Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Ownership Thins Out As Group Size Grows

This article was moved here from the old blog mixture-art.net, where it was written in December 2010. The style and information remain as they were at the time.

From a management perspective, employment is unquestionably a burden and a risk. That’s why (results) / (headcount) is the ratio that, when favorable, makes an organization efficient and productive. In other words, whether each individual’s ability is actually being brought to bear matters enormously.

Even “bringing ability to bear” has several sides to it.

All of that is nothing more than a post-hoc excuse. “This job isn’t suited to me,” “the reason I’m not complaining isn’t that I have no complaints, it’s that my boss has made it hard to speak up,” “I’m the only one working overtime because the work I’ve been given is too high a level” — these are, depending on the case, simply excuses for escape.

Methods aimed at closing off an employee’s “escape routes” certainly have their use. But a company that genuinely wants to raise efficiency should be watching a different parameter.

That is

“a sense of ownership”

Anyone controlling an organization should watch this above all else. For nearly everything else, some convenient reason or excuse can usually be found.

A sense of ownership dilutes the more people there are.

So the concentration of ownership is at its highest when there is just “one person.” That is, when a person is thinking about their own affairs by themselves. Someone who can’t seriously think about their own matters even with full ownership isn’t going to seriously tackle anything at all.

Next comes “two people.” Here too the concentration of ownership stays nearly as high as with one person. A young couple thinking about marriage, for instance. If a person won’t take that seriously, it might be worth reconsidering them as a partner. That doesn’t mean such a person has no interest in you at all. Someone who can’t engage seriously in a two-person situation, where the concentration of ownership is extremely high, is, just like the one-person case, likely simply someone who “can’t think seriously about things.”

Scenes in the world where two people face a problem together are surprisingly rare, though. Most of the time, when a problem arises or a discussion is needed, more people are involved.

The concentration of ownership starts to get shaky at “three people.” “Alright, let’s meet to plan next month’s show!” Everyone gathers, but while the leader talks passionately, one person is smoking and reading manga, and another is idly plucking at a guitar. Can’t you easily picture that scene? “I was thinking we’d open with this song…” “Huh? Sure, whatever.” “Ah, do whatever you want.” This happens easily in an organization where the leader gets a bit ahead of everyone else.

But the fix for a situation like this is simple. Just give each person their own “responsibility” or “moment to shine.”

“For the second song, I was thinking Masaya could take the solo…” “Wait, seriously! If that’s the case I definitely want to do that one! That solo is really cool, right, okay?” “Okay, okay, get the recording ready by the next practice.” “Alright, yes, I’m into it now!”

“In that case, Yoshito, do you want a solo too?” “Hmm, actually I’d rather try doing vocals. Not for every song, just one would be fine.” “Oh, actually there’s a song I’m not quite confident about— with your voice it might actually fit. Practice it before we’re next in the studio.” “Oh, nice. Let’s give it a try!”

Something like that.

The concentration of ownership among “three people” can be described as a state that should naturally stay high, but risks collapsing the moment you let your guard down. Anyone who can’t manage this degree of a group well should probably give up on leading organizations. For everyone else’s sake.

Skipping ahead a bit, next is “six people.” This is said to be the limit for a group to get excited about a single topic together. Once you hit seven people, it’s easy for the group to split into four and three, with separate conversations, separate logics, separate little communities forming. That risk increases dramatically at eight people, and an eight-person organization simply won’t hold together 100% of the time without proper leadership. Everyone drifts off doing their own thing, and efficiency drops sharply.

Someone falling asleep in a six-person meeting — if it really is six people, the concentration of ownership hasn’t yet crossed the critical point. Which means this isn’t a matter of ownership anymore, it’s a matter of that person’s own character. Even in a four-person meeting, you could imagine that same person dozing off. Possibly even in a three-person meeting. Falling asleep is an extreme example, but as shown earlier, in that three-person meeting, awakening “individual opinion and sense of responsibility rooted in ownership” was an extremely easy thing to do. The same goes for a family scene with four or five people, or launching a new project. As long as the leader has a bit of organizational-management technique and attentiveness, it’s fine. It’s not that difficult, and most people suited to leadership already have this skill built in.

But once a meeting reaches seven, eight, ten people, one after another you get “people with no opinion of their own, no sense of responsibility, just sitting there listening for now.” This isn’t a matter of that person’s own character. The drop in the concentration of ownership hits regardless.

And even more alarmingly,

(number of members) − (number of people with low ownership) < 6

holds true. In other words, fewer people end up “engaging with a sense of ownership” than when the meeting had six people.

Once someone becomes aware that they’re outside “the limit for getting excited about a single topic together,” if the discussion is interesting, they’ll “listen the way you’d watch TV or radio,” and if it’s boring, they’ll sit there thinking “I’d like to change the channel but I can’t, so I’ll just put up with it.” Normally, for an interesting discussion, you should propose ways to make it even more interesting, and for a boring one, you should seriously think about how to steer it toward something interesting and throw in your opinion. But once someone has decided they’re “on the outside,” they shut off that kind of thinking entirely.

Complaining doesn’t count as participating, either. What counts is putting forward a proposal for improvement.

You’ve seen this while watching TV: “politicians really need to stand firmer on their positions,” or “they should have dragged this segment out longer, it would have landed better on TV.” This never arrives at an actual proposal for improvement. It’s just an irresponsible remark.

What kind of position, exactly? Oppose the current establishment, or go along with it? Will supporters accept it? Will it cause factional problems? If you drag it out, it affects the other segments — so which corner gets cut? Is it financially feasible? And if more sponsors are needed, where does that money come from? You’re not thinking about any of that at all, are you? “I’m not going to think about that, obviously!” is what you’d say.

This is exactly “a lack of ownership.”

Listening to a meeting the way you watch TV is exactly this. There’s no will to dig into the technical details behind it, no will to properly grasp, or even look into, the risks and returns of each option.

What brings on this psychological detachment can be discussed on an axis that is extremely discrete and sharply, unambiguously cuttable: “number of people.”

Because what can’t be done simply can’t be done.

So coming back to the perspective of running an organization: a meeting of seven or more people should be treated as nothing more than a “report or notification” session, and whenever you want to “discuss or decide” something, you should always convene six people or fewer. This is the crucial organizational technique for raising productivity.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2010/12/1977/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.