The Monty Hall Dilemma Shows Why Switching Doubles Your Odds
This article was originally written in August 2010 on my old blog, mixture-art.net, and has been moved here. The writing style and information are unchanged from that time.
The ending of the quiz show “Monty Hall,” which actually existed.
Three boxes, A, B, and C, are placed in front of the contestant, who chooses one.
One contains a luxury prize, and the other two are losers.
Once the contestant chooses C,
the host, who obviously knows which box is the winner, says,
“Are you sure about C? Then let’s open A.”
Box A is empty. A loser.
“Now here’s your chance to choose again! Which will it be, B or C?”
At this point, should the contestant switch to B, or stay with C —
which choice raises the probability of winning?
———————————————
This is said to be a problem so tricky that even Paul Erdős, the genius mathematician hailed as an authority on number theory, got it wrong. Amazing, isn’t it.
Wait, Monty Hall… isn’t that a Monty Python show..?
——————————————————–
Now, the answer.
Originally, all of the following have equal probability of occurring.
- A is correct, and he opens B
- A is correct, and he opens C
- B is correct, and he opens A
- B is correct, and he opens C
- C is correct, and he opens A
- C is correct, and he opens B
We already know A is a loser, so possibilities 1 and 2 never existed in the first place.
In other words, at the point when the boxes were arranged backstage, it was already determined that the host could only do one of 3 through 6.
Also, the contestant chose C here, so option 4 is forced to change shape.
- B is correct, so he wants to open C, but he can only open A
That’s how it goes.
The key point is not to eliminate option 4.
If you eliminate it, you end up concluding that
“at the moment the contestant chose C, even though A had not yet been opened and shown to be a loser, the probability of B being correct was already restricted to 1/5” —
and of course, nothing like that happens in reality.
This is the hardest part to grasp intuitively.
The fact that the contestant chose C has no bearing whatsoever on the probability of which box is correct.
Obviously, no matter which box the contestant chooses, the probability that B is correct has to be 2/6 = 1/3, or something is wrong. Right? Right?…
…now it’s just confusing.
Now, among the remaining options 3 through 6, there are three cases where A gets opened.
Of those, B is correct in two, 3 and 4, and C is correct in only one, 5.
So the probability that B is correct is higher.
At this point, switching the box choice to B
is more likely to be correct, in terms of probability theory —
but psychology isn’t that simple a matter, is it.
Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2010/08/1972/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.