Clay Tech

"clay-works make things real"

translated from clazytech.com

Covering the Full Back Is Key Against Physical Forwards

This piece first ran in May 2010 on the old blog mixture-art.net. The style and content are preserved as they were at the time.

The category “No Football No Life” covers football topics.

A common tactic is “just boot it long,” and it still works for teams built around a physically dominant forward. This holds true even at the level of amateur weekend football like ours, and the story doesn’t change at the top level either. The advantage of this tactic is that skipping the midfield entirely can sometimes create an easy 1-on-1 situation out of nowhere. Put a physically strong forward up there, and maybe he wins that duel once out of every three tries. That’s actually a very reasonable tactic, in my view, though it tends to get criticized on aesthetic grounds.

So how should a team respond to this kind of “powerful tactic”? (This is a constant issue even for the amateur league team I play for.) Put simply, it comes down to “preparing to lose the aerial duel.” Concretely, the popular responses are:

  1. Having the center back tuck the full back inward
  2. Covering from the defensive midfielder
  3. Introducing a sweeper system

Some of you are probably wondering: if “popular responses” already exist, why is this still always an issue? A fair question. Each of these solutions carries drawbacks as well as benefits.

Take point 1: tucking the full back inward basically means the player on the side away from the ball tucks in. The player on the ball side needs to close down the player with the ball, or at least be ready to at any moment. In practice it rarely works that cleanly. On the far side, a midfielder can pull the full back wide, or a forward can drift diagonally to confuse the full back’s positioning. And if the full back isn’t confused, can he just ignore that threat entirely? Holding the zone matters, but defending by zone contradicts the “prepare to lose the duel” principle mentioned earlier. In the end, the full back has no choice but to react, to avoid leaving anyone free.

Point 2, the defensive midfielder dropping back, simply makes it harder to transition into attack. It’s a misconception that the defensive midfielder is purely a defensive player—his main role is building attacks. Pull him into the back line for covering duty, and the team usually ends up stuck purely on the back foot after that.

As for point 3, introducing a sweeper system, that might make sense if the formation was already a back three like a 3-5-2. But in recent years formations tend to be a back four—4-4-2, 4-5-1, 4-3-2-1, and so on. The wider football world seems to agree that the appeal of full back overlaps, the single greatest strength of a back four when attacking, is too valuable to give up. Run a sweeper system with a back four, and you’re left with only one stopper against the opponent’s two forwards, so without point 1 or 2 in place, the sweeper ends up having to mark a man anyway. If it comes down to the same problem either way, it’s probably better to respond flexibly rather than fix a sweeper in place, so the advantages of the back four actually get used.

There’s no easy answer, after all. That’s the reality.

Now, this logic applies consistently whenever Japan’s national team faces the world’s top sides. Even players who look small are tough physically once they’ve been through the grind of European leagues. The same logic holds from amateur football up through the top leagues: the higher the level, the harder the contact and the faster the pressure. So does that mean Japan’s national team has no answer against the world’s elite?

If there’s one hopeful countermeasure, one way out, it’s this: don’t let them play the long ball in the first place, since that’s the root cause. What’s needed is pressing high up the pitch and pushing the defensive line up. That’s why Japan’s forwards are always required to defend selflessly, and it’s probably why Troussier drilled the offside trap so thoroughly. It likely wasn’t just a tactical fashion of the time, or a personal preference.

Still, as mentioned above, “just boot it long” is an extremely low-risk and highly effective tactic. Coming up with a clear answer to it might, in a sense, be as groundbreaking an invention as discovering a cure for cancer.


Originally published in Japanese at https://clazytech.com/2010/05/1960/. Translated with LLM assistance and reviewed before publication.