Apple Runs On 20,000 People, Sony On 200,000
This article was moved here from the old blog mixture-art.net, where it was written in October 2010. It remains as it was in style and content at the time.
The other day there was a report asking “Is Apple going to acquire Sony?” Stock prices moved and so on, but that’s just a momentary commotion. What really needs thinking about is something deeper and heavier.
*Note: I haven’t rigorously checked the numbers below, so forgive any inaccuracy.
Apple is said to run on something like 20,000 employees. I’d known this vaguely from various official and unofficial announcements, but most Apple employees work in R&D and sales/marketing, while manufacturing, quality assurance, and so on are mostly or entirely outsourced.
So I looked into things under the “B2C maker” constraint. *B2C = Business to Consumer (business where the customers are the general public)
Sony, Toshiba, Honda, Nissan — these are around 200,000 people. Toyota is 300,000. Panasonic is 400,000.
These are the so-called mega-corporations, but below them there’s a sharp gap, and then Sharp, Pioneer, Suzuki, Daihatsu and the like sit around the 40,000-50,000 range.
Sharp has announced its withdrawal from PCs, and Pioneer looks like it’s struggling too. Suzuki and Daihatsu are companies competing by specializing to some degree.
For reference, Google is under 10,000. Nintendo is 5,000.
Among the companies mixing B2C and B2B at the 50,000-person scale, one stands out. That’s Foster. They’re strong in speakers and speaker units, both their own products and OEM/ODM. *OEM = Original Equipment Manufacturer, a business that manufactures products under other companies’ brands *ODM = Original Design Manufacturer, a business that designs and manufactures products under other companies’ brands I find myself wondering: is this the right way to survive? Quietly, solidly holding onto market share. No room to grow, but a firm grip.
Someone once told me: “If you’re going to start a company, secure your B2B footing first. If you can’t do that, the risk is too high.”
“A samurai may starve, but he still holds his toothpick high” — no, a company has to be willing to do OEM work on toothpicks just to eat.
<Blame the times and you’ll get weeded out>
Overall, the small companies that are doing well look like they have more energy — or is that just my impression?
People often say this is an era where things don’t sell easily, where needs scatter, but maybe that’s really just the reality for companies operating “broadly” with “no sharp distinguishing feature.” Apple’s smartphone share is still said to be over 60%, and with the new MacBook Air, what they’re doing looks a lot more energetic compared to other makers.
I suppose “broad” and “no sharp feature” as a business model assumes you can secure solid profit on the manufacturing side and that things actually sell.
The world’s needs aren’t expanding conveniently enough for that. Toyota once pioneered advanced production optimization methods and planted the word “kaizen” firmly into the world’s vocabulary, but that’s now common knowledge, used to the point of exhaustion, so I can’t help but think there’s no more juice left in relying on manufacturing.
“No juice left” here implies you can still scrape by, of course.
In practice, OEM done well can produce dramatic cost reductions. That happens because the OEM partner brings its own channels, its own kaizen, and its own way of allocating investment and profit.
That turns into things like “taking this job keeps the relationship alive,” “we want to earn their trust,” “our production line is free so we want to fill it” — various motives that convert into money, and that’s a good thing in the sense that it advances overall optimization across the economy.
Put simply: suppose Company A and Company B are rivals making nearly identical products. Making that product naturally requires various parts, and similar products require similar parts. Buying parts in bulk is cheaper, but in this case each company buys separately, so bulk purchasing isn’t possible.
But if Company C comes in as an OEM partner and both A and B outsource to C, the cost of parts drops, so both A’s and B’s products can be made cheaper. It’s also easier for the parts maker, who can handle logistics and invoicing in one batch.
Another example: the test department. The name varies by company, but this test department is something every legitimate manufacturer has — the department that checks product operation and quality. Products get made by repeating the cycle: evaluate the prototype design has produced, point out problems, fix them. Right before a product launch is usually the busiest time, and to keep the schedule, design teams go back and forth with the test department daily. But product launch timing tends to cluster, and everyone ends up telling the test department at the same time, “Please check this by such-and-such date!” — and of all things, with a short deadline. So if you staff up to handle peak timing, during the other, slower periods that staff ends up idle and wasted. Still, failing to handle the peak is a problem too. It’s a fairly big headache. Outsourcing clears this up neatly.
These are very easy-to-understand cases. There are plenty of others, and I’d like to write about them if I get the chance later.
So OEM and the like have various advantages, but problems do come up now and then, and they’re usually tied to appearance, ease of use, or feel. These things are hard to convey in words and hard to express in numbers. So the right approach is probably to keep that part in-house, or with a trusted partner closely aligned with you. Conversely, anything where “as long as it comes out matching spec (matching the agreed numbers), that’s fine” should probably be outsourced more and more, I think.
Fail to make skillful use of that, and you’ll keep struggling in a swamp of fixed costs forever. *Fixed costs: factory upkeep, labor costs, and all the various expenses that accrue reliably day after day.
As I said earlier, this is optimization across the whole economy. Falling behind the wave of optimization means getting weeded out.
————————- Now, everything up to here has been general industry theory. So — what about your company? Continued in Vol. 2 (Assessing Your Own Company).
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2010/10/1975/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.