Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

I Try to Grasp the Pythagorean Theorem, Not Just Prove It

This piece was moved here from the old blog mixture-art.net, where it first appeared in October 2010. The writing style and the information are left as they were at the time.

“Ha ha, that’s just like Pavlov’s dog.” “Pavlov?” “If you always ring a bell when you feed a dog,  eventually the dog starts drooling just at the sound of the bell. That thing.” “Ah, right, right. A conditioned reflex.  Put it that way and it sounds simple, but being the first one to figure it out is amazing.” “Same with the first guy who ate natto. Great man.” “Exactly, exactly.” “But say nobody had proven the Pythagorean theorem yet,  and someone told you to just notice it on the spot. You couldn’t.” “Wait, remind me what Pythagoras is again?” “The three-square theorem.”

So I tried to recall the proof of the Pythagorean theorem, and ended up reflecting on how dull my own brain has gotten. It took about 10 minutes, but I got there in the end.

It seems to be the same method Pythagoras himself used first, the simplest one.

Once you see the trick, it’s simple. Let the two short sides of a right triangle be a and b, and the long side c. Then (a + b) > c, always. So if you draw a square with side (a + b), a square with side c fits neatly inside it. Draw it so the corners touch, as in the figure, and the four triangles formed outside the square of side c can all be proven congruent, using vertical angles and so on.

So the square with side (a + b) has an area equal to one square of side c plus four triangles with base a and height b. As an equation:

(a + b)^2 = c^2 + 4 x (1/2 x a x b) a^2 + 2ab + b^2 = c^2 + 2ab a^2 + b^2 = c^2 (← the Pythagorean theorem itself)

There. Done.

Meh.

Thoroughly meh.

It feels like just shuffling equations around. I can’t grasp it intuitively at all. Isn’t there a better proof? I looked around online a bit, and apparently more than 100 proofs of the Pythagorean theorem have already been proposed, but they all seem to be making a simple story harder to prove. Pointless.

Isn’t there a better proof somewhere, something even a young elementary schooler could understand? Something…

“(drying her hair after a bath) What are you doing?” “Hmm, well, the Pythagorean theorem is easy enough to prove,  but somehow it’s hard to grasp. I was wondering if there’s a proof that’s easier to picture.” “Huh. And that’s what you’re doing at 2 in the morning?” (half-surprised, half-exasperated) “Yes. I’ll brush my teeth and go to bed.”

So if I think of something, I’ll write it up in vol. 2. I might not think of anything, though.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2010/10/1974/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.