A 1m Pendulum Does Not Swing With a 1 Second Period
This article was originally posted in January 2013 on the old blog mixture-art.net and has been moved here. The writing style and information are unchanged from that time.
In the earlier post “Base 60”, I raised the topic of
1 year = 360 days → 1 year = 12 months → 1 month = 30 days → 1 day = 24 hours → 1 hour = 60 minutes → 1 minute = 60 seconds
and how units of time came to be fixed in this sort of progression.
This reminds me of something else.
Anyone who graduated from Tokyo Metropolitan Ao〇 High School in 199◯ and was in class 7 in their second year should remember this too. Lol.
Our physics teacher at the time, Mr. ◯ba◯shi (the one with the flamboyant way of talking), used to say this.
“If you make a pendulum by attaching a weight to the end of a 1m string, its period is 1 second.”
Or so he said.
Honestly, my memory of this is shaky.
After all, we’re talking about something from more than 15 years ago.
So let’s just calculate it.
Now then,
first let’s think about
the period of a pendulum.
Let the weight of the mass be m, the starting position of the pendulum be θ, and the forces look like this.
Note that the axis runs along the direction of the arc, as the x-axis. It doesn’t need to be a straight line.
Organizing this force equation gives something like this.
An approximation is used here to simplify things,
and this is allowed because, frankly,
the period of a pendulum doesn’t depend on the initial state of its displacement.
In other words, whether you pull it up a lot and let go (x is large) or pull it up just a little and let go (x is small),
the result is the same.
It’s a bit of a cheat, but without it we’d have to grind through a Taylor expansion, and this old man would rather not.
I want to take the easy way out even more.
So, on the assumption that it can be generalized, I’ll adopt the case where x << l.
If we do that, the final equation looks familiar.
Right, it’s the same as the equation for a spring bouncing boing-boing on a frictionless plane.
Something like this.
That said,
I’m not going to say something boring like
“So what’s the formula for the period of spring oscillation??”
Let’s think about it a little more.
By the way, here I’m using the relationship
derivative of distance = speed derivative of speed = acceleration
Now,
organizing the equation the same way as with the spring gives something like this.
Here we need to notice that getting just some real number out after differentiating twice is actually a pretty special case.
Normally, for example, if you think through the process of differentiating f(x) = x^3,
it’s never going to end up as “just a real number.”
In other words, this is a special case, and only the following cases are actually possible.
Now we’re getting close to the heart of it.
From here on, the result is the same no matter which of these equations we adopt, so let’s go with the top one.
Differentiating the top one,
we can organize it into this form for ω.
Now then, from the angular velocity ω we can calculate the period.
We’ve finally made it this far! Let’s happily plug in the numbers.
Taking the length of the rod l as 1m, the gravitational acceleration g as 9.8m/s^2, and pi as 3.14, and calculating,
since √9.8 is about 3.13,
the period really does come out to about 2 seconds (meaning 1 second for a swing from right to left)!
Tick, tock, tick, tock, really 1 second each time!!
“Wow, what an amazing coincidence!”
Is that what you’re thinking?
Nope, nope.
Think about it a bit and you’ll realize it’s actually the other way around.
In other words, this is said to be how the “m (meter)” was determined in the first place.
As a bit of a digression, when I think about units,
the foot, for example, comes from the length of a foot, and the yard—is that the size of some garden somewhere?
In America, the “m (meter)” isn’t common; they usually use the “mile” instead. A mile is apparently defined as the width of 1,000 paces.
The roots are easy to understand, but…
the value itself is hard to pin down! (There’s individual variation and all that.)
On the other hand,
the amount of water in 1 cubic decimeter (10cm cube) is 1 liter,
and the weight of 1 liter of water is 1kg.
That’s extremely well organized.
In America, weight is measured in pounds, and the definition of 1 pound was apparently set as 7,000 grains of barley (the amount used to bake one day’s worth of bread).
Come on now…
Of course these unit quantities themselves are now properly defined and managed,
but the units used in America feel so arbitrary and vague. Why do they keep using these forever?
I wish they’d hurry up and switch to a properly unified system.
Now, digression number two.
What happens if we don’t use the approximation partway through is quite a hassle. So I don’t intend to go into detail here, but to put it simply, the “first term” in the Taylor expansion is exactly the approximate equation we used this time, and I’d imagine the influence of the second term and beyond becomes non-negligible once you tilt things past roughly 60 degrees.
For anyone interested in the rigorous calculation, digging into that part might be fun too.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/01/1984/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.








