A Conversation About Superstring Theory And The Higgs Field
This post was migrated from my old blog, mixture-art.net, where it was originally written in January 2013. The style and information are kept as they were at the time.
A conversation with a certain space girl.
For the record, she’s only interested in space and physics as a hobby — she’s entirely a humanities type.
And I’m a science type, but an electrical engineer with absolutely no connection to quantum physics, astrophysics, or anything like that.
Note that, for privacy reasons, her replies have all been reworded, keeping only enough to follow the flow of the conversation.
(Space girl) ———————————-
Good morning.
Superstring theory
You told me about this before, but could you explain it to me again? (Our previous exchange is here: “How many dimensions is the universe anyway? …and what even is a dimension?”)
Is superstring theory the theory of quanta that have both particle properties and wave properties?
Also,
the Higgs field
— is it right that elementary particles collide with the Higgs boson there, and that’s how they get mass?
What exactly is the Higgs boson? Doesn’t the Higgs boson itself have mass?
Why wasn’t the photon affected by the Higgs boson?
And what does it mean for the photon to have zero mass??
Sorry for all the questions…
(Me) ———————————–
Okay, let’s start with superstring theory.
Having both particle properties and wave properties at once
is the foundation of quantum theory, conceived as a way to resolve a conflict in earlier physics.
Superstring theory is just one way of interpreting things: assume that the smallest unit of matter is something like a “string,” and it turns out to be convenient — it settles the explanation of various physical phenomena.
The reason this stuff got people excited in the first place is that
Einstein’s general theory of relativity made it pretty much certain that energy and gravity are somehow connected,
so everyone’s been searching for “okay, so what’s the logic behind that connection (what makes up the graviton)??” The Higgs idea is one attempt at that.
So,
let me explain
the Higgs field / the Higgs boson.
Put simply, the definition goes something like this.
Elementary particles originally had no mass. Then the Higgs field came into being, and elementary particles had their motion interfered with by the Higgs boson, which gave rise to something like “resistance to movement.” That’s mass.
So your understanding that “elementary particles collide with the Higgs boson and that’s how mass arises” is correct.
That said, the Higgs boson is a conceptual entity representing the quanta that make up the Higgs field, and nobody has actually seen one yet.
So researchers are working day and night to find a “Higgs boson candidate” to prove this.
Now,
tying this back to your earlier question,
“the photon has no mass”
isn’t really the most accurate way to put it. It’s more that we call “a particle with no mass” a photon. In that sense, as for its relationship with the Higgs boson too, we just call “something unaffected by the Higgs boson” a photon.
It kind of turns into a chicken-and-egg problem, haha (^^;
(Space girl) ———————————–
I see, I’m glad my understanding was right! Still, it’s all so strange…
Sorry, but one more thing —
“energy”
here, what exactly does that mean? I keep seeing the word energy come up — does it have a bunch of different meanings?
(Me) ———————————–
People say “energy” or “field,” right? I think they fundamentally mean the same thing.
Energy is potential — imagine a state where something is being stored up by some kind of action. For example, “motion” is a very easy-to-understand example of energy, but things like “height” and “heat” are energy too.
And everyone gets excited over defining “what is it that brings this about?”
Phenomena visible from the outside have already been studied pretty thoroughly… but the cause isn’t known.
So everyone ends up speculating about that “unseen source.” Sometimes calling it the Higgs boson, sometimes the graviton.
There’s still a long way to go, and that’s exactly where the romance of it all lies~.
Hitoshi Murayama, Higgs Boson: The World of Elementary Particles (Bessatsu Newton)
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2013/01/1983/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.