries near the equator have thriving industries.
Meaning there are no jobs, so moving there is hard. Maybe fine for a wealthy retirement.
California, by contrast, is at nearly the same latitude as Japan, but thanks to Pacific Ocean currents, it’s apparently comfortable year-round.
Even at its hottest it’s only a bit over 30°C. Even at its coldest it’s around 5°C. Winter-like weather only lasts through November, December, and January.
As it happens, I’m writing this in a short-sleeve shirt and shorts right now. Meanwhile Japan is apparently flirting with below-freezing temperatures. Way too cold.
California’s industry needs no introduction. A skilled engineer can find as much work as they want.
Easy to move to, comfortable climate. There’s work, and life is easy here.
California truly is both the gateway to and the final destination of the American continent.
So, roughly speaking, that’s how things stand.
I haven’t touched on the parts where I feel there’s not much difference. If this got any longer, nobody would read it. Lol.
So, that’s it for now.
To anyone seriously considering moving to America, or anyone who just has a vague longing for it, I hope this was useful in some way.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/02/1985/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.